Disagreement, Question-Begging, and Epistemic Self-Criticism by David Christensen

Disagreement, Question-Begging, and Epistemic Self-Criticism by David Christensen

Length: 882 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


In the face of disagreement with an epistemic peer, David Christensen argues for the conciliatory response he calls Independence, in his paper Disagreement, Question-Begging, and Epistemic Self-Criticism. I will first explain Christensen’s Independence Principle about conciliation. I will then present his argument for how it avoids counterintuitive results in cases of super-high confidence and cases of disagreement over basic cognitive resources. I will argue that Christensen’s Independence Principle cannot avoid counterintuitive results without asserting a contradiction. I will specifically focus on his “cognitively altering pill case” to show that, with respect to the Independence Principle, the perception of one’s self is sometimes more reliable than the perception of one’s opponent. Yet at other times perception of one’s opponent is more reliable than perception of one’s self. If this is the case, then I will show that there is no asymmetry in special cases, and so the Independence Principle fails to avoid counterintuitive results in special disagreements.
Like Thomas Kelly, Christensen defines epistemic peers as being both equally familiar with the evidence and questions surrounding the argument, and equals with respect to epistemic virtues such as intelligence (1). Conciliatory views argue that the correct response to a disagreement with a peer is to revise one’s argument and lower confidence where necessary (1). Christensen’s argument for his conciliatory view develops with his examination of the significance of accommodating, either yourself or your opponent making a cognitive error, as rational evidence (1). He argues that the correct response to disagreement is to take a third person view of both yours and your opponen...


... middle of paper ...


... is still your peer, and that they disagree with you about everything, it seems wrong to rely on your intuition about your psychological report only because they disagree with you about many things. Indeed, it seems wrong to claim that in special cases we should suddenly accept agent-specific evidence as epistemically rational, just because if we did not we would end up in skepticism. The symmetry is not broken in the disagreement, we are unable to keep confidence in our positions, unable to regard agent-specific evidence as epistemically rational, and unable to avoid skepticism. Therefore, in super-high confidence cases, or disagreement over basic cognitive resources, Independence fails to avoid counterintuitive results.




Works Cited

(1) Christensen, David. "Disagreement, Question-Begging, and Epistemic Self-Criticism." Philosophers' Imprint 11.6 (2011): 1-18.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Perspective and the Right Reasons View in Solving Epistemic Disagreements.

- In “The Epistemic Significance of Disagreement”, Thomas Kelly gives two responses to the question “How should awareness of disagreement, with those that you take to be your epistemic equal, effect the rational confidence you have in your beliefs?”. Kelly discusses two possible responses to the question. The first is Richard Foley's first person perspective argument. Adam Elga calls the second the right reasons view (Elga, 2007 pg. 485). Kelly pursues the latter, and does not go further than agreeing with Foley that we should only view these disputes with a first person perspective....   [tags: reflection, disagreement]

Better Essays
1024 words (2.9 pages)

Should Begging Be Legal For A Public Place? Essays

- Begging is the solicitation of money or food, usually in a public place, with little or nothing given in return. There are different kinds of begging: primary where the need is fundamental that needs fulfilled immediately. Secondary satisfies an essential but not vital need and tertiary satisfies a need that is not vital. It is important to define these before evaluating which, or if any should be criminalised. Currently in Scotland begging is legal under the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 However in England and Wales begging remains illegal under the 1824 Act....   [tags: Begging, Homelessness, Crime, Poverty]

Better Essays
1001 words (2.9 pages)

A Summary of Epistemic Relativism Essay

- What if everything that you perceive— people, the world, the universe — was not as it seems. Relativism is the concept that points of view have no absolute truth or validity, having only relative, subjective value according to differences in perception and consideration. Defined narrowly, epistemology is the study of knowledge and justified belief. As the study of knowledge, epistemology is concerned with the following questions: What are the necessary and sufficient conditions of knowledge. What are its sources....   [tags: truth, falsehood, persepective]

Better Essays
950 words (2.7 pages)

