Denying The Ideal : Comparison Between The Speakers And ' The Nymph 's Reply Of The Shepherd '

Denying The Ideal : Comparison Between The Speakers And ' The Nymph 's Reply Of The Shepherd '

Length: 1413 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Denying the Ideal: The Comparison of the Speakers in
“The Passionate Shepherd to His Love” and “The Nymph’s Reply to the Shepherd”
Christopher Marlowe and Sir Walter Raleigh both create speakers who disagree about the nature of romantic love. The titles of the twin poems, “The Passionate Shepherd to His Love,” by Marlowe, and “The Nymph’s Reply to the Shepherd,” by Raleigh, show that they are two sides of a rhetorical exchange. The poems’ structures are identical; each of the shepherd’s optimistic requests has a corresponding refusal from the nymph. Although the word choice and meters are similar in the two poems, the shepherd uses an optimistic tone while the nymph uses a pessimistic one. While both speakers are addressing the concept of love, their distinct uses of diction and imagery underscore how the shepherd’s optimism conflicts with the nymph’s skepticism.
In Marlowe 's poem, the romantic shepherd expresses his emotions in an idyllic setting. The title directly informs the reader that the shepherd is “passionate,” but the word “shepherd” is essential to identifying the speaker. A shepherd tends to and watches over his flock, and this shepherd speaks as if he will act in a similar way with his love: “come live with me and be my love.” Moreover, he does not focus so much on the appearance of his lover or himself, but on the “pleasures” and “delights” that he will give her if she accepts his offer. For instance, his offer to “make thee beds of roses” is a way of showering her with luxury. Furthermore, he says they will sit by “shallow rivers;” the word “shallow” suggests transparency and simplicity, implying that he desires instant gratification. The shepherd 's emphasis on luxury and pleasures shows that he is motivated t...

... middle of paper ...

...choice and imagery by both Marlowe and Raleigh draw attention to the conflicting tones in the speakers of the poems. When reading the poems together in this way, the significance of the poems as separate pieces changes completely. Marlowe’s effort to romanticize the idea of love and to provoke an emotional feeling is immediately exposed as an illusion in Raleigh’s poem of reply. In effect, these complementary poems raise the possibility that at the same time the nymph is replying to the shepherd’s proposal, Raleigh is responding to the idea of love conveyed in Marlowe’s poem. As Marlowe’s poem represents the optimistic, romanticized view of a perfect union, Raleigh represents the reality that real love almost never follows that course. Raleigh responds to the way people think about love and poetry while writing about a nymph replying to a shepherd 's request of love.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Approaches Of Development Proposed By The Speakers Essay

- This essay interweaves the approaches of development proposed by the speakers’ presentations and discussions held during the seminars of Perspectives in International Development throughout the Fall Semester 2015. The common thread among the different approaches would be the role that building human and social capital may play in achieving the goal of development. The essay considers nutrition as a form of physical human capital, and a precondition for developing other dimensions of human capital....   [tags: Sociology, Food, Nutrition, Economic development]

Strong Essays
1439 words (4.1 pages)

Ideal Alignment: Execute Movement most Efficiently and Safety Essay

- In dance, the term ‘ideal alignment’ refers to the body at the state of which allows the dancer to execute movement most efficiently and safely. Correct alignment can relieve muscle tension and stress, which can be greatly assisted through imagery. Eric Franklin stated that "Posture reveals our genetic and social heritage as well as the sum of our accumulated mental and physical habits." Posture constantly fluctuates due to one’s psychological state (Franklin, E 1996). As a result, dancers must be able to recognise these postural changes and adapt their movement accordingly....   [tags: dance, ideal aligment, posture]

Strong Essays
1232 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Monolingual Vs. Monolingual English Speakers

- In today’s society, especially in the United States, most people are monolingual English speakers. As a result, these monolingual speakers are at a significant disadvantage compared to those who speak more than one language fluently. This disadvantage is crucial to realize since it is important to learn how individuals and the nation can be enhanced. Multilingual speakers have an advantage in global affairs that involve countries that speak different languages. Speaking multiple languages makes it easier to communicate with people when involved in foreign affairs....   [tags: Linguistics, Culture, Multilingualism, Language]

