Independent Reading Response Questions, Chapters 6-9:
1) Hannah reveals that her best friend is Rosemary, a Catholic girl, and states, “As if that matters (p. 46).” As Chaya, her new friends are in shock upon hearing this. Ester states, “My father will not even let me talk to a goy (p. 47).” Why will Ester’s father not allow this? Why is Hannah not bothered by it? Use text evidence to support your response.
Answer: Esther states, “My father will not even let me talk to a goy.” Her father does not want Esther to be friend with a goy, because he thinks that the goy will influence Esther, negatively. He also thinks that Esther will stop worshipping her religion, since her friend’s religion will change Esther’s point of view of her religion. To continue, her father also thinks that Esther will become a Christian, since she is influenced by her friends. He does not want her to stop worshipping her religion. On the other hand, Hannah states, “As a matter of fact, she’s Catholic,” Hannah said. “As if that matters.” In modern times, Hannah can befriend anyone from any religion. Her parents do not think that she will be religiously influenced by her friends. In fact, she will learn from her friends’ cultures. Nowadays, we find that religion can be an interesting topic, therefore, Hannah finds it normal to have friend with different religions. Finally, I can relate to this, because Hannah and I have many friends that are Catholic or Christian. This of course, is very normal in our time period.
2) Hannah tells stories of her “other” life in which she attends school and looks forward to the weekends. As Chaya, her new friends are again shocked by the fact that she-a girl-attends school. Hannah explains that he...
... middle of paper ...
...htened about being killed, but at least she has known, and this makes her prepared. However, when you do not know that you will be killed, it is much more horrifying. You do not know what will occur, therefore, when you are going to be killed, you will not be prepared for the consequences. Your death will be a surprising attack. I am really thankful that I am not in the Holocaust, therefore, I will not have to face what Hannah is facing. However, if I was in Hannah’s place, at least, I have my knowledge to give me a less surprising and painful death. Lastly, I remember a time where I did not study for a test. At that moment, I already knew that I would not receive a satisfying grade. I was prepared for the divesting moment. Similar to my situation, Hannah knows about the Holocaust, and knows what she will suffer. Therefore, we are both ready for the consequences.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- 1. When Hannah’s head is shaved at the camp, she begins to cry. Gitl makes Hannah promise-“…promise me you will cry no more before these monsters. We will never cry again. ‘Never,’ Hannah agreed…feeling stronger because of the promise…(p. 95).” Why does this promise make her feel stronger. Support your response with text evidence. Gitl states, "Without laughter there is no hope. Without hope there is no life." Crying shows weakness, and if the Jews show weakness, the Nazis will take advantage of that.... [tags: book review and analysis]
1542 words (4.4 pages)
- The Devil’s Arithmetic Independent Reading Response Questions, Chapters 6-9: 1) Hannah reveals that her best friend is Rosemary, a Catholic girl, and states, “As if that matters (p. 46).” As Chaya, her new friends are in shock upon hearing this. Ester states, “My father will not even let me talk to a goy (p. 47).” Why will Ester’s father not allow this. Why is Hannah not bothered by it. Use text evidence to support your response. Answer: Esther states, “My father will not even let me talk to a goy.” Her father does not want Esther to be friend with a goy, because he thinks that the goy will influence Esther, negatively.... [tags: independent reading response questions]
2166 words (6.2 pages)
- The Devil’s Arithmetic is written by Jane Yolen. The story’s main character is Hannah. Hannah is a thirteen year old girl who is unappreciative of her family and everything they do for her. During a Seder dinner, Hannah is transported back in time to rural Poland in 1942. In this time Hannah becomes Chaya. During a wedding procession, she is captured and taken to a concentration camp. In the camp Hannah experienced different kinds of family structures. Some of the family structures Hannah experienced in the camp were with her immediate family, her friendships, and with other strangers.... [tags: Jane Yolen]
693 words (2 pages)
- Jane Yolen's use of structure in the novel Briar Rose is very clever. Her use of allegory and the technique of parallel narrative is very effective in conveying her story which she delivers in a superb fashion. Elements of the story are reveled at specific times to tie in with the theme of growth and development both personal and historical. The use of allegory drives the story along. It is a constant reminder of The Holocaust to ensure the reader is not too captivated by the fairy tale element of the novel.... [tags: Yolen Novel Review Analysis Holocaust]
975 words (2.8 pages)
- According to Ashlock, not only do students need to understand the computations of arithmetic, but also need to have computational fluency, in other words, conceptual understanding. As stated in the Principles and Standards for School Mathematics: Knowing basic number combinations – the single-digit addition and multiplication pairs and their counterparts for subtraction and division – is essential. Equally essential is computational fluency – having and using efficient and accurate methods for computing.... [tags: Addition, Elementary arithmetic, Numerical digit]
1314 words (3.8 pages)
- People are born with different facial structures, heights, and shapes. But in our current society, most people imagine the ideal woman to be tall and slender. In the poem “Fat Is Not a Fairy Tale” by Jane Yolen, the speaker expresses her view through parody, foreshadowing, and figurative language that a more full-figured image of a woman’s beauty will someday prevail. Yolen makes use of parody to effectively state her view that fairy tale princesses shouldn’t have to be skinny to be considered beautiful.... [tags: Poetry Analysis]
618 words (1.8 pages)
- was walking Rodger with his hand on his shoulder saying, “This is my number one man he can get the job done whatever I tell him to do.” In the dream I stepped outside the building going over to Rodger letting him know I wanted to talk to him. He gets angry and he stood there with a frown on his face looking at me but I knew it was the devil leading him. Rodger don’t give up on God you are better than this you are being deceived the devil is deceiving you. Rodger slid down to the ground with his hands on his head.... [tags: God, Devil, Need, Text messaging]
761 words (2.2 pages)
- In the New Testament, Matthew 4: 1-11 told a story of Jesus, whom fasted for forty days and forty nights, being tempted by the devil. The devil, whom is referred in text as Satan and the tempter, and challenged Jesus on three different temptations. All which would distract him away from his test and from The Lord, God himself. According to William Loyd Allen in his article “The Devil at the Crossroads”, he explains in Matthew 4 how “Jesus’ temptations in Matthew 4 came at the stage-appropriate time, but their configuration owed more to conditional sources of crisis than developmental ones” .... [tags: Jesus, God, Devil, God in Christianity]
1153 words (3.3 pages)
- Mary Jane: The Devil Weed ABSTRACT: This paper, entitled "Mary Jane: The Devil Weed?" attempts to examine what we know about marijuana and what problems are associated with its use. The paper examines briefly the history of marijuana legislation, marijuana's known effects, and conclusions about its danger. Early in this century, the government waged a war of terrorism on marijuana, or cannabis sativa. "By 1937, forty-six states had laws against the use of marijuana, and its use had already been made a criminal offense under federal law" (Jaffe, 659).... [tags: essays research papers fc]
821 words (2.3 pages)
- The book Briar Rose follows closely with the fairy tale Sleeping Beauty. Becca Berlin’s grandmother, Gemma, was being held in a secret concentration camp called Chelmno. She was put in the gas chamber and she was rendered unconscious rather than dead. She was dumped in a ditch with dead bodies. Josef Potocki and his band of rebels where tampering with the railroads leading to and from the camp. The group finds Gemma in the ditch and the doctor of the group, Avenger, revives her with CPR. Gemma and Avenger fall in love and are soon married.... [tags: story and character analysis]
883 words (2.5 pages)