The Doctor-Patient Relationship Essay

The Doctor-Patient Relationship Essay

Length: 1489 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


The doctor-patient relationship is one of many debates and change over the years. The reason it is so debatable, is that many people have different views on what this actual relationship should be, and how certain situations may cause questions in this relationship. Such questions could be, do I really want my doctor to make decisions for me, or I know my body the best, why should I not be able to make these decisions on my own, maybe a mixture of both. Either way this subject can be debatable on how the doctors and patients should go about these relationships. There are two models, in particular, out of four that have been deemed the models that doctors and patients should go by. These two, main models are, the interpretive model and the deliberative model.
The first model is the interpretative model, which in the doctor-patient relationship, is when a doctor reveals all medical information to the patient, then helps find out the patient’s values and desire, and finally the doctor counsels the patient into making a decision based on what is medically available and what the patient has for values and desires. In the article “Four Models of the Physician-Patient Relationship”, by Ezekiel J. Emanuel, MD, PhD, and Linda L. Emanuel, MD, PhD, which is an article stating four models of the patient and doctor relationship, and it describes these models, while also debating which model is best, the authors state that this model is like the Informative model which is when a doctor gives all the information to the patient and lets them decide what is best, except the doctor assist the patient on making a decision base on their values and desires. The authors go on to state that this model is based on the fact that the patient’s values ...


... middle of paper ...


...ns that if you are leaning one way they may just tell you how they feel and go in the direction you want, not argue until you change your mind.
To summarize this all up, the doctor-patient relationship is a complicated one. Many different outcomes of a case can come from the way a doctor acts in it. To say one model is better than the other, is really based on a patient’s personal preference. I feel the deliberative model is the best model, however, just because I feel this way does not mean that someone else does not feel the interpretative model is better.



Works Cited

1How'to'Write'a'Philosophy'Essay'Handout'
2. Emanuel'and'Emanuel.'1992.'“Four'Models'of'the'PhysicianSPatient'
Relationship”'JAMA'267:'2221S2226'
3. Gawande.'2002.'“Whose'Body'Is'it,'Anyway?”'Complications:0A0Surgeon's0Notes0
on0an0Imperfect0Science'(New'York:'Henry'Holt'and'Company):'208S227''

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Doctor Patient Relationship Of China Essay

- ... The doctor need to be liable for their goods, when differences between patient and doctor cannot get approval, the dispute began to appear, and the harmonious doctor-patient relationship is broken. Recently, the medical event occurs repeatedly, like revenge of families, doctor sell expensive drugs which stolen from patients who confined on bed with a serious illness. The doctor- patient relationship in China has become more tense because there is a lack of trust between them. Patients have a hard time completely trusting doctors when they initially meet....   [tags: Medicine, Physician, Patient]

Strong Essays
780 words (2.2 pages)

Reflection On The Doctor Patient Relationship Essays

- Reflection is an important part of development and growth for all medical professionals. It gives us a chance to assess our assumptions and make active change in our behaviour towards both our patients and our team. This essay will specifically reflect on what is important in the doctor patient relationship. In order to provide direction for this reflection I chose to watch and review Patch Adams. Patch Adams is the story of Hunter Adams; a man who, upon reaching middle age, suffers from depression and considers taking his life....   [tags: Physician, Patient, Psychiatry]

Strong Essays
1053 words (3 pages)

The Doctor Patient Relationship Is An Important Connection Essay

- The doctor patient relationship is an important connection. Doctor-patient confidentiality is based on the idea that a person should not care for medical treatment because they fear the state will share with others. There are some questions a patient 's doctor must be a secret, you can not tell a third party about the problem. Another example, if a teenager says to a doctor, "I am depressed, I have been trying to kill myself" ( "Youth confidential: a young person 's right to privacy"). Doctors are not sure of information, because the doctor is this guy right help....   [tags: Physician, Medicine, Patient, Hippocratic Oath]

Strong Essays
954 words (2.7 pages)