Strong Essays
1109 words (3.2 pages)

Denying that the Holocaust Essay

- How can history be denied. History is not always pretty, or nice but nothing will change it. The Holocaust was one of the most devastating things to ever happen, but it DID happen. The denial of this piece of history should be illegal. One cannot deny this event and the vital impact that it had on the world. Denying that the Holocaust happened should be illegal because it affected millions of people, there are facts to back it up, and learning about the Holocaust will help prevent it from happening again....   [tags: german politics, nazi, jewish]

Strong Essays
861 words (2.5 pages)

Oscar Wilde 's An Ideal Husband Essay

- A very intelligent novelist, Oscar Wilde, catches his reader’s attention in his satirical play, An Ideal Husband, through a humorous drama filled political scandal and blackmail. Wilde sucks his audience into the romantic comedy by placing the reader with the characters throughout all their battles—in which he points out their bad habits and their faults. Wilde accomplishes drawing readers in by creating the satirical message of his play through satirical elements such as exaggeration, sarcasm, and irony....   [tags: Irony, Sarcasm, Oscar Wilde, An Ideal Husband]

Strong Essays
1499 words (4.3 pages)

Ideal Life vs. Reality through In the Desert by Steven Crane Essay

- Stephen Crane was a realistic, American author. He also wrote little bits of Naturalism and Impressionism. As a child, Crane was constantly sick. In fact, he was so sick that his parents worried he would not make it. After losing four children before Crane was born, Crane’s parents had reason to worry about losing him. Despite his unhealthy nature, Stephen taught himself to read by the age of four. Crane is seen as the most groundbreaking writer of his generation by many modern day authors. A major theme that is seen throughout Stephen Crane’s writing is the sense of ideal life versus reality....   [tags: poem, ideal, reality]

Strong Essays
818 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on The Secret's Speakers

- The secret’s reputation is almost solely based on the people who have come together and combined their individual insights into a nearly a universal outlook on life. John Assaraf, James Arthur Ray, Bob Doyle, Morris Goodman, and John Hagelin are a few of the contributing speakers in the secret and their reputations in each field of study are truly the backbone of the secrets reliability. But really, who are these people. John Assaraf was headed down the wrong rode at twice the speed limit when he was a teen....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Strong Essays
1053 words (3 pages)

Comaparison of The Crucible and Sommersby Essay

- Sometimes two things may seem like they have nothing in common but when analyzed more critically one may find many similarities. A good example of this would be between The Crucible and Sommersby. These two stories may seem like they have nothing in common; one, The Crucible, is about the Salem witch trials, the other, Sommersby, is about a POW returning home after six years. These two stories may appear to be totally different but they do in fact share many similarities. Three of the characters in The Crucible are very similar to three characters in Sommersby....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
796 words (2.3 pages)

A Speakers Reflections Essay

- A Speaker’s Reflections Robert Hayden’s poem “Those Winter Sundays” is a reflection the speaker has regarding his father. An analysis of the poem’s tone and language reveals the speaker regrets his father did so much for the family and “no one ever thanked him”. It is obvious the speaker feels regret for the way he behaved toward his father in the past by examining the phrases in the poem, particularly with the description of the father. The connotations of the language used in this description denote the father in a certain way that the speaker did not see him as before....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
853 words (2.4 pages)

Denying Premise Essay

- The quest to find out who we are, where we came from, where we will go after we die and what, if anything, controls our world has fascinated mankind throughout the centuries. Famous philosophers have devoted their whole lives to developing theories, and yet the closest any have come to success has been to not have their theories disproved. With the knowledge that no theory has been proven to fact, “I don’t know” may be the only true answer to one of civilization’s oldest questions. The idea that we can never know the answers to these and many other questions leads to the theory of Skepticism....   [tags: Philosophy]

Free Essays
1705 words (4.9 pages)