The Difference of How a Theatrical Critic and a Reviewer Look at a Performer

The Difference of How a Theatrical Critic and a Reviewer Look at a Performer

Length: 2357 words (6.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

I. Introduction
In today’s society, we are flustered with a variety of artistic performances, which are both praised and rejected by others. In a recent 2011 article by Bert Cardullo, he explains the two main types of persons whose main jobs are to look over these artistic performances and give their personal feedback. “It is certainly true that the critics—those persons whom the dictionary describes as “skilled in judging the qualities or merits of some class of things, especially of literary or artistic work”—have long harbored murderous thoughts about the condition of our drama, but their ineffectuality as public executioners is legendary. The reviewers, by contrast, come close to being the most loyal and effective allies the commercial theater could possibly desire” (Cardullo, 2011). Looking into this quote, it demonstrates that critics take their job to the extent where they aren’t afraid to strike hard at a particular piece. As for a reviewer, they will be more “sugar coating” about performances and offer helpful suggestions for the piece (they are praised more than critics). This research will focus on the lenses of theatrical critics and reviewers with their similarities and differences (as well as emphasize on some important Theatrical Critics and Reviewers). Then, based on this research, it will be put to the test as a playwright takes his previously produced play and use criticisms and reviews as a guide to recreating a play and bringing it back onto the stage. Once doing that, a survey will be conducted to see if the help of criticisms and/or reviews aided in the success of the newly revised play.
II. Purpose of the Study
Evaluating the differentiation of theatrical critiques and reviews are crucial in any artist...


... middle of paper ...


...fully assist in making the director change some things around in order to make their production more successful and sell more seats.

VI. Conclusion
Theatrical critics and reviewers have been thought of as the same occupation; however, they are two different types of jobs that help in making a production improve on its previous mistakes. In doing so, it creates a newly revised play that is meant to be successful for public consumption. It also creates the idea that critics and reviewers work together to give amazing feedback and bring together new ideas for a playwright/director to take and use to their advantage.



Works Cited

Cardullo, B. (2011). Person of the Drama: Stanley Kauffmann as Theater Critic. Sewanee Review, 119(3), 475-482.
Cardullo, B. (2011). Richard Gilman, American Theater Critic as Appreciation. Sewanee Review, 119(2), 288-295.



Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Difference between Past and Present Views of Alcohol through the Effectiveness of Theatrical Influence

- From generation to generation there have been different methods of influence from particularly adults to young adults on the dangers of alcohol. In theatre there are types performance styles that have evolved over time and when this change happens, it is the result of change in society as well. There are many differences between Augusto Boal and Aristotle as far as theatre presentation is concerned, but when you bring some of the real-life instances and how they demonstrate each morally it can show this contrast even further....   [tags: Augusto Boal, Aristotle, theater styles]

Term Papers
1467 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on The Difference Between High Performers And Low Performers

- WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN HIGH PERFORMERS AND LOW PERFORMERS. Employees are the greatest assets to any given company, I would imagine that the managers and business owners would like nothing else but to attract and maintain the best performers as their employees to deliver good quality product and services to their consumers. That being said there are 3 categories of performance at any work place and they include; • High performers • Middle/medium performers • Low performers For the sake of this research I am going to focus on two of the extremes in order to understand their differences....   [tags: Performance, Performing arts, Team, Music]

Term Papers
1371 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on A Feminist Art Critic, Arlene Raven

- In the section, Words of Honor: Contributions of a Feminist Art Critic, Arlene Raven outlines the events in her life that have led her to be an art critic for artists who were not as “bankable” as other artists. In this excerpt, she discusses how her experiences of being raped exposed her to a cruel reality about the oppression women faced despite equal education acquirement. Consequently, she increasingly got more involved in the feminist/political work, creating iconic associations like the Women’s Building....   [tags: Art, Art critic, Art history, Feminist theory]

Term Papers
1124 words (3.2 pages)

