Dewey's Experience In Education and Tyack and Cuban's Tinkering With Utopia

Dewey's Experience In Education and Tyack and Cuban's Tinkering With Utopia

Length: 1592 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Education reform always occur when an educational system is in unrest or crisis. Furthermore, teachers, business leaders, parents, school boards and presidents feel they have the right ingredient to solve the problems of our educational system. It is unfortunate, but history is repeating itself, and we are in a crisis. in education, in the 21st century. This paper compares Dewey’s Experience in Education written in 1938 to Tyack, and Cuban’s Tinkering with Utopia written in 1995 and the striking resemblance to problems voiced 74 years ago. To show the similarity of Dewey and Tyack and Cuban thoughts on education, this paper contrasts and compares their thinking on the purpose of public education, preserving the quality and integrity of education in politicization, in the United States.

Seventy-four years later: Comparison of Dewey, Tyack and Cuban

High dropout rates from high school, low academic scores, school violence and dull classrooms are all contributing to an educational crisis. It is obvious that we are not creating a school climate that engages the students’ mind and prepare students to be a viable part of society.

The span of years between the writing of Dewey’s Experience and Education and the present writing of Tyack and Cuban’s Tinkering Toward Utopia showed distinct differences in the beliefs of Dewey, Tyack and Cuban about the role of education, but conversely, similar views. Dewey based much of his writings on the philosophical perspectives of humanism, pragmatism and social reconstructionism (Dewey, 1938).

This essay will compare and contrast theorist David Tyack and Larry Cuban’s philosophy on education to John Dewey philosophy on education written seventy-four years apart. Although written in di...

... middle of paper ...

...ever eliminated from the education system (Columbia Encyclopedia, 2007). This idea grew steadily in the 17th century and continued to hold to the idea of developing the individual for society (Columbia Encyclopedia, 2007). Later John Dewey argued that the experimental method should be used for teaching children to recognize the changing environment and solve problems (Dewey, 1938).

Reforms in education always occur when the educational system is in a period of unrest or crisis. Century after century show how hotly debated this topic is. Moreover, individuals, including, business leaders, parents, school boards and presidents feel they have the right ingredient to solve the problems of our educational system. It is unfortunate, but history is repeating itself, and we are now in a period of crisis in the education system in the 21st century (Tyack and Cuban, 1995).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Describe the Causes and Discuss the Effects of the Cuban Revolution.

- The Cuban Revolution, which began in the early 1950’s, was an overthrow of a very corrupt government. It was an attempt to improve the conditions of the Cuban people, but the path was covered in blood and sweat and an informed historian has to ask, was it really worth it. How much actually changed. The main causes of the revolution were the corrupt way in which the country was run, the large role the US played in the running of Cuba and the poor treatment & conditions the lower class Cubans lived with....   [tags: Cuban History]

Powerful Essays
973 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Education in Thomas More's "Utopia"

- The goal of education is to learn, and in this process of learning and being educated there are some greater goals that are served. Education in Thomas More’s Utopia seems to cater to a larger goal, which is to create virtuous persons and citizens, as they are responsible for attaining a flourishing human community. In Shakespeare’s The Tempest there seems to be an underlying idea of a connection between education and a sense of social control. The idea of instilling among his subjects a sense of obedience and influencing their knowledge through education, in order to bring about a feeling of belonging to a nation is prevalent in The Tempest....   [tags: Philosophy ]

Powerful Essays
2623 words (7.5 pages)

The Cuban Revolution Essay

- The time of the Cuban Revolution was a great deal of turmoil, not just in Cuba but in almost every corner of the world. It was 1945, shortly after the end of World War Two, and the Cold War was taking off between the United States and the Soviet Union. Cuba, in the middle of its own war, was caught up in the international politics of the Cold War. The interaction between international and domestic politics played a major role in the outcome of the revolution. The result of the revolution left Fidel Castro in charge of Cuba....   [tags: Cuban Politics]

Powerful Essays
781 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on A Deconstruction Reading of Thomas More's Utopia

