Essay on Different Theories Proposed to Account for the Iron Age Bog Bodies

Essay on Different Theories Proposed to Account for the Iron Age Bog Bodies

Length: 898 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

There are numerous unanswered questions surrounding the Northern European Bog Bodies phenomenon including "How, or why, or even when, the bodies became immersed in quagmires." (Turner, R.C, Scaife, R.G (ed.),1995,p.169). Despite vast amounts of evidence there are still no easy answers that account for the Iron age bodies. However there are four main competing theories providing possible causes including: the Sacrifice theory, Punishment theory, Boundary theory and the Accidental death theory. All these competing theories will be further examined and critically analysed throughout this text allowing us to depict the most convincing and plausible solution for the mystery of the Iron Age Bog Bodies.

Kelly (2006, p30) supports the restricted Boundary theory based on archaeological evidence of Iron age bog bodies found in Ireland stating that the bodies were "votive offerings along boundaries" which could be "interpreted as having a protective function" within the tribes additionally ensuring the fertility of their land and the health of the people . Multiple evidence of Iron age bog bodies in Ireland have been found in close proximity to barony boundaries including that of Old Croghan man who was found whilst digging a drain through what is now known as town land and a parish boundary as stated by Kelly (2006,p26) is this " purely coincidental"?
Also Clonycavan man who laid directly along the county border of Meath and Westmeath, dividing the ancient territories of Brega and Mide. Recent research of Iron age bog Bodies in Ireland clearly isolates forty different locations in which bog Bodies were found in close propinquity to important primarily barony boundaries (Kelly, 2006). Nevertheless the Boundary theory is restricted and bias...

... middle of paper ...

...bodies.', in Turner, R.C, Scaife,R.G (ed.) Bog bodies: new discoveries and new perspectives. London: British museum Press, pp. 168-182.

Brothwell,D.R (1986) 'Clues to Murder', in Brothwell,D.R (ed.) The bog man and the archaeology of people . London: British Museum, pp. 22-44.

Chamberlain,A., Pearson,M. (2001) 'Bog Bodies', in Chamberlain,A., Pearson,M. (ed.) Earthly Remains: the history and science of preserved human bodies. London: British Museum, pp. 44-82.

Connolly,R.C (1985) 'Lindow man: British Prehistoric Bog Bodies', Anthropology Today, 1(5), pp. 15-17.

Green,M.A (2001) 'Dying for the Gods: human sacrifice in Iron Age & Roman Europe ', in Green,M.A (ed.) Suffocation: drowning, strangling and burial alive. Stroud: Tempus, pp. 111-135.
Kelly,E.P (2006) 'Secrets of the Bog Bodies: The Enigma of the Iron Age explained', Archaeology Ireland, 20(1), pp. 26-30.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Iron Sulfur Proteins : Iron Dioxide Essay

- Iron Sulfur Proteins Iron-sulfur proteins, like the name suggests are a protein with a metal center of iron bound to a number of sulfur atoms. Because of the metal center of iron’s ability to have a number of different oxidation states, the iron and sulfur are able to arrange themselves in many different clusters. As a result there are various applications for iron-sulfur proteins. The most prominent is the usage of iron-sulfur proteins in oxidation-reduction reactions, especially in metabolic reactions....   [tags: DNA, Gene, Redox, Oxygen]

Better Essays
1081 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Travel Free Curling Iron

- Travel-Free Curling Iron Girls dream to look stylish each and every day of a year. They want perfect hair everywhere like the movies. It is almost impossible because when you in travel, go camping, go adventure, go outside for project work cannot style your hair. If you carry a light, portable, manageable, usable travel-free curling iron it can possible. The travel-free curling iron specifically designs for travelers. So it has to have some specific criteria to be effective and better curling iron....   [tags: Heat, Temperature, Iron, Hairstyle]

Better Essays
856 words (2.4 pages)

The Movie ' Iron Man ' Essay

- Hero worship exists in almost every culture in various ways. Corresponding to the hero worship, heroism represents the pursuit of particular cultural value, and to a certain extent, it affects the development of the society. Largely reflected in the film and television, heroism is one of the most important themes in Western and Asian media markets. Admittedly, different culture has a different definition of heroism and different taste on the traits of heroes and each culture has its different ways of depicting the heroes....   [tags: Hero, Superhero, Iron Man, China]

Better Essays
2354 words (6.7 pages)