Rotten Tomatoes Vs. Meta Critic On The Film Dope Essay examples

- Rotten Tomatoes vs. Meta Critic on the Film Dope Dope is a controversial film which addresses many issues with today’s youth living in crime-polluted, drug-infested neighborhoods in the city of Los Angeles. The movie, though a low budget film received relatively positive reviews from both Rotten Tomatoes and Meta Critic which have been known for destroying a film’s reputation in the public eye, causing ticket sales and movie goers to plummet all before the movie’s opening weekend, which is when movies earn the most profit....   [tags: Film criticism, Film, Rotten Tomatoes, Critic]

Term Papers
849 words (2.4 pages)

The Evolution of Theatrical Lighting Design Essay

- Beginning with its origins in Ancient Greece, theatre was always staged in outdoor performance spaces, relying on natural light to keep the performers visible, and utilizing scenery or dialogue to convey time of day. As these performances began to shift to indoor theatres, artificial light, such as candles or oil lamps, had to be used as a replacement. As lighting technology advanced, these advancements changed the way light could be manipulated, directed, or focused, allowing for new staging methods to be developed and introducing lighting as an indicator of mood....   [tags: dramatic arts, stage props]

Term Papers
1520 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Making A Difference Within My Community

- Making a Difference in My Community Without culture, uniqueness would be rare. Without uniqueness, society would be dull. In a dull society, there would be no more imagination or new, outstanding ideas. Culture is the reason why everyone is different in their own way, making each and every person, no matter who they are, unique. In order to make a difference, you have to be different. Not many realize how much everyone’s own, personal culture affects their lives and the community they live in. It not only defines one another but brings out new ideas and understandings of the world around them....   [tags: Culture, Difference]

Term Papers
711 words (2 pages)

Pirandello: A Theatrical Philosopher Essay

- Luigi Pirandello’s Six Characters in Search of an Author, is a unique and passionate play in which the dynamics of the theater are uprooted, deconstructed, and questioned for their validity and integrity. In Pirandello’s play, we experience the art of “metatheater.” Pirandello utilizes this technique to demonstrate the disadvantages of theatrical editing, enlighten his audience with self-reflecting philosophical questions, and acknowledge the timelessness of art. To begin with, the Characters express their frustration with Producer when he begins to rewrite and change their stories to suit the theater’s requirements....   [tags: Six Characters in Search of an Authro]

Term Papers
983 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Being a Critic of the Arts

- Being a Critic of the Arts Everyday, we act as critics, i.e., deciding which film to see or which channel to watch. Much of the time, experience guides us through the aesthetic judgments we make. Left on our own, however, we can go only so far. As Martin and Jacobus (1997) argue, in studying the essentials of criticism and in learning how to put them into practice, we develop our capacities as critics (p. 48). 1. introduction We all resist taking on the critic's role because we value the participatory experience....   [tags: Art Critics]

Term Papers
1804 words (5.2 pages)

Disability and the Theatrical Event Essay

- Disability and the Theatrical Event When I was 10, I was hit by a car. Actually, I was 9 years old, got hit by the car and turned 10 in hospital. I was walking home with my friends after school. It all happened in the blink of an eye. Someone was driving. Someone didn't look. Someone was careful but not careful enough. They ran. I waited. Not in the right place. And I was hit. Just like that. A piece of glass from the headlight pierced my skull and entered my brain. My brain was damaged....   [tags: College Admissions Essays]

Free Essays
394 words (1.1 pages)

Essay about Confident Performer

- My desire and craving to write and speak better is what helped me overcome my negative attitude towards my skill level of writing and speaking and to return to school. When I signed up for school, my first class requirement, Peak Performance, was aiming to teach me and to cause me to become aware of whom I am and how to create new healthy habits. The results of my studies taught me that I hold the keys to my success as I train myself to create healthy habits as I take charge of my life. One way that I was learning how to create healthy habits was by visualizing my success, and being positive with confidence, as I was guarding my mind from negative thoughts....   [tags: Personal Ambition]

Term Papers
1072 words (3.1 pages)