Denial of John Walker Lindh's Constitutional Rights Essay

Denial of John Walker Lindh's Constitutional Rights Essay

Length: 1867 words (5.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Bill of Rights was ratified and in full effect in 1791. It spelled out rights and freedoms which protected citizens from the government and gave them, most especially; protections under the law against criminal accusations made against them. In 2001, John Walker Lindh (known to some as the “American Taliban”) became an accused man; he was an American citizen and alleged anti-American terrorist. Lindh was denied a number of rights vital to make his proper, fair, and full defense. Lindh’s constitutional rights should have been upheld despite the charges against him and any possible intelligence towards the war on terror he may have had; for there is a slippery-slope to denying someone these constitutional rights.
The glitch in Lindh’s case, for all American citizens, is that if the story were to play out right; any one of them could be without their constitutional protections. To the founders of the United States Constitution felt that government most certainly has the right to accuse you, me, or anyone else; but also that, under the law, we should have constitutional rights providing us with a fair trial and defense against such accusations.
Due process and Habeas Corpus are two of the very important pillars upon which American democracy and freedoms are based. Without these rights there is no system to fight against the tyranny of the government; and it is such tyranny that the founders of the constitution fought vehemently against. While these ideas of due process of law and habeas corpus were not new to the founders and the foundation of these freedoms can be found in a much older historical document called the Magna Carta, they found them to be of the utmost importance. In 39th clause of the Magna Carta, King John d...


... middle of paper ...


...g that probably only warranted a few years due to a mistake made in childlike innocence, or he should have been more severely punished if he was actually guilty. By denying Lindh his legal and constitutional rights the government did no one justice.



Works Cited

Andrews, John. "US Torture of John Walker Lindh Exposed as Frame-up Continues." World Socialist Web Site. 25 June 2002. Web. 20 Oct. 2011.
Coffin v. United States. Supreme Court. 4 Mar. 1895. Print.
Davis, G. R. C. Magna Carta. London: British Library, 1996. Print.
Mayer, Jane. "LOST IN THE JIHAD." The New Yorker 10 Mar. 2003: p.50. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 20 Oct. 2011.
Welte, Jim. "John Walker Lindh's Father Persists With Legal Fight - San Anselmo-Fairfax, CA Patch." San Anselmo-Fairfax, CA Patch - News, Sports, Events, Businesses & Deals. Patch Network, 16 Feb. 2011. Web. 20 Oct. 2011.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

John Walker Lindh and Constitutional Rights Essay

- In 1791 the Bill of Rights was ratified and in full effect. It spelled out rights and freedoms which protected citizens from the government and gave them, most especially; protections under the law against criminal accusations made against them. In 2001, John Walker Lindh (known to some as the “American Taliban”) became an accused man; he was an American citizen and alleged anti-American terrorist. Lindh was denied a number of rights vital to make his proper, fair, and full defense. Lindh’s constitutional rights should have been upheld despite the charges against him and any possible intelligence towards the war on terror he may have had; for there is a slippery-slope to denying someone the...   [tags: Bill of Rights, Habeas Corpus, Due Process]

Term Papers
615 words (1.8 pages)

Stop and Frisk Violates Constitutional Rights Essay example

- There should not be people who abuse their power through the law; however, in New York City (NYC) cops are using their authority in a negative way. Mayor Michael Bloomberg, 2009 to 2013, implemented a policy called stop and frisk where the New York City Police Department (NYPD) has the right to question and search anybody who looks suspicious. Because of this act in NYC, many men and women, especially of color, have protested against the policy. In addition, the Pierce County Tribune’s article “Stop and Frisk Practice Ethically, Morally Wrong” by Bryce Berginski argues that stop and frisk violates the fourth and fourteenth amendment....   [tags: Constitutional Rights vs. Public Safety]

Term Papers
1042 words (3 pages)

Essay on The Constitutional And Unconstitutional Rights

- ... Evidence that could have possibly been collected under an illegal search or no warrant during the time the crime took place due to the exclusionary rule that protects rights of the citizens the evidence will not be admissible as follows. The reasoning for this exclusionary rule prevents thee government from resenting evidence in trial, which was gathered in violation of the fourth amendment protection against illegal search and seizure. The doctrine is used most common in American Courts. This exclusionary rule discourages police and law enforcement from obtaining illegal evidence or evidence collected without a search warrant....   [tags: Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution]

