Do Copyright Laws Stifle Creativity?

Do Copyright Laws Stifle Creativity?

Length: 936 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
a) Cite your selection in MLA style.
Lessig, Lawrence. "Do Copyright Laws Stifle Creativity?" Online video clip.
YouTube. YouTube, 12 Mar. 2009. Web. 11 Feb. 2014.

b) What is the central message of this text? Please explain it in your own words.
The central message of this text is that increasingly, outdated copyright laws are being manipulated and put to use in a ludicrous manner. This is resulting in the suppression of people’s ability to generate and share their own creative expressions.

c) How would you define your position as an audience member (resistant, neutral, etc.)? With your own position in mind, what kind of audience do you think the author is trying to reach? Please provide an example to support your answer.
As an audience member I am sympathetic. This is a subject of which I had some prior knowledge on before watching the video and had already formulated my opinion. I believe the author, Lawrence Lessig, is trying to reach a neutral audience. After showing multiple videos in which different types of creative expression are shown, Lessig branches off into the topic of copyright laws. He introduces this topic as something new when he states, “So much is not new, there is something that is new.” This implies that the audience would not already be aware of the type of occurrences being discussed and therefor they would not have already formed an opinion making them neutral.

d) What appeal(s) are being used in this text (ethos, etc.)? Give a specific example from the text to support your answer.
The two appeals used are pathos and ethos. An example of pathos is seen in the first case mentioned by Lawrence Lessig on copyright misuse. This case is about a mother recording her young child dancing and finding out after sharing the video over YouTube that the owner of the music’s rights was demanding it be removed. When questioning the behavior of the people who are taking advantage of these laws, Lessig’s tone of voice changes and he even becomes sarcastic referring to the actions of this mother as an “extraordinary abuse”. As well the appeal ethos is used. Although the author does not verbally provide background information on himself as an authority on the subject, he presents himself with great confidence and assuredness in the topic.

e) Did you find the argument persuasive? Why or why not? If you were in charge of editing this example, what would you change?

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Do Copyright Laws Stifle Creativity?." 25 Jan 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Ethical And Moral Stand Points Essay

- RATIONALE What is your opinion on downloading material from the internet which could include copyrighted material. What are your ethical and moral stand points. Use the Kim Dot Com court case as your guide. The Ethical and Moral Stand Points for Downloading Copyright Material Gillian Ellison Southern Institute of Technology – Invercargill Campus | Rationale | Title | Authors and Affiliation | Abstract | Context | Arguments For | Arguments Against | Discussion | Acknowledgments| Literature Cited | Appendices ABSTRACT It is easy to find valid arguments for both sides of the debate around downloading copyright material, but much harder to decide which side wins....   [tags: Copyright, Copyright infringement]

Research Papers
1087 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Copyright Laws And Intellectual Property

- Copyright, Piracy, Intellectual Property and Professional Code of Ethics 2 Copyright, piracy, intellectual property and professional codes of ethics are critical subjects for computer and business professionals. This paper will first explain copyright laws and intellectual property. Second, an explanation concerning piracy will be submitted. Finally, a description of my own professional code of ethics will be presented. Copyright Laws and Intellectual Property Copyright laws help protect intellectual property....   [tags: Copyright, Intellectual property]

Research Papers
1334 words (3.8 pages)

Copyright Laws Are A Form Of Governance Essay

- Copyright laws are a form of governance designed to protect the intellectual property of authors, inventors, and other individuals creating innovations or inventions. Intellectual property consists of published and unpublished books, manuscripts, paintings, music works, sound recordings, movies, choreographic works, architectural works, sculptures, and even pantomime works among others (Copyright Works, 2012). The World Intellectual Property Organization states that: "Intellectual property (IP) refers to creations of the mind, such as inventions; literary and artistic works; designs; and symbols, names and images used in commerce" (What is Intellectual, n.d.)....   [tags: Copyright, Property, United States copyright law]

Research Papers
1050 words (3 pages)

Essay on Copyright Laws Of Argentina- ( Liz Marroquin )

- Copyright Laws of Argentina-(Liz Marroquin) Argentina 's first copyright law was created all the way back in 1933. Today section 2 of this law gives copyright owners almost complete control over there work. After 70 years copyrighted work falls into public domain and Argentina is one of the few countries left to enforce a tax to users who wish to use works in public domain. The tax is a pretty big issue there and and back in 2012 the government tried to pass a bill where public libraries, archives, and museums would be exempt from the tax but were sadly met with strong opposition from collecting agencies and was not passed....   [tags: Copyright, Copyright infringement]

Research Papers
2443 words (7 pages)

Copyright Laws Today 's Business World Essay examples

- Copyright laws in today’s business world In our great world today, there is a big competition and copyrights are getting more concern, getting more and more attention business world today. Copyrighting is a property strictly defines the way for which it can be used A copyright owner has to get right to permit or allow a specific usage of own work. In today business world, when a company wants its own property to present the public, they have to make sure that their copyright confidential must protect, and the requirement of all- copyright must meet....   [tags: Copyright, Intellectual property, Property]

Research Papers
816 words (2.3 pages)

Features Of Copyright Laws That Affect Researching Information Essay

- 2.1 Two Key features of copyright laws that affect researching information Details of copyright law vary between nation countries, however, many nations share a common interest through two international copyright treaty membership agreements, the Berne Convention (which consists of 164 member states) and the Buenos Aires Convention (which is an agreement between North and South American countries,) The treaties, established in order to protect an authors’/creators’ original work from copying - whether it be literary, dramatic, design, musical or artistic....   [tags: Copyright, Copyright infringement, Fair use]

