Did The Holy Spirit Speak Through And Direct The Founders Of The New Prophecy Movement?

Did The Holy Spirit Speak Through And Direct The Founders Of The New Prophecy Movement?

Length: 2064 words (5.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Did the Holy Spirit speak through and direct the founders of the New Prophecy movement?
The early Christian church in the second century was vulnerable to heresy, misguided doctrine and false teachers. It was debated whether one of the earliest nominally charismatic movements of the early church was inspired by the Holy Spirit, or by a spirit not sent by God. Montanism had teachings both in and out of agreement with the mainstream church, but was overshadowed by the controversy of prophecy and the biblical standard by which it was approved.
Montanism, also known as the New Prophecy, was founded circa 160 AD (Montanism, 2014), in the region of Phrygia, now modern day Turkey. Traditionally, the Phrygian people were polytheistic, worshipping many deities. One of their main deities was the goddess Cybele, associated with the wild, nature and fertility. There is evidence of her worship as far back as 8th century BCE (Elizabeth Simpson, 1996), and was eventually adopted into the Roman pantheon circa 204 BC (The Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica, 2007). Her cult was characterized by a eunuch priesthood and ecstatic worship practices. The priests of her following believed that self-castration and emasculating themselves gave them a level of prophetic power (Roscoe, 1996).
The Christian church would have been approximately 130 years old, counting from the time of Jesus’s death. For a religion, 130 years is considered quite young, especially when one is looking back from nearly 2000 years in the future. The church at the time was occupied with several debates and issues. The early Christians did not have a canonized New Testament to reference and they were still confirming what we would consider basic theology today, such as the exist...


... middle of paper ...


...eology, derived from selected New Testament, but then added to by this spirit, is also not consistent when compared to the New Testament, or the Bible as a whole. The Holy Spirit would not contradict the message of the Bible, considered as God’s word. Therefore, it is abundantly clear, that if there was a spirit speaking through Montanus, Priscilla and Maximilla, it was not the Holy Spirit, or any form of the Lord. The Lord is consistent, he is a God of peace and order. There is too much biblical evidence that contradicts with the accounts and descriptions of the prophecies. It is also possible that Montanus had brought the worship practices of his previous faith with him, and colluded with the prophetesses to prophesy from their own understanding, with no spiritual influence present. The movement’s lack of ability to find another prophet, could indicate towards this.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Bible Calls And The Holy Spirit Essay

- The Bible calls Christians to be holy, from the beginning of time all the way to the very end of time, “Rather, he must be hospitable, one who loves what is good, who is self-controlled, upright, holy and disciplined” (Titus 1:8 The New International Version Bible). The term holy can only be achieved through the work of the Holy Spirit that guides Christians and through the Holy Spirit they are given the fruits of the spirit. In this study of Holy verses Good, it will be looked at from the point of view of false fruits, the importance of spiritual practices and discipline and how they are important, it will be shown how Christians despite being in a fallen world are made holy and how through...   [tags: Jesus, Christianity, Christian terms, Holy Spirit]

Better Essays
1068 words (3.1 pages)

The Spirit Of The Holy Spirit Essay

- One of the primary works of the Holy Spirit is to bring men and women into a meaningful encounter with the Risen Christ. Guided by His Spirit, we can truly discover Jesus Christ and develop a genuine relationship with Him if we respond with total surrender and generosity. Soon enough, Christ’s love becomes the center of our lives and saturates us with joy and peace. Hence, when we have had a personal encounter with Jesus Christ by the Spirit’s power, our greatest desire is that our loved ones may also enjoy a similar experience....   [tags: Jesus, Christianity, Holy Spirit, Trinity]

Better Essays
1111 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Confirmation Of The Holy Spirit

- Confirmation is is one of the three Sacraments of Christian Initiation. The other two sacraments of Christian Initiation are Baptism and the Eucharist. Confirmation completes the grace of Baptism through the outpouring of the gifts of Holy Spirit. Confirmation is a rite of initiation of not only Catholicism, but other Christian denominations too. Confirmation 's roots can be found in the New Testament, it is the outpouring of the Holy Spirit, and its practice has not derived much from the Early Church practice....   [tags: Baptism, Christianity, Holy Orders, Chrism]

Better Essays
1601 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on History Of The Doctrine Of The Holy Spirit