Relationship Between Doctor And Patient Relationship Essay

- Today, we are facing a healthcare communication crisis. The relationship between doctor and patient relationship is falling apart. For patient who are not able to make decision for themselves, so they rely on their family members. This puts more stress on doctors, such that patient out number doctors and it prevents them from using their full capacity. Ways to help this cause will be by redefining healthcare to society. To redefine healthcare communication one needs to understand the doctor’s role....   [tags: Physician, Medicine, Third World, Nursing]

Strong Essays
1407 words (4 pages)

The Doctor-Patient Relationship Essay

- ... The difference that is the between both models, is how the doctor acts in the relationship. In the interpretative model, the physician or doctor is more of a counselor or advisor, where as in the deliberative model, the physician or doctor is more of a teacher or friend. Basically, in the interpretative model the doctor can only help the patient find out his or her desires and values, then help the patient make a decision based on those desire and values. The deliberative model doctor is different because he has a say when it come to the patient’s best medical values....   [tags: interpretative model, medical cases]

Strong Essays
1489 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Why I Am A Doctor

- MY BELIEVES I believe that since birth we have a destiny and a destination. Sometimes even before we can rationalize our thoughts, our heart already knows what we want. At the end, our feelings will push us one step closer to accomplishing our goals. My life has been undoubtedly a mirror of my thoughts. WHY A DOCTOR As a frequently ill child, I spent most of my childhood visiting doctors and being torture by needless and medicines. Not being satisfied, my playful curiosity led me to burn the soil of my foot....   [tags: Physician, Medicine, Doctor-patient relationship]

Strong Essays
995 words (2.8 pages)

Essay Going through the Past

- History taking induces connections to the patient’s past problems to his or her reasoning for visiting the doctor today. During history taking, two different things are occurring: the doctor attempts to shape and validate the patient’s visit while the patient discusses his or her medical problem. As seen in the “Sore Shoulder” clip, history taking highlights the patient telling her doctor of her past medical issues with bursitis. Simultaneously, the doctor, in the clip, tries counteracting the patient’s prediction of having bursitis with an acute problem....   [tags: Health, Doctor-patient Relationship]

Strong Essays
1706 words (4.9 pages)

Essay on Personal Statement : Peer Health Exchange

- Peer Health Exchange Traveling to different high schools, I discussed abusive relationships with students.It was my job to create a safe and comfortable learning environment while talking about these sensitive issues.It became very clear that many of the students did not understand the topics we discussed. Seeing this lack of knowledge,it demonstrated to me the need for more emphasis on educating the public on their health and well-being.After my class,these students could identify these relationships and where to turn when in one .This experience showed me how educating preventative information to people is not only important,but personally rewarding.I do not have a contact, since it was fr...   [tags: Patient, Physician, Doctor-patient relationship]

Strong Essays
1691 words (4.8 pages)

The Relationship between Doctor and Patient Should be Platonic Essay

- ... When it comes to physicians in the work place they should always display a level of professionalism in any and every situation. For example, a sexual relationship between a patient and a physician is totally unacceptable. Whether it is in the office or on social networks a physician is always held up to a higher standard just because of who they are. Dr. Jain of NEJM writes that, “In confirming this patient as my “friend” on Facebook, I was merging my professional and personal lives. From my Facebook page, Ms....   [tags: love and medicine]

Strong Essays
1135 words (3.2 pages)

The Relationship Between a Doctor and His Patient Essay

- The Relationship Between a Doctor and His Patient Doctors are bound by a code of conduct. The code of conduct includes appropriate behaviour when dealing with patients who are under their care. In this Eastenders story, the local GP approaches a young patient of his to attend a medical dinner with him. The reason he gives is that he has been turned down by a medical colleague and wants to make her jealous by taking another attractive young woman. The GP's approach is very attractive to the young patient Zoe, because she is very impressed with the GP, his intelligence, lifestyle and the opportunity to attend a exclusive event with an attractive older man makes it...   [tags: Free Essays]

Free Essays
422 words (1.2 pages)