- A Deconstruction Reading of Thomas More's Utopia Thomas More's Utopia is the bastard child of European conventions and humanist ideals. Inspired by More's belief in the elevation of human manners, education, and morals, the text also concedes to the omnipresent traditions of European society. While More accepts parentage of the text, he distances himself from its radical notions and thinly veiled condemnation of Europe's establishment. Through the use of a benign narrator, Raphael Hythloday, and the assumption of a royalist persona by a character of his own name, More discloses the tale of the island of Utopia and its communist society....   [tags: Thomas More Utopia Essays]

Powerful Essays
1800 words (5.1 pages)

The Basis of Utopia Essay

- The Basis of Utopia An impractical scheme for social improvement. This is the third definition of the word utopia in the Mirriam-Webster dictionary. Anatole France says it best with this quote regarding utopian societies, „Without the Utopias of other times, men would still live in caves, miserable and naked. It was Utopians that traced the lines of the first city· Out of generous dreams come beneficial realities. Utopia is the principle of all progress, and the essay into a better future.„ The world has been constantly changing over time, new ideas pave paths that lead to better living....   [tags: Utopia Utopias Essays]

Powerful Essays
1199 words (3.4 pages)

Walden's Utopia Essay

- Walden's Utopia In a post-World War Two era, there was much longing for improvement on current society. Burrhus F. Skinner decided to give his take on what he felt were the appropriate steps to take in order to make a true "Utopia." There have been attempts at other utopia's (which is from the Greek for "no place") and Skinner in his book took the best elements of each utopia and put them into one. However, this does not mean that this utopia he creates in his story, called Walden Two, emulating Thoreau's Walden Pond in Maine, is not without flaws....   [tags: Walden Philosophy No Place Utopia]

Free Essays
1695 words (4.8 pages)

Visions of Utopia Essay example

-      Humans have grasped at the concept of "Utopia" for millennia. In his editorial for the September 1983 issue of Isaac Asimov's Science Fiction Magazine, editor Isaac Asimov provided a concise history of utopian literature. According to Asimov, the history of utopian literature began with religious tales of past golden ages or future paradises. (Asimov gives the examples of the Genesis story of creation and expulsion from the Garden of Eden as an example of the first and the eleventh chapter of Isaiah, which contains the famous line "the lion shall lay down with the calf," as an example of the second.) Utopian literature was first presented in a more scientifically designed (as opposed...   [tags: Utopia Essays]

Powerful Essays
3129 words (8.9 pages)

Utopia Essays

- Utopia In the year 1515, a book in Latin text was published which became the most significant and controversial text ever written in the field of political science. Entitled, ‘DE OPTIMO REIPUBLICATE STATU DEQUE NOVA INSULA UTOPIA, clarissimi disertissimique viri THOMAE MORI inclutae civitatis Londinensis civis et Vicecomitis’, translated into English would read, ‘ON THE BEST STATE OF A COMMONWEALTH AND ON THE NEW ISLAND OF UTOPIA, by the Most Distinguished and Eloquent Author THOMAS MORE Citizen and Undersheriff of the Famous City of London.’....   [tags: Utopic Society Social Issues Essays]

Powerful Essays
4263 words (12.2 pages)

Utopia Essay

- Utopia The text Utopia was written by Sir Thomas Moore in 1516, just before the outbreak of the Reformation. More’s life flourished through the late fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries, which were influential years in the Renaissance, a flowering of art and thought that began in Italy and flooded through Europe and England. Humanists often stressed the dignity of man and the power of reason while remaining deeply committed to Christianity. Their thought and writings helped to break the strict religious orthodoxy that had forced itself through the Middle Ages....   [tags: More Philosophy Perfect Society Essays]

Powerful Essays
1170 words (3.3 pages)

Utopia Essay

- Education, Science, Philosophy Summary Though, as has been mentioned earlier, only certain accomplished people are allowed to give up manual labor for intellectual studies, every Utopian child receives a thorough education. The Utopians believe that it is through education that the values and dispositions of citizens are molded. The success of the Utopian educational system is evident in the fact that while most Utopians are engaged in manual labor as a career, in their free time Utopians choose to follow intellectual pursuits....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
426 words (1.2 pages)