Death's Waiting List by Sally Satel Essay

Death's Waiting List by Sally Satel Essay

Length: 903 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Critique for “Death’s Waiting List” by Sally Satel

After her diagnosis of chronic kidney failure in 2004, psychiatrist Sally Satel lingered in the uncertainty of transplant lists for an entire year, until she finally fell into luck, and received her long-awaited kidney. “Death’s Waiting List”, published on the 5th of May 2006, was the aftermath of Satel’s dreadful experience. The article presents a crucial argument against the current transplant list systems and offers alternative solutions that may or may not be of practicality and reason. Satel’s text handles such a topic at a time where organ availability has never been more demanded, due to the continuous deterioration of the public health. With novel epidemics surfacing everyday, endless carcinogens closing in on our everyday lives, leaving no organ uninflected, and to that, many are suffering, and many more are in desperate request for a new organ, for a renewed chance. Overall, “Death’s Waiting List” follows a slightly bias line of reasoning, with several underlying presumptions that are not necessarily well substantiated.
In her article, Satel criticizes the current methods governing organ sharing in the United States, and suggests that the government should encourage organ donation, whether it was by providing financial incentives or other compensatory means to the public. Furthermore, the author briefly suggests that the European “presumed consent” system for organ donation might remedy this shortage of organs if implicated in the States.
At the beginning of her argument, Satel claims that the current transplant list systems are ineffective, and are causing a shortage of organs availability, thereby allowing countless patients to suffer. At first, she makes an invali...


... middle of paper ...


... pricing organs like vultures, holding a great deal of disrespect to both the deceased as well as their families. In addition, the author fails to remain neutral when discussing the issue, and exaggerates in blaming the government, solely and entirely.
Arguably, “Death’s waiting list” discusses a crucial topic of our times, regardless of how sincere Satel is in her argument, she does provide alternatives worth further analysis and consideration, after all, incentives are not that appalling to winning someone’s consent. Further research and public poles should be set up to take a deeper look into such alternative systems, yielding with insight to whether Satel’s suggestions potential in remedying this shortage of organs. While her argument might not be ideal, it does shed the light on this rising issue, and provides us with a place to start looking for solutions.



Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Death's Waiting List Essay

- In “Death’s Waiting List”, Sally Satel presents a strong and compelling argument for the implementation of changes to the organ donation system. The author addresses a shortage of organ donations due to the current donation system in the United States, which puts stipulations on the conditions surrounding the donation. She provides ideas to positively affect the system and increase organ donations. Satel starts her essay with an appeal to emotion, detailing the shortage of organ transplants and the deaths that result....   [tags: Literature]

Better Essays
929 words (2.7 pages)

Summary of a Sad Story, Ways to Live Forever by Sally Nicholls Essay

- ... This book is set in the past because Sam is telling the story of his last few months of living, this setting is not familiar to me as I have never experienced anyone with cancer that is close to me and I have never had cancer so this setting is not familiar to me. I learnt that I have to live my life to the fullest because life can end very quickly just like Sam’s life did. This book is about Sam an 11 year old boy who has had leukaemia for nearly his whole life, Sam has a bucket list which he wants to finish before he dies, and he also wants to finish his book which has a lot of questions on death an why people die, Sam and his friend Felix who also has leukaemia try and complete Sam’s...   [tags: bucket list, luekemia, death]

Better Essays
546 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of The Play ' Waiting For Godot '

- Everything Comes to Those Who Wait When Alan Schneider put the first American performance of Waiting for Godot, he asked Beckett who Godot is or what is Godot, Beckett said: “If I knew, I would have said so in the play.” This is a useful warning to anyone who is coming to the Beckett’s play with the intention to find the key to understand and accurately identify the meaning. However, it is not surprising that the plays written in this unusual and mysterious manner are perceived as if there is a particular need to disclose their secret meaning translated into everyday language....   [tags: Waiting for Godot, Samuel Beckett]

Better Essays
1132 words (3.2 pages)