- Summarize Erickson’s overview of the history of the doctrine of the Holy Spirit. In early church history little was said about the work of the Holy Spirit. His working was mainly relegated to the inspiration of scripture. Later there were arguments of the Holy Spirit’s position in the Trinity and whether he should be viewed as equal to God the Father and God the Son or subservient to them. Others resisted the idea of emotions or feeling. Many believed that reason and rational proof was the only credible belief system as apposed to the more subjective view of the Holy Spirit with emotion and feeling....   [tags: God, Christianity, Theology, Holy Spirit]

Better Essays
2255 words (6.4 pages)

The Holy Spirit Is For Everyone Essay

- 1. Pentecost was a one-time event. We don’t need to repeat Pentecost as the NT church today in fact we can’t. As the church we should partner with the Holy Spirit to continue the work he has started. When we do this we allow the Holy Spirit to do his will in our lives. 2. The Holy Spirit is for everyone. When the Holy Spirit came in Acts it fell on everyone who was in the room not just certain people. According to verse 17 the sign of the Holy Spirit is that you speak. When the Holy Spirit comes on falls on you the only response is to tell people about it....   [tags: Jesus, Christianity, Holy Spirit, Trinity]

Better Essays
737 words (2.1 pages)

The Holy Spirit By Stanley M. Burgess Essay

- For many Believers, there is a lack of clear understanding between the different natures of the Holy Spirit. Many, due to theological dogma, have failed to teach the multifaceted manner the Holy Spirit operates in the lives of Believers, while others have neglected the unity of the Holy Spirit. The purpose of this paper is to show both the unity and the unique distinctions in the nature of the Holy Spirit. Throughout the history of the Church there has been conflicted regarding the nature and purpose of the Holy Spirit....   [tags: Holy Spirit, Christianity, Jesus, New Testament]

Better Essays
941 words (2.7 pages)

The Holy Spirit, By Mark D. Burnham Essay

- These supernatural acts of the Spirit are not relegated to Acts or the New Testament. The same acts of the Spirit is evident in the New Testament as well. Mark D. McLean instructs us to put out of our minds completely the impression that the Holy Spirit did not come into the world until the Day of Pentecost. Possibly the most direct empowerment connection in the Old Testament is Joel 2:28-32. The connection from Old Testament to New Testament is drawn by Peter in Acts 2:17-18. Here Peter sees the fulfillment of the promise of God that He will “pour out His Spirit upon all flesh.” This verse was the bridge that brought the history of Israel to Pentecost....   [tags: New Testament, Christianity, Holy Spirit, God]

Better Essays
1709 words (4.9 pages)

The Prayer Of The Holy Spirit Essay

- Introduction Sanctification occurs throughout the Christian’s life and cannot be maintained without the assistance of the Holy Spirit. Evidence can be observed in Christians today from the moment of accepting Christ as well as exemplifying a life that would be pleasing to God by means of obedience. The Holy Spirit and sanctification are two components fundamental for the Christian life according to Paul in Romans. We will discuss and address the Holy Spirit, sanctification and obedience and how these relationships manifests themselves in the life of a Christian through a lifestyle of sound judgement, good morals and ethics....   [tags: Jesus, Christianity, Holy Spirit, Christian terms]

Better Essays
1214 words (3.5 pages)

The Sin Against The Holy Spirit Essay examples

- The Sin Against The Holy Spirit On the occasion of Jesus healing a man who was blind, dumb and possessed by a devil, the Scribes and Pharisees accused Him of using power from Beelzebub to work the miracle. (Matt. 12:22-24) The Lord said, “Wherefore I say unto you, All manner of sin and blasphemy shall be forgiven unto men: but the blasphemy against the Holy Ghost shall not be forgiven unto men. And whosoever speaketh a word against the Son of man, it shall be forgiven him: but whosoever speaketh against the Holy Ghost, it shall not be forgiven him, neither in this world, neither in the world to come” (Matt....   [tags: Jesus, God in Christianity, God, Holy Spirit]

Better Essays
883 words (2.5 pages)

The Holy Spirit And The Christ On The Road Of Damascus Essay

- . First major theme of the book of Acts is the work of the Holy Spirit in the apostles and the early church. Jesus appeared to his disciples and commanded them not to leave Jerusalem but wait for the gift, the Holy Spirit (Acts 1:3b-5) As they gathered together and prayed in one place, the Holy Spirit came to rest on each of them (2:1-3). The disciples who were filled with the Holy Spirit boldly proclaimed God’s word and performed miracles (2:14-42, 3:1-10). Throughout the book, the author focuses on how the Holy Spirt ministers the apostles and the believers in their lives and the community....   [tags: Jesus, Christianity, New Testament, Holy Spirit]

Better Essays
1802 words (5.1 pages)