A fairly obvious comparison between these two stories is the setting in which they take place. Both occur in New England territory, mainly in the forests and hilly country. It also seems as if the land in each of the tales is rocky and hard to work. The geographical features of these lands sound much the same. In fact, each of the two takes place in an area very close to, if not in, Massachusetts. Tom Walker lives a few miles from Boston, while Jabez Stone lives in New Hampshire, near the area where that state meets up with Vermont and Massachusetts. Daniel Webster lives in Massachusetts, in a town called Marshfield. The geographical and cartographical similarities here show an obvious parallel between the two.
The motivation of the Faustian character is to a great extent the same. Both Tom Walker and Jabez Stone manifestly want a better life than what they had. Each character is down on their luck. Walker lives in “a forlorn-looking house that stood alone, and had an air of starvation” (Irving 259) while Stone is “an unlucky man” (“Daniel Webster”). Each of the...
... middle of paper ...
...niel Webster”). This version of Old Scratch is obviously not the rugged, “manly-man” of Irving’s writing. As noted later, this devil also has teeth filed to a point. By introducing the Devil in such a light, Benét is apotheosizing his mental power as opposed to physical power. This creature is more than a match for the smartest human who will be pitted against him. Showing the Devil like this early in the story makes Daniel Webster’s victory over him later all the better.
Both “The Devil and Tom Walker” and “The Devil and Daniel Webster” are exemplary specimens of Faustian myths, and as such have very many similarities and concurrences. But, they also emphasize different aspects of the characters and their respective personalities. These two commendable stories serve as excellent chronicles of literature and as worthy examples of moral lessons for all ages.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Intent and Motive in The Devil and Tom Walker and The Devil and Daniel Webster Washington Irving, in writing "The Devil and Tom Walker", and Stephen Vincent Benet, in writing "The Devil and Daniel Webster" illustrate to the reader the consequences of man's desire for material wealth and how a person's motivation for a relationship with the devil affects the outcome of the "deal". In these two different, yet surprisingly similar narratives, the authors present their beliefs about human intent and motive.... [tags: Tom Walker Daniel Webster Essays Papers]
1563 words (4.5 pages)
- I would hate to be Thomas Black Bull. Tom the main character of the story is often forced into many of his situations; such as losing his parents, throwing many rodeo titles, or being used or pushed around by other people. This book fits many of the bildunsroman genre because of the protagonist, the theme of the story, and the amount of external conflicts Tom is forced to face with. In the beginning of the story Tom loses both his parents at a very young age. Since Tom’s father died in the avalanche, he was forced to take the role of a man as a boy.... [tags: When the Legends Die, characters,]
543 words (1.6 pages)
- Distortions of the Daniel Boone Legend and Their Impact  The silent film, With Daniel Boone Thru the Wilderness, was produced in 1926: a time of prosperity, an era without the skepticism of the modern American mind. People were not yet questioning the stories and histories they had been taught as children. The entertaining story told in this Robert North Bradbury film is loosely based on the life of an American hero. However, the presence of several insidiously inaccurate historical representations demonstrates how an entertaining film might not be as innocent as it initially seems.... [tags: Daniel Boone Essays]
2899 words (8.3 pages)
- Daniel Defoe born in or around 1660 experienced the most complex disastrous events in England before he was seven. In 1664 a Dutch fleet attacked London, in 1665 the plague took seventy thousand lives and in 1666 the great fire destroyed Defoe’s neighborhood expect for three houses, one being his. Born to a family of dissenters a class of people who refused to conform to the Church of England, Defoe was hindered with obstacles from the start. Receiving his education from a dissenter’s school and as West indicates: “barred from Oxford and Cambridge and instead received three years of higher education under the Reverend Charles Morton, a future vice–president of Harvard University who drilled... [tags: Work of Daniel Defoe]
1248 words (3.6 pages)
- ... Urban legends are a type of folklore that separate itself from fictional novels since they spread through the means of socialization. Traditionally, they have spread by word of mouth, which is why urban legends have been previously referred to as a friend-of-a-friend stories. They are often told to be real life events and tend to have a darkness to them used to give a warning or tell a moral. Urban legends would more accurately be described as contemporary legends, since these legends tend to reflect upon the current time period and deal with real social issues.... [tags: ancient greek, legends, myths]
1104 words (3.2 pages)
- To Believe or Not To Believe Modern Urban Legends Many people have heard the tale of the dotty grandmother who tried to dry off her damp poodle by placing it in the microwave oven. The dog exploded, sad to say the least , and Grandma has never been quite the same since. The story is not true; it is an urban legend, circulating by word of mouth since the 1970s (Brunvand, 108). Urban legends are popular stories alleged to be true and transmitted from person to person by oral or written communication.... [tags: essays research papers]
1488 words (4.3 pages)
- Circular Life(When The Legends Die) When the Legends Die, by Hal Borland, is a novel in which traces the life of Tom Black Bull from a young Indian boy to an older, mature adult. Thus meaning When the Legends Die is a bildungsroman. A bildungsroman is a novel in which the protagonist from beginning to the end matures, and in a classic bildungsroman, undergoes a spiritual crisis. His life is filled with many obstacles and affected by many people positively and negatively. Throughout the story he overcomes these obstacles and lives through the people.... [tags: When Legends Die Essays]
796 words (2.3 pages)
- The Introduction: According to A Handbook to Literature, folk tales are short narratives passed down through oral tradition, with various tellers and groups modifying them, that they become stories of cumulative authorship (Holman 207), which means that no one person decided how the tales should be. A folk tale that I am familiar with is the story of King Arthur. King Arthur is represented as being a great man, leader and king and is an icon of good morality and the values of England, which is why the tale has continued to be told.... [tags: Legends of King Arthur]
1676 words (4.8 pages)
- Relationships play a large part in the average modern day person's everyday life, just as relationships were important in the past. Although types of companionships have somewhat changed over time, the presence and importance of them still remains. Viewing, analysing and comparing other individual's relationships to our own is something most people do, as a sort of assurance that things are natural. This is why many people are interested in novels about ways that other human beings interact with individuals and groups.... [tags: Daniel Defoe Roxana]
1050 words (3 pages)
- When the Legends Die Setting The term setting refers to the time and place of a story or play. There are four different settings in this book. It is like this because the book is divided into four different sections. The four sections are Bessie, The School, The Arena, and The Mountains. All of these sections have totally different settings. First, I will discuss the first section of the book, Bessie. In Bessie, The setting takes place in a town called Pagosa and in the Bald Mountains. The start of the book is in the town.... [tags: When the Legends Die]
2952 words (8.4 pages)