Defining Art And Artworlds By Stephen Davies Essay

Defining Art And Artworlds By Stephen Davies Essay

Length: 1242 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the article “Defining Art and Artworlds” by Stephen Davies from The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, published in fall 2015, informs the readers that “[m]any of the late twentieth-century definitions of art were prompted by the challenge of controversial avant-garde works.” There are many contributions to consider before identifying any specific work as a piece of art. Establishing what exactly qualifies an art-piece will develop further contributions to the artworld, whether it is because of the piece’s aesthetic, skill, genre, intention, or tradition. A definition suggests that something is art if it displays advanced skill-work to achieve significant beauty to the extent that it makes a vital contribution to its primary function, falls under a genre or form of identified art within an art tradition, or was intended by its certified maker to be art. There are flaws, these definitions allow the possibility of: something being art even if it falls outside all artworlds, a piece’s location can become sufficient for the piece to become art, or art being self-conscious. Artworlds are “different art traditions latched onto different prehistoric art cohorts…what makes them all artworlds is their origins in first art.” Artworlds become autonomous and can take many directions.
(1) The main idea of this article is that an adequate definition for “art” must be developed to accommodate the artworld’s efforts, since something can qualify as art in more than one way. The thesis argues that art is something that: shows the advance of skill and significant aesthetics that alternates its primary function, identifying function, falls under an art form or genre and recognized within an artistic tradition, and the maker does what is ne...

... middle of paper ...

(11) This is a positive article. It strives for a goal of developing an accurate definition of art and artworlds, and sets aside emotional influences. (12) There were many thing that I learned from this article; one being that ther is an enormous difference between an item being “beautifully functional,” when the item has a secondary aesthetic function that assists the primary function, to “functionally beautifully,” when the primary function is achieved and displays aesthetic quality. Another thing that I learned is, that the earliest artworks were created by people were started unintentionally (not possessing the concept of art). (13) There are some ways I would improve the article is by adding examples of more core art forms not just paintings and ceramics/sculptures. I would have included some images of actual artworks to give the readers a visual factor.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Study of Guild in Fifth Business by Robertson Davies Essay

- Guilt can take on many forms. It is a powerful force to overcome, and a majority of people collapse because of it. In “Fifth Business”, by Robertson Davies, guilt is the intended study that is portrayed throughout the novel and impacts a number of lives. Davies demonstrates this by having one character feeling guilt and tries to confront it, a second character ignoring it and a third who tries to run away from it. Davies introduces the reader with Dunstan Ramsay and Percy Boyd Staunton who are parallels in competition with each other....   [tags: dunstan, davies]

Better Essays
794 words (2.3 pages)

Fifth Business by Robertson Davies Essay

- Fifth Business by Robertson Davies      In Robertson Davies' novel Fifth Business, the author uses the events that occurred in Deptford as a Canadian Allusion to reveal character identity. Three characters in the novel from Deptford: Boy Staunton, Dunstan Ramsey and Paul Dempster, leave Deptford to embark on a new identity to rid of their horrid past. The three main characters of the novel, all of whom to some extent try to escape their small town background, change their identity to become people of consequence....   [tags: Fifth business robertson davies Essays]

Free Essays
847 words (2.4 pages)

Fifth Business by Robertson Davies Essay

- Fifth Business by Robertson Davies In the essay Fifth Business, each of the main character traits is developed more and more clearly throughout their lives. Childhood characteristics are evident in the characters of Dustan Ramsay, Percy Boyd Stauton and Paul Dempster. All paranoia, and memories of the town of Deptford are resurfaced in each of them after they all had left to start lives on their own. It was childhood that scared or marked them as people and the fact that parents often have influence on children so, there is no question that these characters were definitely influenced by the parents in Deptford....   [tags: Essays Papers Davies Fifth Business ]

Better Essays
638 words (1.8 pages)