Research Papers
722 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on The Copyright Office

- Article1, Section8, Clause8 of the constitution gives congress the power to make laws: to promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited time to authors and inventors exclusive right to respective writings and discoveries (U.S. Copyright Office). Formerly, claims were registered by clerks of U.S. district courts, however in today’s time the Copyright office is a separate department of the library of congress. The mission of the Copyright Office is to promote creativity by administering and sustaining an effective national copyright system and since 1870; the Copyright Office has registered more than 33,654,000 claims to copyright and mask works (U.S....   [tags: File sharing, Copyright, Copyright infringement]

Research Papers
1075 words (3.1 pages)

Issues on Patent and Copyright Laws In China Essay

- Issues on Patent and Copyright Laws In China This site contains information on China's patent and copyright law. It goes on to discuss some ethical issues about China's lack of law enforcement on intellectual property protection. History of Patent System China’s patent system can be traced back to the late Qing Dynasty when China began signing international treaties. For example, on August 18, 1903, China and the United States agreed on a treaty on navigation and commerce. The treaty provided for a “reciprocal patent-granting arrangement whereby citizens of one contracting party could apply for and secure patent rights for their inventions in the other contracting party.”1 After the...   [tags: China Patent Copyright Essays]

Research Papers
2384 words (6.8 pages)

Essay about Piracy Of Copyright

- Piracy Of Copyright Introduction: The world today has entered into an era of instant communication. A person sitting in the remotest corner of India can enjoy live performance taking place in the far away places like America or Africa, thanks to electronic (parallel) media. Telephone and fax have made it possible to communicate oral or written messages across the globe within seconds. The computer-aided communication technologies such as E-Mail and Internet have added altogether a new dimension to today's communication process by making it more speedy, informative and economical....   [tags: Copyright Laws Piracy]

Research Papers
1090 words (3.1 pages)

Music Copyright Essay

- What is a Copyright. Music Copyright is a very important aspect of the music industry. The Copyright law was established to preserve the creativity and rights of authors, composers, performers of expression. Copyright is the law that protects the property rights of the creator of an original work in a fixed tangible medium. ( A fixed tangible medium is something substantial like copying lyrics on paper or putting a song on tape or CD. Copyright can be seen every where in the music industry....   [tags: Copyright Laws Music Industry Essays]

Research Papers
1626 words (4.6 pages)

What would you keep the same?

Although I am in agreement with the general topic, I did not find the argument to be particularly persuasive due to the lack of factual evidence shared. The first few minutes of the presentation showed numerous videos in which people were not being suppressed in any fashion for using an artist’s material without direct consent. Lawrence Lessig makes reference to these videos mentioning that there are “literally scores of these on YouTube”. By following this statement with only two examples in which copyright laws were misused, it gives the impression that the two incidences are not the normative and that this is not an issue the average person should be concerned with. If I was editing this, I would drastically reduce the number of videos shown in the beginning and increase the number of cases shown of people being negatively impacted by the abuse of these laws. As well, I would include information regarding the legal ramifications of using a person’s copyrighted material without consent and evidence showing how common these cases are.

a) Cite your selection in MLA style.
Carr, Nicholas. "How the Internet Is Making Us Stupid." The Telegraph.
Telegraph Media Group Limited, 27 Aug. 2010. Web. 12 Feb. 2014.

b) What is the central message of this text? Please explain it in your own words.
The central message is that the overabundance of stimulation people are continuously receiving when using the internet is having negative effect over their ability to focus and process information.
c) How would you define your position as an audience member (resistant, neutral, etc.)? With your own position in mind, what kind of audience do you think the author is trying to reach? Please provide an example to support your answer.
I would define my position as resistant. I believe the author, Nicholas Carr, is trying to reach a sympathetic audience. In the article, Carr includes statements from multiple sources and references numerous studies that have been performed regarding the impact the internet on the human mind. One example mentioned is the experiment where during a lecture, half a class is permitted to use laptops connected to the internet and the other is not. The findings of this test were that those who went online performed much worse when tested on how well they retained the lectures content. Among all of the tests Carr mentions and statements, the focus remains solely on information that is in support of his opinion. There is no diversity or potential for common ground with no mention made of any studies with findings that are opposing to Carr’s.

d) What appeal(s) are being used in this text (ethos, etc.)? Give a specific example from the text to support your answer.
The appeals used are ethos and logos. The author makes his authority and knowledge on the subject known almost immediately stating “I’ve been studying this research for the past three years, in the course of writing my new book The Shallows: How the Internet Is Changing the Way We Think, Read and Remember.”

e) Did you find the argument persuasive? Why or why not? If you were in charge of editing this example, what would you change? What would you keep the same?

I found the argument to be somewhat persuasive. Primarily it was the mention of multiple studies and sources that I found to be swaying. However, the article ultimately came across more as though Carr was trying to increase sales of his book then he was interested in increasing awareness on matter he was truly concerned with. If I was editing this I would include more comparative studies and utilize actual testing results. Showing numbers and hard facts would provide stronger support and persuade more readers. I would also remove the usage of word stupid from the title and avoid similar terms in the rest of the article. I believe that using this word only increases the number of people that are going to be resistant. By beginning an article with a word like stupid, it gives increased potential that the reader will perceive the article as personally insulting before they even make it past the title.

Return to