Compare and contrast Dickinson and Gilman’s treatment of gender and gender norms.
Emily Dickinson and Charlotte Perkins Gilman both lived in a time where women were considered to be “second class citizens”. During this time it was expected of women to be obedient and submissive to their husbands. A woman’s thoughts and opinions were never valued as much as a man’s was. Despite these unfavorable conditions both Emily Dickinson and Charlotte Perkins Gilman fought back and expressed themselves. They served as huge inspirations for other women enduring the same struggles. Although both works depict how each author overcame gender inequality, Dickinson was a rebel who didn’t hesitate to express herself while Gilman was submissive at first but exploded when finally pushed past her breaking point.
Emily Dickinson’s style is very fierce and unreserved. Her unusual style of poetry perfectly conveys her emotions. It was already uncommon for women to write works of literature, but what separated her even more from the herd was her use of punctuation. Her style was so radical that when it was first initially published it had to be modified. Dickinson was a true rebel of her time! Charlotte Perkin Gilman however was quite the opposite, in her writing she seemed to be paranoid, scared and frail. She was submissive to her husband, but still yearning to express herself. She’s very much like a bird locked in a cage wanting to spread its wings. Gilman was frightened of disappointing her husband and unfortunately for her one of the many things he disliked was her writing. Despite this, she still decided to keep writing showing how much she truly wanted to express herself.
In The Yellow Wallpaper, the narrators hu...
... middle of paper ...
... use of capitalization and hyphens was deemed as unnecessary by many, but to her it was completely necessary to express her emphasis. Unfortunately, she was unable to obtain recognition during her lifetime. When her poetry was first published many changes were made so that it would meet the current standards. Little did anyone know that the true strength of her poetry lied within her unique style. Only when her work was published in it’s original form did Dickinson start to receive recognition as a pioneer. Dickinson writes” Assent – and you are sane- Demur – your straightway dangerous – And handled with a Chain –" (Lines 5-7) If one was to conform to standards then they would be considered normal. However, if one strayed away from norms they would be deemed outcasts. “Much Madness is divinest Sense” (line 1) meant that madness was true free thinking and expression.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Gender norms are ideas that are deeply ingrained in us at a very young age. At birth infants are dressed in gendered clothing, given gendered toys and talked to in different ways. These gendered ways of acting and thinking are upheld all throughout childhood. Society and parents inflict their gender ideas and norms on children and expect them to act and behave in certain ways. Children learn gender from being subjected to society’s expectations, even though pressuring kids to conform to those rigid roles can end up having serious consequences for the children whose social circles try to over-correct their behavior.... [tags: Gender, Gender role, Transgender, Gender studies]
1377 words (3.9 pages)
- Society constructs images that define males and females to boundaries called gender norms. When a person steps out of the gender boundaries, it is often looked down upon by society. I chose to violate the gender norm by opening doors for people. This past weekend, my friend and I went out to a store near my house. As I was entering the store, I decided to hold the door open for two men who were walking out. One of the men paused and told me, “shouldn’t I be holding the door for you?” and I reacted to tell him, “No I’m fine” and the two men paused and left.... [tags: Gender, Sociology, Gender role, Woman]
933 words (2.7 pages)
- From the beginning of time gender roles played a big part in society, gender roles are based on expectations and beliefs of what a society has on a specific person based on their sex. In literature Gender roles have always been a major conflict, whither it was in a play, a poem, or a story. If women are not projected as a weak person, or if men are not presented as manly and heroic, people start taking offense to that. Like how Serena is seen as strong independent women in the story, and her role shuts down are all gender norms, and sets a new meaning for what a women should be like.... [tags: Gender role, Woman, Role, Gender]
1004 words (2.9 pages)
- Today the social construct of gender we see in Western society consists of two genders: men and women. The binary gender system has strict, set roles and expectations for presentation of gender, activities appropriate for each gender, and especially sexualities. The social construct of a strict binary gender system creates and enforces strict binary contradicting roles for sexuality through gender roles and norms that oppress everyone who does not conform and oppresses any other non-conforming sexualities.... [tags: Gender, Homosexuality, Sexual intercourse]
760 words (2.2 pages)
- What is gender. The formal definition is, “the cultural social and psychological meanings that are associated with masculinity and femininity.” In all reality there is no differences between the two sexes. We are actually the same in a lot of aspects. Then why do gender-role stereotypes still exist now that it is the twenty-first century. To start with gender-role stereotypes are, “ the beliefs and expectation of people that hold about the typical characteristics, preferences and behavior of man and women.” Gender-stereotypes come directly from gender norms.... [tags: Gender, Male, Female, Heteronormativity]
846 words (2.4 pages)
- Around the world gender is genuinely seen as strictly male or female. If you step out of this “social norm,” you could be considered an outcast. This disassociation includes, biological males/females, interssexed, and transgendered individuals. These people are severely suppressed by society because their gender identification, behaviors, and even their activities deviate from the norm. Most Americans are exceedingly devoted to the concept that there are only two sexes. Therefore, the constrictive American ideals of male and female gender identities inhibits growth and acceptance of gender expression.... [tags: biological genders, gender stereotypes]
818 words (2.3 pages)
- Norms in society are the expectations of actions in specific situations. Social norms keep human social relations and behavior stable. Norms are “rules” that have developed within a particular society taking into account its values, culture and way of living. Sometimes, it is even the case that individuals do not have a choice and rarely recognize that fact that social norms have arbitrary origins because they have experienced this during the ongoing process of living (Clinard and Meyer 2011:10).... [tags: Gender Issues]
1236 words (3.5 pages)
- The evolution of human species has lead to roles we have placed on males and females and what we expect them to do for our society. With the gender norms we have developed over time towards each gender, in order to break the cultural barrier, this requires us to put down the norms we know for each gender and to accept that some males and females maybe different from the norm. These differences should not be considered as harmful to our society or deviant acts that interfere with our gender norms that we have set for our society but should be considered accepted.... [tags: Gender, Woman, Gender studies, Male]
1281 words (3.7 pages)
- A typical afternoon consists of my dad laying on the couch from a long day at work, and my mom in the kitchen, preparing dinner. Although we live in an era that has predominantly nullified sex-specific social norms, a difference in gender roles still exists within households. What exactly are gender roles. They are fixed, gender specific expectations, established, in this case, among families. These roles of what should socially be considered masculine and feminine have existed throughout many centuries.... [tags: Gender role, Gender, Sociology, Gender identity]
1303 words (3.7 pages)
- When you mention gender roles in society the first thing that comes to mind usually are stereotypes, or the set labels that society has established on how everyone acts based on the different biological, social, and cultural categories they fit into. Throughout history these stereotypes that pertain to genders roles in society have been proven true. Gender roles refer to a behavioral and social norms that are widely accepted for people of a certain sex. In this report I will discussing the gender roles of the two most recognized types of gender, man and woman, from the perspective of a man and a woman who have lived 65+ years.... [tags: Gender role, Gender, Homemaker, Woman]
1730 words (4.9 pages)