Robertson Davies' Fifth Business Essay

- Robertson Davies' Fifth Business In the novel 'Fifth Business', the author Robertson Davies is successfully able to relate both the themes of magic and religion throughout. He achieves this relationship between the themes primarily through the characters and their actions. Dunstan Ramsay, Paul Dempster, Mary Dempster and Liselotte Vitzliputzli all help to illustrate the close relationship between magic and religion. One of the characters that Davies uses to relate the theme of magic and religion is Dunstable Ramsay....   [tags: Robertson Davies Fifth Business Essays Papers]

Better Essays
597 words (1.7 pages)

Liesl - Fifth Business by Robertson Davies Essay

- Liesl Robertson Davies’ colourful novel “Fifth Business” outlines and describes the development of a lost and emotionally void man, Dunstan Ramsay. This is a man who carries the weight of Paul Dempsters premature birth on his shoulders his entire life. It portrays his quest for self knowledge, happiness, and ultimately fulfilling his role as ‘Fifth Business.’ This would not have accomplished without Liesl, an extremely graceful and intelligent woman imprisoned inside a deformed and gargantuan body....   [tags: Robertson Davies Fifth Business Critique]

Free Essays
1076 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Stephen Crane and The Civil War

- Stephen Crane and The Civil War         While merely speculative, some biographers claim that Crane began The Red Badge of Courage in response to a challenge made by an acquaintance urging him to write a war novel that exceeded the quality of Emile Zola’s Le débâcle.  Crane, shortly thereafter, undertook the task and researched various articles in Century magazine on battles and leaders in the Civil War.  In several personal letters he writes of the process he underwent in producing the narrative and discusses his opinions and feelings in reference to the quality of his work.  While he generally concedes to the positive opinions surrounding its reviews, he makes a conscious effort to refut...   [tags: Stephen Crane]

Better Essays
1791 words (5.1 pages)

Definition Essay - Defining Art

- Definition Essay – Defining Art What is art. Art and perception are deeply interrelated, since our ability to experience and comprehend artistic works is strongly biased by our own perceptions. Accordingly, any definition of art should emphasize the importance of perception in creating and experiencing art. Yet, each person has his or her own opinion of every artistic work, biased by his or her own perceptions, causing each person to define art as a whole in his or her own subjective manner. Hence, in my opinion it is impossible to create an objective definition of art, if art is something that each person perceives and experiences in a wholly subjective manner....   [tags: Expository Definition Essays]

Better Essays
503 words (1.4 pages)

Essay on Defining Art

- As an artist I constantly find myself bombarded with the question of “What is exactly art?” Normally I’m a person who can answer any question with ease, but this one caught me off guard. So I began thinking to myself what is exactly art. I didn’t really have an answer to that right away. So after more thought I realized that art is anything you want it to be. Art isn’t merely a drawing or a painting. Art is how you express yourself when words aren’t enough. Art can be a memory caught in time. Art can be the sounds or lyrics you hear of everyday music....   [tags: Visual Arts Studies]

Better Essays
737 words (2.1 pages)

Defining Art Essay

- The first time I saw a photo of Michaelangelo Buonarroti’s statue the Pietà I didn’t think of it consciously, but my brain was saying, “Now this is art!” That was over a decade ago, and I still have much the same reaction when I see that Renaissance sculpture. The work depicts the dead body of Christ, languid in the arms of his mother Mary. The subject matter alone is likely to evoke emotion in many, while I find myself astonished at the technical achievement. It is plain to see in the highly detailed marble figures, with their perfect anatomy and expressive character, that Michaelangelo was a true master, an artist beyond question....   [tags: Forms, Masochism, Avant-Garde]

Better Essays
1048 words (3 pages)

Robertson Davies Essays

- Robertson Davies With a vision that reflects the experiences of Canadians, Robertson Davies achieved international renown as one of Canada’s foremost men of letters. Born in Thamesville, Ontario, on August 28, 1813, Robertson Davies was the youngest of three sons of newspaper publisher and Liberal senator William Rupert Davies and his wife, Florence Sheppard McKay Davies. With parents who were theatre enthusiasts, Robertson Davies was drawn to the theatre early in his life and acted in school plays....   [tags: Biography Biographies Essays]

Free Essays
1128 words (3.2 pages)