The Difficult Questions Concerning Elder Abuse Essay

The Difficult Questions Concerning Elder Abuse Essay

Length: 1038 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The article, Elderly health care: The line between care and killing, from the Hearld-Review, illustrates the many problems the courts have with elder abuse cases. The case involved the death of 91 year-old Maria “Concha” Lopez of Madera, California who was being cared for by her 26 year-old grandniece, Stephanie Hernandez. Ms. Hernandez called 911 when her Aunt stopped breathing and told the dispatcher that her aunt’s bones were too fragile for CPR, so the dispatcher gave instructions for basic mouth-to-mouth resuscitation. Arriving firefighters and paramedics were inundated with the odor of urine, feces, and rotting flesh emanating from piles of soiled diapers, used bandages and the patient. Ms. Lopez’s had dementia and would not go near doctors. She weighed about 35 pounds and had bedsores so deep that you could touch her bones and the metal rod in her hip. Ms. Hernandez was arrested and charged with murder for failure to give adequate care to her aunt. The trial took five weeks with the defense attorneys showing Ms. Hernandez as a loving niece whose efforts kept an old woman alive and the prosecutor showing autopsy photos and describing the woman’s condition as the result of severe criminal negligence. Ms. Hernandez’s mother worked in the fields and left her in the care of four great-aunts. Ms. Lopez watched her three sisters die in hospitals and made her family promise that she would not be taken to a hospital. The family expected Ms. Hernandez, who also had a small child, to take care of Ms. Lopez after she broke her hip. During the trial, the experts disagreed on whether the bed sores were caused by neglect or because her skin failed when she lost over half her body weight. The jury deliberated for two days and ev...


... middle of paper ...


...the Federal Sentencing Guidelines judges may consider aggravating circumstances when sentencing decisions. A typical aggravating circumstance that applies to elder abuse is if the defendant took advantage of a position of trust or confidence to commit the offense. (text pg 321) Before a judge can impose a sentence, a jury has to find a defendant guilty. It is often difficult to obtain a guilty verdict in a case involving elder abuse, as the case against Ms. Hernandez illustrated. Medicine and the law are not yet able to adequately answer the difficult questions facing doctors, courts and families in regards to elder abuse.



Works Cited
http://www.herald-review.com/lifestyles/health-med-fit/article
“Elderly health care: The Line between care and killing”
http://www.preventelderabuse.org/
2005 National Center on Elder Abuse, Washington, D.C.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Childhood Sexual Abuse : Prevention Through Education And Awareness Essay

- One of the most important questions a victim of childhood sexual abuse, their family, friends and society in general faces when dealing with the aftermath of child sexual abuse is: whether the victim of childhood sexual abuse is likely to become an adult sexual offender?, it is a fact that at least . . . 30% of adult sex offenders were sexually abused as children and/or teens. (Myths and Facts about Sex Offenders) Sexual offenders who have been sexually abused as children are often a consequence of other dysfunction and violence occurring during their childhood that helps catalyze their progression into becoming a sexual predator....   [tags: Child abuse, Human sexual behavior, Sex offender]

Better Essays
1273 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Motherhood: Addicted Mothers

- Methods This study investigated motherhood from substance addicted mothers’own perspective. The survey was conducted at an inpatient ward at a substance abuse clinic in Norway. To gain new insight about the participant`s life-world, a qualitative methodology is the best approach (Kvale, 2002). Data were collected using individual semi-structured in-depth interviews, in order to produce thick descriptions. A thick description is one that explains a human behavior in its context, so that the behavior becomes meaningful, also from an outsiders’ point of view....   [tags: mental health, substance abuse]

Better Essays
955 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Indian Woman in Manju Kapur’s Difficult Daughters

- The status of women in India has not enhanced much even after six decades of Indian Independence. Repression and enslavement still compel her to lead a regulated life. However, education has come to the aid of women to move forward and they have endeavored to liberate themselves from the domination of men. In this context it is interesting to note that the last decade of the twentieth century witnessed a world of change in the literature produced in India in the English language....   [tags: Difficult Daughters Essays]

Better Essays
1850 words (5.3 pages)

