Decision Making In Global Organizations

Decision Making In Global Organizations

Length: 1644 words (4.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Decision-Making in Global Organizations
In today's business environment, there is sustained pressure for companies to maximize productivity in order to be competitive in the marketplace. Many businesses are moving a variety of activities, such as manufacturing and product development, to countries with low labour costs. They are also opening up sales channels in many new markets. The resulting global organizations need to structure themselves, so that they can effectively manage operations across numerous locations. This paper looks at how the organizational structure of a global company influences decision-making at the regional level, and how this can affect the business performance. This paper will:
- Consider whether centralized and decentralized business structures will make different business decisions depending on the cultural values in the region.
- Explore how a transition from an autonomous structure to a centralized structure affects regional performance.
- Examine how a global company can delineate decision-making responsibility that balances a corporate code of conduct with regional cultural differences to achieve optimal business results.
- Recommend steps that global organizations can take to optimize regional decision-making, and corresponding business results, across regions with different cultural backgrounds.
Large corporations have been attempting to find a balance between the traditional hierarchical structure and the flexible local entrepreneurial structure for many years. Increasing global competition has made it critical that multinational enterprises be both globally integrated and locally responsive at the same time (Bartlett & Ghoshal, 1988). Sohn & Paik (2004) describe the efforts of Toshiba to achieve a hybrid of centralized control and localized autonomy. Irrespective of the structure chosen, corporations can all be placed somewhere along the continuum between centralized and decentralized management. A centralized structure will be slower to respond to changing market conditions but provides stability and control. A decentralized structure provides autonomy for local businesses to make their own decisions quickly, ; however, the decisions may not align with the parent organizations' strategic objectives and ethics. Many business decisions involve conflict between making money and ethical treatment of employees, customers, and the environment. Centrally managed organizations are more likely to align decisions with a universal corporate code of conduct. Autonomous subsidiaries will make decisions that are reflective of the local cultural values. The risk to the parent organization is that some of these decisions may severely conflict with shareholder values. Treatment of women, children, and respect for the environment are some areas where regional differences exist.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Decision Making In Global Organizations." 18 Jan 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

American Well : Decision Making & Impact Essay

- American Well: Decision-Making & Impact American Well is a major producer of telehealth technology in the health care industry. The company is faced with several ethical and regulatory issues that impact the decisions made in the organization. Ethical issues in telehealth pertains to the demand of American Well to develop products that improve health care quality and are acceptable to all stakeholders in health care. Regulatory issues in telehealth include concerns of the privacy and security of protected health information (PHI)....   [tags: Ethics, Decision making, Health care]

Research Papers
880 words (2.5 pages)

Understanding The Customer Purchase Decision Making Process Essay

- Understanding the customer purchase decision-making process is of great importance to all organizations. This understanding can be used as the basis for creating marketing strategies that suit the needs of the customers. The main purpose of this report is to develop an understanding of acceptable standards of branding and how it can be applied to create effective marketing strategies. This analytical report is targeted at managers in different organizations, to help them understand the importance of branding and how this can affect the success of their organizations....   [tags: Marketing, Brand management, Decision making]

Research Papers
727 words (2.1 pages)

The Leadership Roles Of Organizations Essay

- Leadership Roles in Organizations The most significant core ideology is one where an organization is shaped at their core, and is characterized by their ability to balance change and continuity, which require discipline, and is practiced on a conscious level (Srinivasan,2013). Srinivasan (2013) notes that vision guides strategy of organization ability to achieve and retain its competitive advantage significantly by functioning in the height of a crucial transitional stages of human evolution. Rothaermel (2013) argues that organizations must decide how organizations can measure their competition’s advantages to formulate businesses, corporation, and global strategy....   [tags: Leadership, Decision making, Risk]

Research Papers
1245 words (3.6 pages)

Diversity In Today's Organizations Essay

- With today's workforce becoming increasingly diverse and organizations doing more to maximize the benefits of the differences in employees, organizations are relying on managers to get the people who get the job done. People have always been the central to organizations, but there strategic importance is growing in today's knowledge-based business world. An organization's success increasingly depends on the knowledge, skills, and abilities of its employees excluding there gender, age, ethnicity, and the differences in skill and abilities....   [tags: Organizations Diversity Business]

Research Papers
1132 words (3.2 pages)

Judgement and Decision Making Essay

- This paper provides a strategic analysis of the decision making process within AT&T Asia Pacific. The analysis contains an in-depth discussion on AT&T strategic decision in terms of the approach on multiple perspectives by Linstone (1984) and the power model by Parkin (1994). According to Parkin (1996: 155), strategic decisions can be divided into organizational decisions and social decisions. The consequences of social decisions affect the society as a whole and the process involves parties from outside of the organizations....   [tags: Business Management]

