Descartes: Relationship Between Mind and Body Essay

Descartes: Relationship Between Mind and Body Essay

Length: 935 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Meditation Six entitled “Concerning the Existence of Material Things, and Real Distinction between the Mind and Body”, one important thing Descartes explores is the relationship between the mind and body. Descartes believes the mind and body are separated and they are two difference substances. He believes this to be clearly and distinctly true which is a Cartesian quality for true knowledge. I, on the other hand, disagree that the mind and body are separate and that the mind can exist without the body. First, I will present Descartes position on mind/body dualism and his proof for such ideas. Secondly, I will discuss why I think his argument is weak and offer my own ideas that dispute his reasoning while I keep in mind how he might dispute my argument.
Descartes argues that the mind and body can be thought of as separate substances. Descartes writes “I have a body that is very closely joined to me, nevertheless, because … I have a clear and distinct idea of myself, insofar as I am merely a thinking thing and not an extended thing and because … I have a distinct idea of a body, insofar as it is merely an extended thing and not a thinking thing, it is certain that I am really distinct from my body and can exist without it” ( Descartes 50). With this quote, Descartes is saying that the mind and body are separate because he has two distinct ideas of the body and the mind and the body is not a thinking thing as he is but an extended substance. Another point to Descartes argument is that the mind and body are different due to one being indivisible and the other being divisible. Descartes writes “a body, by its very nature, is always divisible. On the other hand, the mind is utterly indivisible” (53). Here is saying that there are ...

... middle of paper ...

...ning of mind is something that cannot be divisible but that is hard to see because I have already proved that by my understanding of the mind it has parts. It is also hard to think of a mind or soul that does not have such things as memory and personality therefore I believe Descartes argument is false.
In short, I summarized Descartes position of the relationship of the mind and body. After that I discussed two objections to his argument which were related to the mind existing without the body and that the mind is not divisible while I discussed how Descartes might respond to these arguments. These arguments adequately show that Descartes argument for mind/body dualism is false.

Works Cited

Descartes. "Descartes, Meditations on First Philosophy." Readings in Modern Philosophy. Ed. Roger Ariew and Eric Watkins. Vol. I. Indianapolis: Hackett, 2000. 22-55. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on How did Descartes Explain the Relationship between Mind and Body?

- Across the years, many scientists and philosophers believed that a human being is made up by mind and body (Radner, 1971). Some of them believed that the mind-soul is something different from the body and each of them works by themselves without any interaction between them (Radner, 1971). The other point of view said that body and mind works together as a unity and mutually influences each other and the result is the human being. This view had been held by great figures like the Greek philosopher Aristotle and Aquinas (Radner, 1971)....   [tags: rene descartes, mind and body, aristotle]

Better Essays
1105 words (3.2 pages)

Descartes: Shedding Light on the Mind Body Relationship Essay

- Many philosophers have tried to explain the distinction between the mind and body. They have tried to explain how the body affects the mind and how the mind affects the body and if they can exist without one another. The reason was to enlighten people in the attempt to replace faith in religion reasoning with proof of scientific facts and reasoning. One philosopher who stood out and developed this movement to shed light on the mind and body relationship was a French philosopher by the name of Descartes....   [tags: Philosophy]

Better Essays
934 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Relationship of the Mind and the Body: The Person

- Can the mind exist without the body. Can the body exist without the mind. Surely in this day and age, there are artificial ways to keep the body alive even if the brain is pronounced dead. Likewise, the body can be completely immobilized, in a coma, yet the mind can still be alive and active. But can either really exist in its entirety on its own, performing its functions as usual, and in the same manner as if it was still in union with its partner. In his book, Discourse on the Method and Meditations on First Philosophy, Rene Descartes analyzes the mind and the body as two entirely distinct and separate entities....   [tags: philosphy, descartes, aquinas]

Better Essays
1084 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Descartes ' Theory Of The Mind And Body