Analysis Of ' Waiting For Godot ' Essay example

- In the play Waiting for Godot, Samuel Beckett uses the motif of habit as a way to portray the two characters, Estragon and Vladimir as unnatural while they wait, as well as a forum to show a dependency upon habit thus presenting addictions as part of human nature. Throughout the play, Estragon and Vladimir develop abnormal routines, as portrayed in the simple start. Beckett starts with “A country road. A tree. Evening”, a simplistic setting. He creates a sense of ambiguity as they could be anywhere, and anytime....   [tags: Waiting for Godot, Samuel Beckett, Lucky]

Better Essays
1495 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Waiting For Godot, By William Beckett

- Waiting for Godot is a tragicomedy play that is both funny and depressing. During the play we are trying to figure out who or what is Godot. We are constantly asking ourselves what are we waiting for and why. Throughout the play we follow Vladimir and Estragon on their daily escapades to find out if today is the day they meet Godot. We witness the suffering that Vladimir and Estragon are put through each day while they are anxiously waiting for something. Vladimir and Estragon seem to be very sad and lonely....   [tags: Waiting for Godot, Lucky, Theatre of the Absurd]

Better Essays
767 words (2.2 pages)

Waiting for Godot and The House of Bernarda Alba Essay

- In the plays Waiting for Godot and The House of Bernarda Alba, life and death are significant concepts. Life is meaningless in Godot as they merely wait until death, whilst Bernarda Alba depicts futility of life without passion, love or freedom. The House of Bernarda Alba, through Adela’s rebellious spirit signifies living a life that is passionate, while in Waiting for Godot Beckett seems to imply that life is meaningless. Whilst Waiting for Godot focuses more on the metaphorical aspect of death, The House of Bernarda Alba takes on the literal death through Adela’s suicide....   [tags: Waiting For Godot Essays]

Better Essays
1550 words (4.4 pages)

Waiting For Godot and the Theater of the Absurd Essay

- Who is Godot and what does he represent. These are two of the questions that Samuel Beckett allows both his characters and the audience to ponder. Many experiences in this stage production expand and narrow how these questions are viewed. The process of waiting reassures the characters in Beckett's play that they do indeed exist. One of the roles that Beckett has assigned to Godot is to be a savior of sorts. Godot helps to give the two tramps in Waiting for Godot a sense of purpose. Godot is an omnipresent character that helps to give meaning and function to the lives of two homeless men....   [tags: Waiting For Godot Essays]

Free Essays
1071 words (3.1 pages)

Seeing Myself in Waiting for Godot Essays

- Seeing Myself in Waiting for Godot Some people wondered why in high school my favorite book was Waiting for Godot, a drama described on the title page as “a two-act play in which nothing happens twice.” In fact, my liking a play that does not portray a series of connected incidents telling a story but instead presents a pattern of images showing bewildered people in an incomprehensible universe initially baffled me too, as my partiality was more felt than thought. But then I read a piece by the critic Martin Esslin, who articulated my feelings....   [tags: Waiting for Godot Essays]

Free Essays
1267 words (3.6 pages)

Pozzo and Lucky in Waiting For Godot Essay

- Interpersonal relationships are extremely important, because the interaction of the characters in Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot as they try to satisfy one another's boredom, is the basis for the play. Pozzo's and Lucky's interactions with each other form the basis for one of the play's major themes. The ambivalence of Pozzo's and Lucky's relationship in Waiting For Godot resembles most human relationships. Irritated by one another, they still must function together. References to their relationship are generally couched in rope images....   [tags: Waiting For Godot Essays]

Free Essays
800 words (2.3 pages)

Samuel Beckett and Waiting for Godot Essay

- Samuel Beckett and Waiting for Godot         As much as any body of writing this century, the works of Samuel Beckett reflect an unflinching, even obsessive flirtation with universal void. His literary and dramatic accounts of skirmishes with nothingness portray human beings (generally beings, at least, beings more or less human and intact) situated in paradoxical, impossibly absurd circumstances.   Samuel Barclay Beckett was born in the comfortable Dublin suburb of Foxrock in 1906, on the 13th either of April, which was Good Friday that year, or else of May-he and his birth certificate always disagreed on this point....   [tags: Waiting for Godot Essays]

Better Essays
2200 words (6.3 pages)