The Differences Between Hans Christian Andersen And Walt Disney 's Tales Of The Little Mermaid

The Differences Between Hans Christian Andersen And Walt Disney 's Tales Of The Little Mermaid

Length: 1435 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Difference Between Two Tails
Often times people forget that Walt Disney got many of his ideas for movies from previous fairy-tales and folklore. Since I was young my personal favorite Disney movie has been The Little Mermaid.. However, it scarcely crossed my mind as I grew older that there was a different story contradicting almost everything in the film. Despite bearing some similarities, the striking differences between Hans Christian Andersen’s and Walt Disney’s tales of The Little Mermaid have just furthered my love for Disney’s version.
Andersen’s tale of “The Little Mermaid”, originally published in 1837, features a nameless mermaid who is referred to, simply, as the Little Mermaid. She is ten years old at the beginning of the story and is the youngest of the Sea King’s six beloved daughters. The youngest sister is described as the loveliest of her mer-sisters, but much less confident and outgoing than the five others. The opening scenes of the fairytale say that the Little Mermaid “was a strange child, quiet and thoughtful,” (Andersen 2) making it seem as though she was a weird and timid girl.
In Disney’s film The Little Mermaid, originally released in 1989, the mermaid is known by the name of Ariel. In this adaptation, she is sixteen years old at the start of the film and the youngest of King Triton’s (The Sea King) seven daughters. In this film, Ariel is portrayed much different from how Andersen described his Little Mermaid. Ariel is a very joyful character who has an adventurous and vibrant personality. She has a mind of her own and does much of what she wants to, whether it’s against her father’s rules or not. Showing her independence, Ariel often says things along the lines of “I 'm not a child anymore!” to her...


... middle of paper ...


...is quite easy to see that Disney portrays his prince character much better. Eric is kind and respectful toward not only his friends, but his whole kingdom. When he finds Ariel, Eric takes responsibility for her and ensures that she is cared for properly. Andersen 's Prince may tolerate his kingdom, but he regularly uses Ariel to busy himself because she is readily available. Using someone when they are vulnerable does not seem like much of a prince-like trait to me.
As shown time and time again, it is easy to see that both Andersen 's and Disney 's version of The Little Mermaid have very distinct differences. Although it is strange that two stories could be so similar yet have so many striking differences, it is apparent which tale I prefer. The very grim and gruesome differences in Andersen’s story have just furthered my love for Disney 's film, The Little Mermaid.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Little Mermaid: Hans Christian Andersen vs Walt Disney Essay

- The Little Mermaid is well known to everyone, but which version is known best. Hans Christian Andersen or Walt Disney, both are very similar mostly because Hans Christian Andersen’s Little Mermaid was the most popular version of the story before Walt Disney. Although Hans Christian Andersen’s “The Little Mermaid,” published in 1837, contains many patronizing nineteenth-century attitudes towards women, a value system that at least acknowledges the legitimacy of femininity shapes the fairytale. Unfortunately, Walt Disney’s 1989 film version of “The Little Mermaid” eliminates the values that affirm femininity in the original story (Trites 145) Walt Disney needed to change his version and many...   [tags: The Little Mermaid Essays]

Strong Essays
2433 words (7 pages)

Hans Christian Andersen 's The Little Mermaid Essay

- For my literary analysis I read Hans Christian Andersen 's The Little Mermaid, and watched Disney 's rendition of The Little Mermaid. I felt that these stories had more differences than similarities. Where Hans Christian Andersen focused more on the consequences of becoming human, the movie focused on Ariel winning the prince over. While reading this story I took note of the fact that even though The Little Mermaid was a normal human, in the end she still didn 't get what made her happy. The movie on the other hand, gave Ariel everything she wanted along the way for conforming to normalities of the world above the sea....   [tags: The Little Mermaid, Hans Christian Andersen]

Strong Essays
1216 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Into the Mind of Hans Christian Andersen

- Into the Mind of Hans Christian Andersen “Hans Christian Andersen was a product of two towns, two social environments, two worlds and two ages.” Said Johan de Mylius. Andersen was born on April 2, 1805 in Odense, Denmark. The only child to a poor shoe maker and a washerwoman, Andersen experienced the lower quality of life. As a young child he would roam the local town. He would often visit the home for the elderly in Odense where the old women would tell him aged stories and legends they were told when they were children themselves....   [tags: Biography]

