Disney's Inaccurate Portrayal of Mulan and Pocahontas Essay

Disney's Inaccurate Portrayal of Mulan and Pocahontas Essay

Length: 913 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Many times, things are not what they seem. Deception is often used to publicize things in a different light and it distorts actual historical content and facts. One example of this is when Disney inaccurately portrays the actual life of historical characters such as Mulan and Pocahontas.
In the movie Mulan, based on the “Ballad of Mulan,” Disney inaccurately portrays her life causing many incongruities. In the movie, Mulan is portrayed as being weak and unskilled with weapons and horsemanship. The “real” Mulan, however, was said to have practiced with many weapons and warfare methods. As an article in The Epoch Times stated,” Mulan’s father…raised Mulan like a boy. She....practiced martial arts, archery, and fencing with her father….liked to read her father’s manuals on military strategy.” This would show that contrary to the Disney version, which depicts a young Mulan as being hopeless and weak, she was actually a fierce warrior who could carry herself into battle. In addition, the real Mulan also rode horses and shot arrows, differing from the incompetent Mulan that is depicted in the “We Are Men” scene of the movie. While Disney portrays Mulan as being unskilled and inadequate upon her entrance to camp, the actual Mulan was extremely adept to the art of war and extremely capable of holding her ground.
Another way that Disney inaccurately portrays Mulan is by saying that she was the only child in her family. When Mulan’s father is asked to enlist, Disney shows that Mulan is outraged by the idea, knowing that her father will indeed die in vain this time, and as his only child she must make this sacrifice for her father. However, while Mulan did make this sacrifice to save her father, Mulan did indeed have an...

... middle of paper ...

...to many important historical, taking their original stories and manipulating it into a crowd pleasing versions. This shows that Disney inaccurately portrays the actual life of historical characters, such as Mulan and Pocahontas. Yet while most people commonly know the inaccurate versions of these characters, the real story is worth learning.

Works Cited

Custalow, Linwood, and Angela L. Daniel. The True Story of Pocahontas: The Other Side of
History. Golden, CO: Fulcrum Pub., 2007. Print.
Shen, Teresa, and Gisela Sommer. "The Legend of Mulan." The Epoch Times 31 Aug. 2011: n.
pag. The Epoch Times. Web. 21 Nov. 2013.
Mossiker, Frances. Pocahontas: The Life and the Legend. New York: Knopf, 1976. Print.
Rountree, Helen C. Pocahontas Powhatan Opechancanough: Three Indian Lives Changed by
Jamestown. Charlottesville: University of Virginia, 2005. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Insensitive Portrayal of Society and Cultuer in Disney Films Essay

- The Not So Wonderful World of Disney The “Wonderful World of Disney” has been a part of America for as long as I can remember. With its movies, television shows, songs, theme parks, toys, and fictional characters, Disney is the epitome of children’s entertainment. Disney serves as one of the largest sources of entertainment to Americans, which is why it reigns as a commercial success and influence in our country. According to Henry Giroux, a popular critic of the Walt Disney Company, Disney’s immense success also represents “the power of the culture industries to mediate and influence almost every aspect of our lives” (19)....   [tags: Walt Disney Film Cinema Movies]

Better Essays
1523 words (4.4 pages)

Gender Role Portrayal And The Disney Princesses Essay

- Children were running around inspecting the entire store while their parents watched over them in hopes they wouldn't break anything too expensive. In all this confusion, I had lost sight of my younger sister who was now busy looking at the collection of princess dolls, with a few other girls. As I made my way towards my sister, I couldn't help but notice that many of the dolls had been glamorized and put into extravagant dresses, emphasizing their princess status. Mulan no longer had short hair or armor but long flowing hair, dressed in a traditional Geisha dress completely dismantling her warrior status, emphasizing her feminine qualities instead....   [tags: Gender Role Essays]

Better Essays
1649 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on How Do Gender Roles Get Portrayed in Disney Films?

