The Dilemma Of Impaired Infants Essay

The Dilemma Of Impaired Infants Essay

Length: 1819 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Treating or Terminating: The Dilemma of Impaired Infants. Should we as a society require treatment, and spend thousands upon thousands of dollars trying to save a new life that may or may not have any real quality? Or should we require that a person terminate an infant that is guaranteed to suffer impairments and guaranteed to struggle in many inhumane ways throughout their life? Rather than terminating could society maybe choose to allow nature to take its course, instead of using every medical treatment available to prolong a life that may not be meant to live? These are the questions that society must ask and must come to an answer together on, since it is society that helps to cover the costs of these children and society who is responsible for ensuring that all have a fighting chance at having a life of quality.
Over the years the field of medicine has grown and improved by leaps and bounds, infant care has not been immune to this growth. In a time span of only 30 years the survival rate of a low birth weight child (about 2 pounds) rose from not likely to live long to a 70 to 71 percent chance of survival. About 20% of premature infants will have no lasting major physical or mental impairment. Not only are we able to save the lives of infants that would otherwise have no chance of survival, but we are able to do so with a 20% chance of zero major impairments.
Currently it seems that society is divided between providing all babies showing any sign of life at delivery with heroic measures in order to resuscitate them and only working to keep an infant comfortable until they pass away on their own, where resuscitation is seen as a waste. Baby Doe laws passed in 1985 requiring that all newborns be treated with lifesaving trea...


... middle of paper ...


... off. Also, while using machines might provide the infant with more time for their lungs to develop, we cannot measure the damage that being born prematurely has already caused. Using multiple surgeries to repair a defect that will still allow the infant to suffer for the rest of their life needs to be weighed out against the quality of that life. We cannot look merely at the fact that the infant will be alive and that should be enough, because it should not be enough. As a society we should want the same for these impaired infants as we do for all other infants, as close to a normal, healthy, life full of quality as possible. We should want the world for these infants just the same as we would want for any other infant. If an infant has no hope to come close to these qualities, then we should allow nature to decide whether the infant is meant to live in this world.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Dilemma Of Impaired Infants Essay

- Treating or Terminating: The Dilemma of Impaired Infants. Should we as a society require treatment, and spend thousands upon thousands of dollars trying to save a new life that may or may not have any real quality. Or should we require that a person terminate an infant that is guaranteed to suffer impairments and guaranteed to struggle in many inhumane ways throughout their life. Rather than terminating could society maybe choose to allow nature to take its course, instead of using every medical treatment available to prolong a life that may not be meant to live....   [tags: Infant, Childbirth, Down syndrome, Pediatrics]

Strong Essays
1819 words (5.2 pages)

The Dilemma of Artificial Immunity: Vaccines Essay

- On the 28th of February 1998 British gastroenterologists, Dr. Andrew Wakefield, published a paper declaring correlations between vaccines and severe developmental disorders in children (Gerber & Offit, 2009, p. 456). Although Dr. Wakefield’s study has since then been found to be flawed, his research started a highly controversial debate between artificial and natural immunity. The reality is that we still do not know all the potential short and long-term effects vaccines may have on us. Do the side effects they pose out weighing their benefits....   [tags: Vaccines, Prevention, Disease]

Strong Essays
866 words (2.5 pages)

An Ethical Dilemma For Premature Infants Essay

- Whether or not there is a gestational age at which extreme measures should not be provided for premature infants continues to be an ethical issue today. As nurses and members of the health care team provide information to families about the risks and benefits of extreme life support measures, they must keep in mind the four basic principles of ethics: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice. With supporting evidence provided for both sides, this paper is an attempt to prove why there should not be a gestational age alone, rather many other factors should play a role in the decision making of the viability of a preterm infant....   [tags: Childbirth, Pregnancy, Health care, Preterm birth]

Strong Essays
1726 words (4.9 pages)

Media Consumption Of Infants And Toddlers Essay

- Media Consumption of Infants and Toddlers Lesly Longoria Texas Woman’s University   Media Consumption of Infants and Toddlers With everyday technological advancement, the media consumption of infants and toddlers is a growing topic that not only brings up questions and concerns for parents and those who work with children, but also prompts multiple opinions on what is right or wrong. While research has been conducted to prove that media use by younger children is not harmful to their development, there has also been research done to refute these claims....   [tags: Infant, Developmental psychology]

Strong Essays
1127 words (3.2 pages)

Infant Mortality Rate Is A Global Dilemma Essay

- High infant mortality rate is a global dilemma, but with ongoing research and medical discoveries, high infant mortality rates may lower or completely diminish. There are several causes of infant mortality such as: hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, respiratory failure and traumatic stress. Several technologies have been developed to reduce the infant mortality rate. The artificial placenta, hypothermia therapy, stress therapy are technologies/techniques that may help alleviate the infant mortality rate....   [tags: Infant mortality, Infant, Pediatrics, Infancy]

Strong Essays
1363 words (3.9 pages)

The Visually Impaired Student Essay

- A large percentage of students with visual impairments learn in the general education classroom. General education teachers do not have to work alone; they can collaborate with TVIs and other experts trained to work with students who have visual impairments. Teachers can also use accommodations and modifications to alter their lessons to meet the needs of these students. General education teachers are presented with the unique opportunity to provide state required education while teaching daily living skills to these students that will help them transition into adulthood....   [tags: Special Education]

Strong Essays
1054 words (3 pages)

Question and Answers: Destructive Behaviors, Prisoner's Dilemma and GRIT

- 1. Describe how being in a crowd can lead people to engage in destructive behaviors When people join a large crowd, often they find themselves losing their individuality. Some people may feel a strong desire to conform to fit into the crowd (Changing Minds, 2013). People in crowds may undergo deindividuation, which is a loss of individual identity to gain the social identity of the group. This can result in a loss of the normal constraints that a person may have to guard against deviant behavior (Kassin, Fein, & Markus, 2010)....   [tags: large crowd, resource dilemma]

Strong Essays
1102 words (3.1 pages)

Symptoms And Treatment Of Infants Essay

- Infants tend to surprise you, even when you are related to them. Madelyn Grace Rodriguez, a bright, adorable face with only 2 front teeth, is a 14 month female baby. Her mother, Virginia, who is related to me as first cousins from my father side, explains to me her experience during her pregnancy and labor that changed her relationship with her daughter. Madelyn was a premature child, born approximately 2 months before her due date after her mother suffered a long, complicated pregnancy. She was born with complications that included respiratory functions, gastric function, and bleeding in the brain....   [tags: Infant, Childbirth, Infant mortality, Emotion]

Strong Essays
1198 words (3.4 pages)

Jealousy in Cantor's Dilemma Essay

- Jealousy in Cantor's Dilemma The beast hides in the shadows. Its presence is all around us; its existence denied by all. It moves stealthily from one body to the next, peering with its infinite, green eyes into the deepest thoughts of all, a merciless predator seeking out those who least expect its attack. It strikes without a sound, paralyzing its prey. The monster's bite drives its victims into behaving rashly. It injects a poison strong enough to cause one to distrust one's best-friend....   [tags: Cantor's Dilemma Essays]

Strong Essays
712 words (2 pages)

Essay on Autism in Infants

- First described and named by Leo Kanner in 1944, the mysterious disability of autism is characterized by a peculiar emotional and intellectual detachment from other people and the common human world. In autistic children, an impaired capacity for communication and human relationships and a severely restricted range of activities and interests become evident before the age of three. Although the symptoms vary in nature and severity, language and the capacity for a normal social life are always seriously affected....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
972 words (2.8 pages)