Strong Essays
1882 words (5.4 pages)

The Princess and the Pea by Hans Andersen Essay

- The Real Her While reading the story ‘The Princess and the Pea’, Hana does a great job in using irony and confusion to its readers. The story of “Prince” follows an imagination to marry not only a princess, but a real princess. There were enough princesses, but no where close to the one he wanted. The author does a good job to define the plot and breaking it down to real life relationships. To me this is like a beloved story tale. The author creates a very delusional story line with the prince having problems finding a wife....   [tags: princess, fairy tale, royal]

Strong Essays
990 words (2.8 pages)

Hans Christian Andersen Depicted His Need of Love in His Stories Essay

- Hans Christian Andersen was Lonely and desperately wanted to find love. This longing and failure to find someone showed through into his work. In his work cupid is portrayed as deceptive and evil. The Little Mermaid is the most often cited example of Andersen’s loneliness. The protagonist goes through much pain and loneliness for the one she loves, only to have him choose someone over her. In the short story The Sunbeam and the Prisoner, Andersen shows how fleeting love and happiness were in his life....   [tags: Fairytales, Lonely, Family]

Strong Essays
836 words (2.4 pages)

Using Propp's Methods to Analyze Thumbelina by Hans Christian Andersen Essay

- Thumbelina is a fairy tale of Danish origin, created by Hans Christian Andersen and published in 1835 under its original name, "Tommelise". The name Thumbelina was first used by H.W. Dulcken in 1864. The tale revolves around a tiny girl of the same, and her adventures as a pint-sized human facing up to the challenges surrounding her. Her name is interchangeable, as she is named Thumbelina, but is referred to as Tiny. The motifs of the story are almost typical of fairy tales - talking animals (toads, mole, white mouse, cockchafer), traveler's tales (Tiny on a long journey after being kidnapped from her home), guardians/helpers (the white mouse, the swallow), large and unknown areas (the fores...   [tags: fairytale, villainy, hero]

Strong Essays
776 words (2.2 pages)

David Duncan and the Arthur Andersen Case Essay

- In May 2002, Andersen was prosecuted for obstruction of justice based on two main reasons. First, David Duncan, a former Andersen partner in charge of the Enron audit, destructed related documents to keep them out of the investigation. Second, Nancy Temple, an in-house attorney for Andersen, suggested the management to pay attention to the document retention policy. The jury convicted Andersen and believed David Duncan was corruptly persuaded to impede the integrity of the justice proceedings. In 2005, the Supreme Court overturned the conviction of Andersen based on flawed jury instructions....   [tags: Arthur Andersen]

Strong Essays
976 words (2.8 pages)

Hans Eysenck : Personality And Individual Differences Essay

- Hans Eysenck was born in Germany in March of 1916 and died in September of 1997 at the age of 81. He eventually moved to England, being that he and his family were Jewish and the Nazi regime was growing in power. While in England he attended University College in London where he received his PhD in 1940. He spent nearly thirty years of his life as a psychology professor at King’s College. He wrote the Journal of Personality and Individual Differences during that time period. Eysenck won a number of APA awards such as the Presidential Citation for Outstanding Contributions to Society and the William James Fellow Award....   [tags: Psychology, Personality psychology, Neuroticism]

Strong Essays
898 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about The Ethics Of Arthur Andersen Llp

- Over the years many companies have decided abandon ethical practices is lieu of higher profits. Because of the high value placed on profits in America, many companies have taken extreme measures to increase profits and increase payouts for shareholders. Arthur Andersen LLP is a prime example of how business executives have been willing to make unethical business decisions in order to please clients and gain an edge on competition. In the short run, these unethical decisions may have seemed beneficial, but in the long run, the extensive consequences of this behavior was not worth any anticipated gain....   [tags: Arthur Andersen, Enron, Business ethics]

Strong Essays
1396 words (4 pages)

Essay Walt Disney Is Not Perfect

- The Disney brand brings happiness to children and adults alike and families welcome the company into their homes through movies, music, and merchandise. Disney is synonymous with joy, amazement, wonder, and magic and this reflects the personality of the creator. Walt Disney used his optimism and charisma to lead his employees and infuse that into his work. Other leadership skills Disney had that helped him succeed both in the arts and business is his tough management style, attention to detail and organization, and his intense commitment and value of loyalty....   [tags: The Walt Disney Company, Walt Disney]

Strong Essays
1409 words (4 pages)