Research Papers
2278 words (6.5 pages)

Ethical Ideas And Morals : Human Resource Departments Within Organizations

- An Issue of Ethics Ethics is a topic that is highly considered and viewed as a vital part of every decision making process for all companies, organizations and individuals. Ethics can be defined as a system of moral principles and a branch of philosophy which defines what is good for individuals and society (Ethics Guide, N.D.). If a company were to decide to show support for a controversial topic such as gay rights or not show support for women employment then they would increase their chance for public boycotting and rage towards their decisions not including how individual employees would feel....   [tags: Ethics, Decision making, Decision theory, Virtue]

Research Papers
1221 words (3.5 pages)

Organizational, Communal, And Global Conflict Essay

- Communication is a complex subject to grasp. Those who study the subject, however, learned the importance of studying it. Understanding the ideas behind becoming skilled in dialogic practices creates value, whether it stems from conflicts of a personal nature, in institutions, or across cultures. While some argue conflict does not create value, those who grasp its value, create positive value in presenting themselves and in exploring others. Organizational, Communal, and Global Conflict There exits benefits and value in conflict, whether it is organizational, the communal, or global....   [tags: Decision making, Critical thinking, Conflict]

Research Papers
1557 words (4.4 pages)

The Decision-Making Process Essay examples

-   Table of Contents Introduction 1 Traditional Decision-Making Process 1 Making Rational Decisions 2 Problem Definition-Rational 3 Identify Decision Criteria-Rational 3 Weight the Criteria-Rational 3 Generate the Alternatives-Rational 4 Evaluate the Alternatives-Rational 4 Select the Optimal Solution-Rational 4 Making “Good Enough” Decisions 4 Making Intuitive Decisions 4 Making Creative Decisions 5 Global Decision Making 5 Ethical Decision Making 5 Key Aspects of the Management Process 6 Decision-Making in Today’s Changing World 6 Global Managerial Decision Making 7 Effective Global Manager 7 What It Takes for a Manager to Be Effective in a Global Scope: 8 Conclusion 8 References 9 intro...   [tags: management strategies]

Research Papers
2253 words (6.4 pages)

Quality Decision Making in Management Essay

- The overall purpose of this research paper is to define and assess decision making in management as well as the need for alternatives to use in the decision making processes. Management is concerned with combining all of the inputs of production. Managers decide what to make and how to make it. They chose from the available inputs and work out the right mix. Management must organize production to meet the goals of the company, which normally include keeping manufacturing costs low and producing a profit....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Research Papers
1726 words (4.9 pages)

Essay on Decision-Making and Strategy Development

- I. Introduction Examining my lessons on how businesses and other similar entities traditionally developed their strategies, and comparing it with the way that some of today's more innovative firms have begun to plan, reminds me of the change in many companies' approach to quality decision-making. From what I have learned, quality was traditionally associated with inspectors assuring quality after the fact--after parts were made--rather than getting everyone down the line involved in building in quality in the first place, as eventually happened through the TQM (Total Quality Management) movement....   [tags: Total Quality Management]

Research Papers
2211 words (6.3 pages)