Questions On Writing ' The Middle Column ' Essay

- ... 19. Kirstin: So it sounds like to me you’re trying to decide between keeping the baby and having an abortion? Paraphrasing a key idea 20. Patricia: Yeah, we always wanted another one. We were told we couldn’t, um, have another one. So it is kind of... I am torn, with, with what to do. 21. Kirstin: What are the risks for you if you move ahead with the pregnancy? Open-ended question. 22. Patricia: It varies. I ended up very, very ill with the second pregnancy. The first one was not too bad....   [tags: Question, Sentence, Interrogative word, Questions]

Better Essays
1746 words (5 pages)

Is Dementia A Difficult Disease? Essay

- Dementia is a difficult disease to understand and handle. A major problem involving these patients are caregivers that are not properly trained and educated to care for people with the disease resulting in issues such as neglect and abuse. To better understand the patient, you should first understand the disease itself. According to Wayne, White, and Smith (2015), “dementia is caused when connections in the brain are lost due to inflammation, trauma, or disease and eventually the neurons die and dementia is the result.” Although some believe that dementia may be genetic, research suggests that it has more to do with your lifestyle, heredity, and environment....   [tags: Abuse, Child abuse, Domestic violence]

Better Essays
1210 words (3.5 pages)

Questions Frequently Asked Concerning the Purchase of a Website Essay

- Questions Frequently Asked Concerning the Purchase of a Website Reprinted with permission of VotanWeb.com What are the key motivators for people to buy a website. Before making a decision to purchase a website, a buyer should understand his or her objectives to make sure those objectives can be met by purchasing a particular website. Surveys of people purchasing websites reveal similar responses. Surprisingly, making money is not at the top of the list. Here is a list of the typical answers, in their order of importance: I want to control my own destiny....   [tags: Sell Websites Buy Websites]

Free Essays
840 words (2.4 pages)

Ignorance Concerning Child Abuse Essay

- It is said that our children are our most precious resource. They should be protected and allowed to grow up with out being mistreated. Child abuse is a disturbing problem in our country. Most people don't think about child abuse. They just go about their everyday lives doing nothing to combat this issue. They choose to ignore that the problem exists because it is too ugly to look at. It is easier to not do anything if you don't see it in your own life. Therefore, it appears that those people who try to make a positive impact have in someway come in contact with abuse themselves....   [tags: Violence Against Children]

Better Essays
1273 words (3.6 pages)

The Effects Of Child Abuse On Children Essay

- ... When other forms of abuse are identified, emotional abuse is almost always present. Physical abuse of a child results in potential or actual physical harm from an interaction or lack of interaction. This is within the control of a parent or guardian in control, trust, or has responsibilities. Such accidents or injuries are considered abuse, regardless whether or not the parent or guardian intended to hurt the child. Sexual abuse is an involvement of a child in a sexual activity that he or she does not fully comprehend, is unable to give consent to, or is not developmentally prepared for....   [tags: Child abuse, Psychological abuse, Abuse]

Better Essays
764 words (2.2 pages)

Domestic Abuse And Sexual Abuse Essay

- ... Although her quiet desperation yearned to tell, the stigma of a wife talking badly about her own husband would classify her as a “complainer, a bitch.” The secret of abuse likewise seemed distasteful for image, not something anyone would want to be associated with. A part of her did want the story passing through people’s lips and spreading as hot gossip. Augustine also clung onto the diminishing hope that winds of change will blow over what was done. It could be a passing phase- “it could be just temporary…something that won’t last” she told herself....   [tags: Abuse, Child abuse, Psychological abuse]

Better Essays
1278 words (3.7 pages)

Elder Abuse Essay

- Elder Abuse Population ageing is currently one of the most significant demographic trends and becoming a worldwide problem(cite) specially among the elderly who are often the most recognized and forgotten group in this analysis. They are recognized as the ’elder’ the wisest, and perhaps the most knowledgeable about life and its experiences. This population however, is forgotten in terms of the respect and value it once contributed to society. And in today’s world this group is often marginalized because of age....   [tags: Abuse ]

Better Essays
2069 words (5.9 pages)