Deterrence Theorists and Capital Punishment Essay

Deterrence Theorists and Capital Punishment Essay

Length: 909 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Deterrence theorists view murder as rational behavior, and assume that in calculating the gains and losses from killing, potential offenders are aware of the death penalty and regard it as a more severe sanction than imprisonment. Because the threat of one's own death presumably outweighs the rewards gained from killing another, murder is not an option for most people and always discouraged. In addition, some noted proponents assert that capital punishment provides an important educative function in society by validating the sanctity of human life (Berns, 1979; van den Haag, 1975; van den Haag & Conrad, 1983). Despite this logic, some challenge the applicability of deterrence to murder. Rather than being a product of deliberation and calculation, it is known that most murders are emotionally charged and their crimes are spontaneous events; they are "acts of passion" or result from a situated transaction rather than from deliberation (Bowers & Pierce, 1980; Chambliss, 1967; Luckenbill, 1977). Indeed, a significant proportion of homicides may not be intended. The situation escapes calm discussion, or due to some extraneous factor, an assault victim dies. Under such conditions, it is unlikely that perpetrators ("killers") give serious thought to whether they reside in a death penalty jurisdiction, or the possibility of execution.
Raymond T. Bye describes the basis for the theory of deterrence in the idea that the privilege to live and therefore an individual’s life is the most sacred and only thing any human really owns. Because of this, threatening an individual with the consequence of death will cause them to decide not to engage in the criminal activity. There is a spectrum of consequences that individuals mentally process for...

... middle of paper ...

...New England area and northern-more Middle West area, and the higher rates found in Michigan, Indiana, and Ohio. Sellin grouped the states according to geography but made sure that the populations of each group also had similar social and economic conditions. Within these groups he found it impossible to distinguish the abolition state from the non-abolition states according to crime rates. Therefore, he found the homicide death rates of these grouped states to be similar, no matter their position on the death penalty. The inevitable conclusion is that all things remaining the same, executions have no discernible effect on rates of homicide. This study sparked debate and lead many other researchers to conduct their own analysis of data at different points in time up to the present in order to support or contradict Sellin’s findings in accordance with their own views.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Punishment for the Sake of Deterrence is Justified Essay

- Introduction The author is a strong supporter of the notion that "punishment for the sake of deterrence is justified", and this is because people tend to obey the law after calculating the consequences attached by the law to a particular act of crime. Punishing a person for a crime in order to deter others from performing the same crime again does not guarantee us that the crime will never be performed by anyone at all, but it definitely lowers the number of people who would commit the same crime in future....   [tags: Deterrence Theory of Punishment]

Good Essays
2543 words (7.3 pages)

Capital Punishment And The Death Penalty Essay

- When is murder ever justifiable. That is a question that needs to be asked when discussing the righteousness or wickedness of capital punishment, or more simply stated, the death penalty. The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy describes the act of capital punishment as deliberately killing an individual for a criminal offense, usually a serious offense such as murder or treason (Murtagh, n.d.). Taken at face value, capital punishment is premeditated murder committed by a governing authority justified by law as the punishment for the crime committed....   [tags: Capital punishment, Crime]

Good Essays
1537 words (4.4 pages)

The Ethics of Capital Punishment Essay

- Americans have argued over the death penalty since the early days of our country. In the United States only 38 states have capital punishment statutes. As of year ended in 1999, in Texas, the state had executed 496 prisoners since 1930. The laws in the United States have change drastically in regards to capital punishment. An example of this would be the years from 1968 to 1977 due to the nearly 10 year moratorium. During those years, the Supreme Court ruled that capital punishment violated the Eight Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Good Essays
1503 words (4.3 pages)

The Death Penalty Of Capital Punishment Essay

- In 2007, the United States placed fifth in the world for highest executions per year, around 220, just under Iraq’s 256 (Rogers). Executions are categorized under capital punishment, which is the act of legally killing someone for a crime he or she committed. Commonly known as the death penalty, capital punishment dates back to the beginning of human societies, and even civilizations. Although there are thousands of years of history to back this up, the death penalty has become a very potent discussion, one that abolitionists and anti-abolitionists debate every day; and it is one that civil and justice systems want to, and need to, revise....   [tags: Crime, Capital punishment, Criminology, Prison]

Good Essays
1229 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about Two Types of Criminal Deterrence

- There are two different types if deterrence, the first is classified as specific deterrence. The goal of this category of deterrence is to lessen the probability of having a repeat offender. The three strikes law is an example of one of the methods that is used to assist this category of deterrence. The other category of deterrence is general deterrence. This category focuses more on future offenders. General deterrence attempts to positively influence would be offenders and stop the crimes before they happen....   [tags: Law]

Good Essays
868 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on The Debate Over Capital Punishment

- The debate over capital punishment has been raging on for countless number of years. Capital punishment has been used for thousands of years due to the physiological fear it inflicts on the people who witness and learn about the death penalty. The use of this punishment has helped to reduce crime and alter the minds of future criminals to deter them against committing heinous crimes such as murder, treason, espionage, terrorism and in some cases aggravated kidnapping. Advocates say it deters crime while abolitionists say it is unconstitutional....   [tags: Capital Punishment]

Good Essays
1139 words (3.3 pages)

The Death Penalty Of Capital Punishment Essay

- One of the most repetitive and controversial topics discussed in the criminal justice system, is the death penalty. Capital punishment has been a part of our nation’s history since the creation of our constitution. In fact, as of January 1st, 2016, 2,943 inmates were awaiting their fate on death row (Death Penalty Information Center). Throughout my life, I have always been a strong advocate for the death penalty. During the majority of my undergraduate degree, I was a fierce supporter of capital punishment when discussing the topic in classes....   [tags: Murder, Capital punishment, Crime]

Good Essays
2435 words (7 pages)

Capital Punishment: An Ongoing Arguement Essay example

- Since the year 1608, over 15,269 people have been executed in the United States and its predecessor colonies (Smykla, and Espy). With the multitude of persons executed, there is still little evidence proving the effectiveness of capital punishment when concerning future violent crime rates. The death penalty is also costly when compared to the cost of imprisoning a violent criminal for life. With such a definitive punishment and with its finality, there have also been a large number of persons executed who were in fact shown to be innocent at a later time....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Good Essays
1042 words (3 pages)

The Abolition Of Capital Punishment Essay examples

- Capital Punishment British law has been predominant in Canada until 1859 in which around two hundred and thirty infractions including the stealing of turnips used to be punishable by death. Later in 1865, due to the law change, only murder, treason, and rape are considered capital offences. The first attempt to abolish this unusual punishment is taken in 1914 by a parliamentarian, Robert Bickerdike. He stated strongly in the house that, “there is nothing more degrading to society at large…than the death penalty”....   [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Prison]

Good Essays
1469 words (4.2 pages)

Capital Punishment Essay

- a) Through the Utilitarian perspective, Bedau is a firm believer in the removal of capital punishment; Bedau thinks that no reason is good enough justify the more severe punishment like death penalty on the moral ground, and no evidence of deterrence and prevention is sufficient enough to support the retribution of justice to keep capital punishment. Bedau have raised several arguments direct to the issue of death penalty: The morality of self-defense and death penalty; the efficiency prevention and the deterrence through capital punishment; then finally the inequity treatment towards the racially disadvantaged and poor....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Good Essays
2003 words (5.7 pages)