Bribery and use of kickbacks are relatively common practice in certain cultures. An autonomous subsidiary may allow these practices to occur, whereas a centralized management structure would likely not allow . Even with a strong company policy on values and ethics, ethical decisions are open to interpretation by the regional organization. Thus, the incentive for global organizations to maintain a centralized management structure may be significant; however, there are several drawbacks to this structure.
Global corporations assimilate smaller businesses on a regular basis. If they enforce a centralized organizational structure upon recently purchased businesses there can be some significant challenges. Taking away decision-making authority from people who are used to being empowered can result in conflict, loss of key employees, poor business decisions, and a rapid decline in business performance. Key employees, who remain, will struggle with the lack of empowerment and will be unsure of which decisions they can make and which the centralized management should make. This confusion can have a significant negative impact on business performance. In 1997, Honeywell assimilated the Measurex pulp and paper business. Many of the individuals who knew how to run the business left the company due to conflict with Honeywell executives. Subsequently, market share has dropped from over 50% to around 30% due to poor decisions made by executives with limited knowledge of the pulp and paper business.
With a centralized management structure, leadership is remote to most locations and the only contact between employees and leadership is through site-visits, webinars, or emails. Accompanying this lack of local leadership is a lack of empowerment for employees. According to Bavendam (2005), leadership, adequate authority, and opportunity all have a direct influence on employees' job satisfaction. In addition, Bavendam finds that bureaucracy and lack of teamwork among departments negatively influences customer satisfaction. A centralized organization is more bureaucratic and often, different functions report to different centralized chains of command. Without strong local leadership responsible for all functions, different departments spend as much time trying to work together as they do addressing customers' needs. This distraction has a negative impact on customer satisfaction and correspondingly on business results.
A company code of conduct is an important basis from which global corporations can drive ethical business practices and help to ensure that a company makes decisions that are consistent with shareholder values. A multinational company may enforce a code of conduct via a centralized hierarchical structure to ensure that all parts of the organization operate according to these values. Alternatively, a company may allow regional offices to make business decisions that are sensitive to local customs. Whether or not a company chooses to enforce a central code of conduct should be dependent on the degree of cultural difference between the parent company and its regional offices. Liouville & Nanopoulos state, "Local differentiation is advantageous when it is applied in countries with differing cultures, whereas globalization is necessary when the national cultures are similar." If a company spans regions with similar cultural values and customs, implementing a common set of ethical standards may be advantageous. There are established groupings of nationalities with similar cultural values: English speaking, Western European, Islamic, etc (Schwartz, Fig. 4). However, in today's global environment fewer and fewer companies operate solely within one of these groupings. These dispersed companies may find that a central ethics policy is detrimental to the business success of the company. If the culture of the country where the subsidiary is located is different from the culture of the country of the parent company, the autonomy given to the subsidiary limits conflicts and encourages performance improvement [Liouville & Nanopoulos, 1996/2 p 103; Ghoshal & Nohria 1989].
The success of transnational [hybrid] organizational structures that provide certain centralized control functions while delegating operational control to subsidiaries has been well documented (Bartlett & Ghoshal, 1988, 1992; Sohn & Paik, 2004; Yip, 1993). Hybrid organizational structures combine the benefits of centralized control and regional flexibility. Global companies would do well to modify their codes of conduct to a hybrid policy that recognizes regional differences. This hybrid organizational structure combined with a hybrid code of conduct will provide subsidiaries with the flexibility to make decisions, within an agreed strategic direction, while allowing the businesses to recognize regional cultural sensitivities. This structure will help to ensure that regional management makes decisions that will keep employees engaged, customers satisfied, and yield positive business results. "At the level of the organization of subsidiaries abroad, a style of management contrary to the culture of the local workforce should be avoided" [Liouville & Nanopoulos, 1996/2 p 115-116]. This hybrid code of conduct will identify cultural diversity within the company and help to create an environment where decision-making is consistent with a global ethics policy while prioritizing regional cultural differences where appropriate. This will avoid situations where the parent company's ethics policy supersedes local cultural values and will ensure that local employees and customers feel respected. A mismatch between local customs and managerial style could result in a de-motivated workforce, low employee retention rates, and a confused customer base. For this reason, local management must be extremely knowledgeable of the local culture. Several additional changes may also improve regional decision-making. Clearly defining a long-term strategic direction and clearly defining the roles and decision rights between headquarters and the local leadership [Olsen, Pinto and Virji (2005)] will help to delineate responsibility.
The organizational structure of a global company plays an important role in the success of decisions made at the regional level. Centralized business structures can often be too strict to allow culturally sensitive decisions to be made by local management. A careless transition from an autonomous structure to a centralized structure can cause problems between corporate and local business units and negatively influence business performance. A global company will succeed if it can maintain a balance between centralized control and autonomous regional control that will foster decision-making that takes into account cultural differences.

Bartlett, C. A., & Ghoshal, S. (1988, Fall). Organizing for worldwide effectiveness: The transnational solution.. California Management Review, 31(1), 54-74. Retrieved February 25, 2006, from ProQuest database
Bartlett, C. A., & Ghoshal, S. (1990, Jul/Aug). Matrix Management: Not a Structure, a Frame of Mind. Harvard Business Review, 68(4), 138-146. Retrieved February 25, 2006, from EBSCOhost database
Bavendam, J. (2005). Managing Job Satisfaction. Retrieved February 22, 2006, from
Liouville, J., Nanopoulos, C. (February 1996). Performance factors of subsidiaries abroad: Lessons in an analysis of German subsidiaries in France. Management International Review, 36, 101-122. Retrieved February 06, 2006, from InfoTrac database
Olsen, T. A., Pinto, M., Virji, S. (2005). Navigating growth in emerging markets: six rules for improving decision making between corporate and local leadership. The Journal of Business Strategy, 26, 37-45. Retrieved February 8, 2006, from InfoTrac database
Paik, Y., Derick Sohn, J. (December 4, 2004). Striking a balance between global integration and local responsiveness: The case of Toshiba Corporation in redefining regional headquarters' role. Organizational Analysis, 12(4), pg. 347-359 Retrieved February 6, 2006, from ProQuest database.
Schwartz, S. H. (1999). A theory of cultural values and some implications for work. Applied Psychology: An International Review, 48(1), 23-47. Retrieved February 23, 2006, from EBSCOhost database
Yip, G (1993). Total global strategy: Managing for worldwide competitive advantage. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall
Return to