Solving Disagreements in Teams Essay

- The work place, social organizations, educational institutes, and community groups all use teams to accomplish projects and goals. The environment of teams determine if these projects and goals will be met in an efficient manner. As businesses and organizations continue to restructure work teams, the need for training in disagreement resolution will grow. Does disagreement arise from team player differences. When individuals come together in teams, do their differences in terms of power, values, and attitudes contribute to the creation of disagreements?As team players, are individuals able to state their opinions, introduce their ideas, listen to other ideas with an open mind, respect, and...   [tags: disagreements, examiners]

Better Essays
2061 words (5.9 pages)

Essay about True Epistemic Value of Religious Experiences

- True Epistemic Value of Religious Experiences For many years, the idea of what it means to have a “religious experience” has been greatly debated. Philosophers and great thinkers alike have grappled with many questions, such as what constituted a “religious experience” and the difference between that and a mystical experience. Part of this great debate involves two philosophers from a similar time period, William James and C.D Broad, who each saw these experiences, despite some similarities, as having different epistemic values....   [tags: Religious Experiences, Philosophy]

Better Essays
1659 words (4.7 pages)

India and Pakistan: Dissent vs. Disagreement Essay

- Tensions between India and Pakistan, which have been increasing in recent years, are reaching an all-time high as nuclear technologies in both countries threaten safety and provide potential for direct nuclear war. For now, India and Pakistan are in a disagreement – but as time progresses, and their discord transforms into dissension, citizens are put at risk as both nations currently have the technology to utilize weapons of mass destruction. For now, the people are safe. But once this conflict reaches new heights and diminutive disagreements turn into dangerous dissent, devastation is inevitable....   [tags: Argumentative, Persuasive]

Better Essays
887 words (2.5 pages)

Begging in America Essay example

- When we observe the enormous progress America has made from the beginning of the thirteen colonies to what it is today, we clearly see that society has grown tremendously in its advancements in communication, speed, and travel, etc., but have we unknowingly degenerated in our culture and values. Mark Sundeen says “Begging may be the most shameful act in America.” But why is that so. If we take a look at religions such as Hinduism and Buddhism, giving alms to the poor is thought as “… increasing the chances [of being] admitted into paradise or reincarnated in a good body…” (McMahon)....   [tags: panhandling, homelessness, money]

Better Essays
874 words (2.5 pages)

WVO Quine's Epistemic Paradigm Essay

- WVO Quine's Epistemic Paradigm Since its publication in 1969, Quine's seminal essay entitled Epistemology Naturalized has had a polarizing effect on pursuits in this field. Many have rejected the naturalist approach to epistemology on the grounds that it is mere relativism (see below), while others have celebrated Quine's program for articulating an empirical approach to epistemology. In what follows, I will endeavour to provide a clean explanation of some of the central features of Quine's naturalism and point out what I believe are the strengths and weaknesses of these features and, I will offer a brief account of why I believe Quine's naturalism to be an exemplary approach to clarifying...   [tags: Naturalized Epistemology]

Free Essays
3203 words (9.2 pages)

Coherence and Epistemic Rationality Essay

- Coherence and Epistemic Rationality This paper addresses the question of whether probabilistic coherence is a requirement of rationality. The concept of probabilistic coherence is examined and compared with the familiar notion of consistency for simple beliefs. Several reasons are given for thinking rationality does not require coherence. Finally, it is argued that incoherence does not necessarily involve fallacious reasoning. Most work in epistemology treats epistemic attitudes as bivalent. It is assumed that a person either believes that there is an apple on the table, or that there is not, and that such beliefs must be either warranted or unwarranted....   [tags: Mathematics Science Theories Papers]

Free Essays
3366 words (9.6 pages)

Essay on Robert Frost's Love and a Question

- Robert Frost's Love and a Question Robert Frost's poetry has a confortable and familiar nature at first glance, but this author is known for dealing with human tragedies and fears often in a symbolic manner. He uses poetry to express his reaction to the complexities of life and his acceptance of his burdens. Although his work is rooted in New England region, he is a far reaching poet who's work spans metaphysical and psychological topics. One can often notice these under the surface of minute details that are characteristic of most of his work....   [tags: Love and a Question]

Free Essays
554 words (1.6 pages)