Essay on The Debate Over Affirmative Action

Essay on The Debate Over Affirmative Action

Length: 1565 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The debate over affirmative action is a debate over the conflict of rights. This conflict of rights makes a clear-cut ruling or decision on the subject almost unattainable. However, there can be arguments made both for and against affirmative action.
Supporters of affirmative action claim that racism and sexism can only be overcome by taking race and sex into account in finding a solution. They think that giving everyone equal rights is not enough to overcome the burden. Therefore, for everyone to be truly equal some people must be given certain benefits. So in hiring, acceptance to college, and other related things, businesses or colleges must hire or accept applicants on the basis of sex and race. In doing so they should give preference to blacks, women, and other minorities. This preference in hiring and accepting to level out the playing field is often called equality of results. Lately, affirmative action has taken the role of trying to diversify the environment of jobs and colleges.
On the other hand, you have people who do not believe in or support the idea of affirmative action. They believe in the equality of opportunity rather than the equality of results. Equality of opportunity means that everyone should have the same rights and opportunities from the beginning, and what the individual does with those rights is up to them. People that do not agree with affirmative action often argue that if it is wrong to take away rights on the basis of race or sex, then it would also be wrong to give extra rights or preference to someone on the basis of their race or sex. This reverse discrimination seems to go against the principle it was founded on.
Naturally, the Supreme Court has gotten involved with this controve...


... middle of paper ...


...tion would not support a quota system.
There have been mixed rulings in the Supreme Court so it is still hard to say whose side is right. In 1978, 1989, and 1993 the Supreme Court ruled against a quota system in the workplace. However, in 1980 and 1990 the court upheld a system of quotas in the workplace. So even the Supreme Court itself cannot decide which stand to take on quotas and affirmative action.
There does seem to be some pattern to their rulings. If any quota system is created it will be strictly scrutinized. In deciding whether the quota system in each case is legal, they must first show that the system is needed and that there was discrimination. So where does that leave those who do and do not support affirmative action? It looks like each case is being decided on a situational basis and that there is little or no precedence used in new cases.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Debate Over Affirmative Action

- This American society confronts many controversial ideas from gun control to abortion. Citizens live in an era during which opposing groups argue at tremendous length to defend their viewpoints. These arguments create intense discussions over the years. One of the most controversial issues today is whether colleges should use affirmative action. Affirmative action refers to admission policies that provide superior access for underrepresented groups such as minorities and women. Supporters for affirmative action argue that it creates a diverse campus environment that benefits all students....   [tags: Affirmative action, Discrimination, Minority group]

Better Essays
1380 words (3.9 pages)

The Debate On Affirmative Action Essay

- The debate on affirmative action has extended over the course of time, existing among the reparations that the current system has foreseen. The consequences that evolved from this issue at hand have included a prolonged social stratification based on race. Michael Omi and Howard Winant, in Racial Formations, discussed race as a social construct, stating that “racial categories and the meaning of race are given concrete expression by the specific social relations and historical context in which they are embedded” (21)....   [tags: Racism, Black people, Race, Race]

Better Essays
1285 words (3.7 pages)

The Affirmative Action Debate Essay example

- The Affirmative Action Debate   Most Americans desire a colorblind society. A society where individuals are judged upon merit, as opposed to the color of their skin. That is the reason Affirmative Action was birthed by Lyndon B. Johnson in 1964. That is also the reason that Proposition 209 was voted for in 1996.  These two historical events are driven by the desire of equality.         What is Affirmative Action?  According to Geraldine Leshin, it is "Taking positive or active steps to accomplish the public policy goal of equal employment opportunity."   What is Proposition 209?  Its a new law that has been passed that "prohibits the state of California and local governments from dis...   [tags: affirmative action argumentative persuasive]

Better Essays
1760 words (5 pages)

Essay about Affirmative Action Debate

- Affirmative Action Debate "A policy designed to redress past discrimination against women and minority groups through measures to improve their economic and educational opportunities." At first glance this definition seems to explain fairly well what affirmative action is and convinces the reader that it is done in good faith to help make up for past discrimination, yet affirmative action is accompanied by many different opinions. This paper will discuss the different viewpoints regarding affirmative action....   [tags: Affirmative Action ]

Free Essays
1077 words (3.1 pages)

The Affirmative Action Debate Essay

- For the sake of this essay, affirmative action in education is defined as: “policies and programs designed to advance equality of educationalopportunity for individuals from groups that have suffered systematic historical discrimination” (Mickelson 29). What is being referred to here is race-based affirmative action, or the act of taking into consideration an applicant’s race in the college admissions process. This is a hot topic all over the United States and has been for quite a while, the debate raging between two sides: those in support of affirmative action and those opposed....   [tags: argumentative persuasive 2014]

Better Essays
1650 words (4.7 pages)

Essay about Affirmative Action And Its Impact On Society

- In the United States, obtaining the American dream oftentimes becomes a race in which the fastest competitors make it to the finish line; however, past discrimination has made the finish line truly untouchable for certain competitors: minorities. Dating back to the 15th century, African Americans callously experienced slavery, hatred, discrimination and other cruel forms of racial oppression. The 19th and 20th centuries were times of fighting back; African Americans struggled to abolish slavery, end discrimination and gain citizenship rights....   [tags: Affirmative action, Discrimination]

Better Essays
1677 words (4.8 pages)

Affirmative Action And Its Impact On Society Essay

- Affirmative action is an everlasting topic that still is on debate in today’s society. In the reference issue, two scholars debate on if affirmative action is essential in today’s world to achieve racial equality. The first scholar named Robert Staples had started the debate stating that the affirmative action programs was started to provide economic opportunities to minorities and women. He also became critical to the fact that politicians that said the program was geared toward blacks and only benefited them....   [tags: Affirmative action, Discrimination, Black people]

Better Essays
1170 words (3.3 pages)

Affirmative Action needs to be Changed not Ended Essay

- Affirmative action: Should it be mended or ended. Affirmative action is an attempt to correct unequal distribution of benefits (status, income and wealth, power and authority), and burdens associated with ethnic and gender differences. Affirmative action has been promoted by the Federal government since the mid 1960's, when president Lyndon B. Johnson ordered federal contractors to adopt affirmative action plans. (Congress and the Nation, 748). This paper will focus on the relevance of affirmative action in the American society....   [tags: Affirmative Action]

Better Essays
1336 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Affirmative Action

- In 1997, three students were denied admission into the University of Michigan. Each of them, in turn, sued the school, charging them with discrimination. In one of the cases, a student was denied admission into Michigan’s law school. Chicago Sun-Times writers Dave Newbart and Kate Grossman reported that last Monday, June 23, 2003, in a 5-4 majority ruling, swing vote Justice Sandra Day O’Connor judged for the school maintaining their right to consider the race of their applicants. In a second decision, the court ruled that they supported the University’s use of race in their admissions policy, but use of a point system was unconstitutional under the fourteenth amendment (Equal Protection Cl...   [tags: Affirmative Action Essays]

Free Essays
1066 words (3 pages)

Affermative Action Essay

- Affirmative Action Affirmative Action efforts were started in 1964 to end the long history of overlooking qualified people of color and women from higher education. Affirmative Action sets standards for a business or office of admissions, so that a white man does not have the upper-hand over an equally or greater educated minority. The initial way the government tried to justify Affirmative Action was to develop a human resource approach: first identifying the problem, which is racism then establishing the solution (Phillips 67)....   [tags: Affirmative Action Essays]

Better Essays
1273 words (3.6 pages)