Term Papers
998 words (2.9 pages)

Denial of Human Rights in Egypt Essay

- In the United States we enjoy religious and political freedoms that are not always practiced in other countries of the world. In fact in Egypt there is no tolerance for opposing viewpoints and diverse religious beliefs. These polarized views have often times led to violent behavior. In 2004, members of the Islamic extremists bombed the Hilton Taba hotel in Egypt which killed 34 tourists in hopes of destabilizing Egypt (Omer…). For years the Islamic extremists have been terrorizing and violating the rights of the Egyptian people, as well as innocent bystanders that have come to visit Egypt....   [tags: Opposing Viewpoints, Religious Beliefs]

Term Papers
1463 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Students' Rights

- In the constitution we the people are guaranteed certain rights. Those rights include life liberty and the pursuit of happiness. These are guaranteed to the people as long as we follow the laws of the land. There are twenty-seven amendments to the United States constitution. The most important one in my opinion, is the first one. It states “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.” (Constitutional Topic: Student Rights - The U.S....   [tags: Constitutional Rights]

Term Papers
1890 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on The Denial Of The Holocaust

- ... Occasionally, survivors of mass killing operations bore witness to the killing program” (USHMM). Arad mentions about the success of the Soviet Army that helped to provide more evidence about the Holocaust, “by the summer of 1943, the Soviet army had advanced into Nazi occupied land and prevented the Germans from completing their plan to erase all evidence” (355-366). The Germans took extreme measures to not leave behind any evidence of the top secret operation by the use code words, and verbally commanding the officers (355)....   [tags: Nazi Germany, Adolf Hitler, Holocaust denial]

Term Papers
1254 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Constitutional Rights of Worship

- Introduction In her obiter dicta of Kruger v Commonwealth, Gaudron J (in dissent) made an interesting argument concerning constitutional guarantees of freedom of religion (s. 116). She said that the Commonwealth can infringe on these guarantees in order to perform a needful government action. Gaudron stated this in reference to section 116 of the Constitution and in context of the Stolen Generations. Gaudron reveals an interesting trend in the Commonwealth today showing a disregard towards religious affiliation....   [tags: Australian Commonwealth]

Term Papers
1605 words (4.6 pages)

Threatened Patriotic Rights Essay examples

- Every American has a constitutional right to defend themselves and obtain ownership of any style of handgun, if they so choose to do so. Although, some may feel this is an outdated method of self-protection or hobby people such as congress and anti-gun activist who feel there is no need for a civilian to own any firearms. However, in the past few years there has been an ongoing war between the NRA (National Riffle Association) and congress to limit or ban the use or ownership of handguns. Some people think by disarming society, it will limit deadly altercations and fatalities of innocent people.(should there be more here ) Everyone has a right to own a handgun for either protection or a hobb...   [tags: Americans, Constitutional Rights, Gun Control]

Term Papers
1024 words (2.9 pages)

The Evolution Of Individual Rights And Liberties Prior To The Constitutional Convention

- The Nevada Constitution has much comparison to the U.S. Constitution, and has various perceptions and requirements of the Nevada Constitution, which have roots that go back to English common law. The right of petition are often forgotten when people are asked to recite the rights guaranteed in the First Amendment. Up till now, this right could arguably be credited with providing the foundation for all other First Amendment rights. In this paper, I will analyze the evolution of individual rights and liberties in England, and in the Colonies, and States of the Confederation during the years preceding the Constitutional Convention....   [tags: US History Constitution]

Term Papers
1145 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about The Center for Constitutional Rights

- There are many factors that are essential to the manifestation of a holocaust with prejudice being at the core of these contributing factors. If all prejudice was eliminated all cause for holocausts would be destroyed. Sadly it is impossible to eradicate prejudice because it is naturally fostered by human beings and their environment. Education and exposure to different minorities can help break down prejudice, but ultimately the only recourse to prevent future holocausts is to subdue human prejudice through the judicial system....   [tags: CCR Non Profit ]

Term Papers
1403 words (4 pages)