Disability By Nancy Mair 's Disability, And Matthew Soyster 's `` Living Under Circe 's Spell ``

Disability By Nancy Mair 's Disability, And Matthew Soyster 's `` Living Under Circe 's Spell ``

Length: 1033 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Nancy Mair 's "Disability" and Matthew Soyster 's " Living under Circe 's Spell" the authors give the reader a firsthand opinion and experience on what it is like being disabled. In Mair 's opinion, disabled people should be viewed as normal people. In contrast, Soyster does not view his disability as normal,but instead as something that is ruining his life and independence. Through their essays they give their personal opinions on their lives as cripples, but their aims in discussing the topic differs. Mair 's finds her disability to make her who she is and has grown to accept it. She uses figurative language such as description, diction, and allusions to disclose her forbearance of MS. In contrast, Soyster believes that his disability is dwindles down his worth and purpose. Mair and Soyester both use language, tone, and rhetorical strategies to convey these message, but their intended audience diverges.
In"Disability", Mairs describes the media 's depiction of disability versus her firsthand experiences as a woman with multiple sclerosis. She believes that disabled people should be treated the same as able bodied people; since disabled people perform the same everyday task as others, besides modify some of them to accommodate their situation. She is in search of an accurate depiction of disabled people " For months now I 've been consciously searching for representation of myself in the media, especially television." (Mair 1). When she finally finds a



Ukpaby 2

show with a women similar to her on it, the women is portrayed as a damsel in distress and chooses dependence on people over independence. This allows her to support her allusion about the media 's false representation of the disabled community.
In Mairs op...


... middle of paper ...


...ince his
Ukpaby 4
audience,of people can relate to his bitterness, and logos- when he speaks on the difference between able bodied and disabled people. Soyester wants his audience to see the uncut, graphic truth about his experience being disabled. He also wants his audience to understand his perspective of being disabled.

Though both Mairs and Soyster recollect on how MS has affected their lives, their aims are different. Mairs aims to apprise her audience on the reality of being disabled . Mair does not view disabilities as belittling, but instead as empowering. Through her experiences she has been able to appreciate different aspects of her life, as well as value her disability since it helps shape her. In antithesis, Soyster 's aim is to recollect specifically on how MS has changed him negatively and how he is still unable to accept his condition.



Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Living with Disability Essay

- Disability is an topic that has produced conflict, and is viewed very differently from either side. For able-bodied people to truly understand what disabled people go through they need to see disabled people more; see their lives. If seeing disabled people more often became reality, they would be viewed as normal more, and it would make interacting easier for both sides. Disabled people have a hard life, but it does not mean it is not worth living. Nancy Mairs, Andre Dubus, and Harriet McBryde Johnson all have physical disabilities, and have written about their experiences and views....   [tags: A Disabled Perspective]

Better Essays
1645 words (4.7 pages)

Is Deafness a Disability or a Way of Living? Essays

- Two centuries ago, the Deaf community arose in American society as a linguistic minority. Members of this community share a particular human condition, hearing impairment. However, the use of American Sign Language, as their main means of communicating, and attendance to a residential school for people with deafness also determine their entry to this micro-culture. Despite the fact that Deaf activists argue that their community is essentially an ethnic group, Deaf culture is certainly different from any other cultures in the United States....   [tags: Deaf Community, American Society]

Better Essays
1579 words (4.5 pages)

Disability And Disability Of Disability Essay

- 19% of the US population has a disability, which is about 1 in 5 people. 15% of the world’s population has a form of disability. The event focused on diversity and it was presented by Lloyd Shelton who is a case worker at the Eastern Michigan University Disability Resource Center. He has spinal muscular atrophy. The presentation was on November 17, 2016, at 6:30 pm in 201 Pray-Harrold. Disability can be defined as a person having a physical or mental condition that hampers that person to function at a normal level....   [tags: Disability, Wheelchair]

Better Essays
724 words (2.1 pages)