Treatment Of Iron Deficiency Anemia Essay

- Based on the symptoms, test results, and the history of the patient it can be determined that the patient is suffering from iron deficiency anemia. Iron deficiency anemia is a “condition in which there is a decrease in normal body stores of iron and hemoglobin levels” (Nursing Central, 2016). This condition is illustrated with symptoms of extreme fatigue, shortness of breath, accelerated heartbeat and decreased appetite (Mayo Clinic, 2014). Some symptoms of iron deficiency anemia can be so mild it can go unnoticed (Mayo Clinic, 2014)....   [tags: Red blood cell, Iron deficiency anemia, Hematology]

Better Essays
1305 words (3.7 pages)

The Bog Bodies of Northern Europe Essay

- On the morning of May 3, 1983, an eight year old Irish boy named Sean O’Leary wandered around a peat bog, accompanying his father who worked nearby in the fields. He was completely clueless to the secrets the mud was holding. As he explored the bog he encountered upon what he claimed was a forgotten toy. Once home when presented the object to his father, they realized the “forgotten toy” was a cadaver’s hand. Unbeknownst to them, this well-preserved body part came from a body that had been buried in a swamp a thousand years earlier, a common practice at that time all across Northern Europe....   [tags: huldremose Women, Gallagh Man]

Better Essays
1709 words (4.9 pages)

Coal and Iron and the Unification of Germany in 1871 Essay

- Coal and Iron and the Unification of Germany in 1871 In 1862, Bismarck said that ‘the great questions of the day will be settled by blood and iron.’ Although there is undoubtedly some degree of accuracy in this statement, the most important reason for the unification of Germany, which ended ‘the great questions of the day,’ was ‘coal and iron.’ This is a quote from British economist John Maynard Keynes, who argued that the industrial and economic preparation before the wars, which united Germany, were more important....   [tags: Blood and Iron ]

Better Essays
1511 words (4.3 pages)

Ronald Takaki's Iron Cages: Race and Culture in 19th-Century America Essay examples

- Ronald Takaki's Iron Cages: Race and Culture in 19th-Century America After America declared its independence from British rule, the founding fathers faced a conundrum: How to build and maintain a successful republican government that was ultimately dependent upon the passions and character of its people. Their solution was to propose the construction of what historians have called "iron cages," which were ideological devices intended to deter the corruption and folly that might consume a free people, and instead promoterational and virtuous American citizens....   [tags: Iron Cages Ronald Takaki Essays]

Better Essays
1673 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on Australian Iron Ore Mining Industry Review

- Iron ore is Australia’s highest valued and most successful commodity export (see Figure 1). Throughout the 1990s and early 2000s, this mining industry played a key role in both Australia’s and the global economy. The change in the industry was brought about, particularly, by the many operations and movements resulting from globalisation that pushed Australia’s exports further than they had ever been. In 2007, “Australia produced around 16% of the world's iron ore and was ranked third behind China (32%) and Brazil (19%)” (Minerals Council of Australia, 2008)....   [tags: Iron Ore Mining Mines]

Free Essays
1889 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on Marx's Theories

- Though Marx’s theories were first conceived over 150 years ago, his work continues to be tremendously influential and is perhaps the most well known scholarship within the sociological canon. Despite their prominence, some of Marx’s most famous ideas have yet to be proven by the course of history. Neo-Marxists may insist that the revolution is coming, but the fact remains that the overthrow of capitalism has yet to materialize. I argue that the communist revolution has not yet occurred because the proletariat has been unable to develop the universal class consciousness that Marx asserts is a necessary condition for his predicted mass uprising....   [tags: Neo-Marxist Theories, Marxist Ideology]

Better Essays
1564 words (4.5 pages)

Iron Jawed Angels Essay

- Iron Jawed Angels Iron Jawed Angels is a film which portrays the women's suffrage movement during the 1920's. The film is a documentary and a drama which uses live action and music to deliver the sympathetic and distressful mood the film creates. An example of the distressful mood is when the suffragists refuse to eat when they go to prison. This shows how passionate and distressed the suffragists are to get the 19th amendment passed, which would give women the right to vote. The films message, which is the hardships and adversity women had to withstand to get the 19th amendment passed, is effectively portrayed because the struggle the suffragists faced is accurately and beautifully depic...   [tags: essays research papers Iron Jawed Essays]

Better Essays
536 words (1.5 pages)