- ... A woman cleaning and cooking for a man is now a common-day stereotype/objectification of women. A phrase used a lot by men now-a-days is, “Women belong in a kitchen.” The author believes women lessening themselves for men are both the universal and overall message the movie is sending out. B. “Gender Roll Portrayal and the Disney Princesses” By Dawn England, Lara Descartes, Melissa Collier-Meek This article talks about a study done on all Disney movies and the coding of the male and feminine characteristics of Princesses and Princes....   [tags: princesses, article, interpret]

Better Essays
704 words (2 pages)

The Changes in Gender Roles Portrayed in Disney Princess Films Over Time

- According to the Kaiser Family Foundation Report (1999), children spend an average of 2.5 to 3 hours on watching television per day. As van der Voort and Walma van der Molen (2000) noted, children learn most readily from visually presented materials, such as videos and films. As a result, mass media has a great influence on children’s development. As noted by Swindler (1986), the contribution of media exposure to the cultivation of children’s values, beliefs, dreams, and expectations cannot be overstated....   [tags: children, stereotypes, helplessness]

Better Essays
1028 words (2.9 pages)

Media and the Antifeminist Agenda Essays

- ... Merida’s coming of age brings forth the inevitable adult duties that she must assume as a woman. Through the context of the film, marriage is a tradition, intended to keep the peace among clans with a history of warfare, and therefore its Merida’s duty to maintain amity among these groups; a theme that is not at all to different from modern day society, were marriage is used as means to build bridges or insure economic/financial stability. “A princess doesn’t raise her voice; she is cautious, clean” and above all, strives for perfection.” (Brave....   [tags: media, cinemias, pixar, disney]

Better Essays
813 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about From Delicate Damsels to Strong Self-Starters

- ... “Ariel . . . stood out amongst the carbon-copy princesses thanks to a head of red hair and a feisty attitude, but unlike her predecessors she went after a prince instead of waiting for him to save her” (Salt, 1). Disney’s next princess, Belle, from “Beauty and the Beast”, released in 1991, shares many qualities with Ariel. A powerful man, Gaston, always tries to win over Belle’s love. However, Belle holds her own strong opinions and refuses to let another individual force her to do something, as an earlier princess would....   [tags: Walt Disney, image, princesses, idols, role models]

Better Essays
980 words (2.8 pages)

Disney Change And Left Out Historical Events From The Original History Of Pocahontas

- Research Paper: Why did Disney change and left out historical events from the original history of Pocahontas. Back in the days 1607 was the time where Natives of American had their own land and freedom. Coming to the contribution of the film of Pocahontas with the cons and pros. The history will continue and a famous figure should always be honored. Disney is leaving out and changing out the most important events from this historical figure that represents the Native Americans her name is Pocahontas....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States, Pocahontas]

Better Essays
958 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about Pocahontas and the Mythical Indian Woman

- Pocahontas and the Mythical Indian Woman Pocahontas. Americans know her as the beautiful, Indian woman who fell in love with the white settler John Smith and then threw her body upon the poor white captive to protect him from being brutally executed by her own savage tribe. The magical world of Walt Disney came out with their own movie version several years ago portraying Pocahontas as a tan, sexy Barbie doll figure and John Smith as a blond-haired, blue-eyed muscular Ken doll. Although Disney attempts to instill racial tolerance, inter-racial friendship, and nonviolent resolutions in Pocahontas, they contribute to the inaccurate Indian woman stereotype that has evolved from such stories....   [tags: Disney Argumentative Portrayal Essays]

Better Essays
5417 words (15.5 pages)

Disney's Whitewashing of Pocahontas Essay

- In 1995, Disney produced a romanticized version of relationships between early Native Americans and Europeans in the film, Pocahontas. It is controversial whether this movie was intended to enlighten children about the beginning of America in a story-like manner, or a way to conceal a dark past and brainwash future generations with this illusion of a happy beginning to the United States of America. In order to make the Pocahontas and John Smith love myth suitable for children, it is understandable that Disney needed to alter the story....   [tags: Movie, Film 2014]

Better Essays
2644 words (7.6 pages)

Pocahontas Essay

- Pocahontas Introduction [1] Disney’s Pocahontas has understandably received a lot of flak about the historically inaccurate story that is told about the legendary Pocahontas and Captain John Smith. There is a good reason for that. The movie does little that can be construed as historically accurate, yet Disney claims that was never their intent. Disney, in their previous movies, has been attacked for being racist and unsympathetic to racial minorities. Their answer was a movie whose sole purpose, as stated by Disney, was to promote racial tolerance....   [tags: History Native Americans]

Better Essays
2786 words (8 pages)