Disability Of Disability And Disability Essay

- Going into Intro Disability Studies, I honestly thought I already knew all I needed to know on the topic of disability. When asked to define disability I was uncommonly confident in this answer, “A disability is some kind of mental or physical ailment that prevents a person from being able to think, move , or do an activity that is essential for life. This condition would put the person who has it at a disadvantage in some way shape or form.” I quickly learned that I wasn’t necessarily wrong but I was missing a lot of important pieces because I was only thinking of disability in two terms physical and mental.Throughout this course I learned a vast number of ways to look at disability such a...   [tags: Disability, Mental disorder]

Better Essays
1301 words (3.7 pages)

Living with a Disability Essay examples

- On many occasions teachers have asked, "Is the volume high enough for you?" while my class watches a television documentary. Many teachers in middle school imposed strict rules about where in the classroom I could sit. I've had coaches ask if I know sign language. And during my elementary years, the school insisted I meet with a learning specialist once a week to discuss my "feelings" about being hearing-impaired. All these restrictions were placed on me despite the fact that I was an above-average student and an aggressive athlete....   [tags: Personal Narrative, essay about myself]

Better Essays
570 words (1.6 pages)

The Problem Of Developmental Disability Essay

- Developmental disability is a phrase that people often associate with negative feelings. “Developmental disabilities are a group of conditions due to an impairment in physical, learning, language, or behavior areas. About one in six children in the U.S. have one or more developmental disabilities or other developmental delays (CDC, 2015).” When people are born into a family, having some type of developmental disability, it is often just as difficult for the parents, as it is the child. In today’s society we have more resources and knowledge about disabilities, but it has not always been this way....   [tags: Disability, Developmental disability]

Better Essays
1287 words (3.7 pages)

The Gospel Of Matthew Is The Most Important Essay

- The Gospel of Matthew is the most Jewish gospel in the New Testament. It is placed first in the New Testament because people find it to be the most helpful. It is the second written Gospel. This Gospel maintains the hope in Parousia, the final coming of Jesus Christ. This Gospel also presents a great concern: the mission of the Church to all nations is to preach the Gospel of the Kingdom. Jesus is presented as the new Moses in the Gospel of Matthew, who prophetically challenged his listeners to live the radical demands of beatitudinal living....   [tags: New Testament, Jesus, Gospel of Matthew, Gospel]

Better Essays
715 words (2 pages)

Community Living Toronto and Intellectual Disability Essay

- Community Living Toronto is an organization that took place in 1948 to provide support for adults, youth, children and families with an intellectual disability by giving this group an accessible ways to fit into the community they live in. The agency’s mission is to “change the lives of people with an intellectual disability by giving them a voice and supporting their choices where they live, learn, work and play” (Community living Toronto, 2011). The program focuses on connecting individuals who has an intellectual disability in recognizing their “work, volunteer, leisure and recreational interests and goals” (Community living Toronto, 2011)....   [tags: Social Issues]

Better Essays
1062 words (3 pages)

The National Disability Insurance Scheme Essay

- Those living with Disability in Australia and around the world, are faced everyday with challenges that they are to overcome in order to achieve full occupational participation. From an Australian Perspective, those living with a disability are now empowered by the NDIS; a revolutionary new way of providing disability support services. The National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) is designed to “support people with disability to build their skills and capability so they can participate in the community and employment” (Australian Department of Human Services, 2014, pg....   [tags: Disability, Disability rights movement, Australia]

Better Essays
1713 words (4.9 pages)

Images of Lilith in A Sea-Spell and The Orchard Pit Essay

- Images of Lilith in A Sea-Spell and The Orchard Pit While Lilith's only explicit appearances are in the poems "Lilith" and "Eden Bower," images of her arise in a number of other poems by Rossetti, including "A Sea-Spell" and "The Orchard Pit" (Johnston 120). Considered "minor" poems, very little has been written on either. Of "A Sea-Spell," some have gone so far as to proclaim "it is kinder to the memory of the artist to say nothing. It is the work of a prematurely faltering mind and hand" (Waugh 211)....   [tags: Sea-Spell Essays]

Free Essays
1135 words (3.2 pages)