- The foundation of Descartes’ theory of the mind and body rests upon his famous notion: ‘I think therefore I am’. As a prime advocate of modern philosophy, Descartes was both a rationalist and a substance dualist. He proposed the mind and body dualism theory in an attempt to explain everything physical. For Descartes, in order for material things to exist, the mind and body have to be separate entities. This essay will explore Descartes’ account on the relationship between the mind and body, through his accounts in his series, Meditations and go onto analyse Descartes’ arguments for the separation of the mind and body as two clear and distinct entities....   [tags: Mind, Philosophy of mind, Dualism, Thought]

Better Essays
1398 words (4 pages)

Essay about Descartes ' Theory Of Mind And Body

- Throughout Descartes First and Second Meditations the philosopher explores the relationship between mind and body and therefore the contrasts which arise. Meditation One covers the nature of the mind and how this relates to the concept of reality. In Meditation Two Descartes uses the questioning of everything in order to clarify this nature, and ultimately make connections to the body and physical world. In conclusion, the philosopher ties together the complex concept of mind and body using a metaphorical piece of wax....   [tags: Mind, Ontology, Perception, Metaphysics]

Better Essays
1227 words (3.5 pages)

Descartes ' Ontology And Its Impact On The Mind Of Thinking Essay

- Descartes’ ontology endeavoured to distinguish between veracity and falsity. He introduced to the realm of philosophy a paradoxical way of thinking wherein one reached the state of certainty after a having been through a continuum of doubt. This essay traces the conception of crucial Cartesian definitions such as that of a human being and explicates Descartes perception of the positioning of humans and beasts on the Great Chain of Being. Descartes begins his meditations by challenging his epistemological dispositions and rejecting any ideas or opinions which he can find reason to doubt (Descartes,13)....   [tags: Mind, Perception, René Descartes, Thought]

Better Essays
861 words (2.5 pages)

Analysis of Descartes’ Mind/Body Distinction Essay

- In his Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes states “I have a clear and distinct idea of myself, in as far as I am only a thinking and unextended thing, and as, on the other hand, I possess a distinct idea of body, in as far as it is only an extended and unthinking thing”. [1] The concept that the mind is an intangible, thinking entity while the body is a tangible entity not capable of thought is known as Cartesian Dualism. The purpose of this essay is to examine how Descartes tries to prove that the mind or soul is, in its essential nature, entirely distinct from the body and whether or not he is successful....   [tags: Descartes Meditation One 2014]

Better Essays
1172 words (3.3 pages)

Descartes and the Existence of Physical Objects Essay

- Descartes and the Existence of Physical Objects In his sixth meditation Descartes must return to the doubts he raised in his first one. Here he deals mainly with the mind-body problem and tries to prove whether material things exist with certainty. In this meditation he develops his dualist argument; by making a distinction between mind and body; although he also reveals that the are significantly related. He considers existence of the external world and whether its perception holds any knowledge of this world....   [tags: Descartes]

Better Essays
669 words (1.9 pages)

Cartesian Dualism : The Mind And The Body Essay

- Cartesian dualism refers to the notion that the human being consists of two distinct substances – the mind and the body. Today this idea is taken for granted, so it is difficult to imagine that when it is was first theorized by Rene Descartes; it was a truly revolutionary idea. According to Descartes, the mind and body are two essentially different things that causally interact. The mind is an immaterial thing responsible for thought that is somehow connected to the body - a material thing, through which sense perception is possible....   [tags: Mind, Perception, Thought, Cognition]

Better Essays
1463 words (4.2 pages)

The Existence Of Understanding The Mind Body Problem Essay

- Descartes pursuit of understanding the mind-body problem eventually led to the Cartesian theory; build on the principle that mind and body are respectively different. This school of thought is built on the concept that the body occupies space while the mind doesn’t. Material properties are transformed to the imagining, because once things become structured the outcome are properties, which are the elements that make them up. Previously only material, when properties become combined they become emotional, thus a consciousness is formed....   [tags: Mind, Psychology, Philosophy of mind]

Better Essays
1093 words (3.1 pages)