Essay on The Death Penalty Should Be An Option For Punishment

Essay on The Death Penalty Should Be An Option For Punishment

Length: 1114 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

I am writing a response to your New York Times editorial on April 6, 2014, on the "Death Penalty Needs to be an Option for Punishment." The article began by providing statistics and informing the reader about the harmful misconception that life in prison is better than a death sentence. The article you wrote was vague and filled with fallacies. There were many open ended statements and ideas that were not fully developed. He based his argument on the concept that a life is worth another life. Even though, my opinion is based on religious philosophies I realize that conceptually this idea could be reasonable; however, taking another person 's life as a consequence of a crime is morally wrong. I disagree with the author of this article because the death penalty does not truly punish the criminal, does not eliminate the suffering of the victim 's’ family, and does not discount the importance of the crime.
Killing someone for the crimes they have committed is a rash decision, that does not make the criminal truly suffer. To truly punish a criminal, people must place them in jail where they can suffer for their crimes. The author of the article defended the death penalty by stating that even in heavily guarded prisons the criminals will not be treated poorly. He stated “Many who prefer life without parole wrongly imagine that sadistic or callous killers experience prison as a daily punishment worse than death.” Furthermore, the officers won’t care about the crimes you committed, they will only be concerned with your behavior in the prison. If you act properly in maximum prison you get moved to medium, in which you are able to read, play, and enjoy your time. The author is trying to prove that jail is not really as bad of a punishment...

... middle of paper ...

...n idea and excluded information that did not agree with his idea, For example, expenses, the trauma that the families would have to go through, and the chance that an innocent would be killed.
The author’s argument was not strong enough to convince people to be pro-death penalty because of the lack of development. In an attempt to appeal to logos, the author defended the death penalty by concluding that a life is worth another life. By killing the criminal people will be able to end their suffering, however, there is proof that victims’ families are usually traumatized even more by the death penalty. He used fallacies in his arguments which further weakened his point. He failed to mention how expensive, tedious, and heinous the death penalty is. He also used his experience to generalized how all prisons would be. This article was overall weak and not well developed.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Capital Punishment : Should The Death Penalty Be Banned As A Form Or Punishment?

- Controversy of Capital Punishment “Many see the penalty as barbaric and against American values.” says Joe Messerli in his article “Should the Death Penalty be banned as a form or punishment?” (Messerli) Whether or not capital punishment should be used creates a huge dispute between Americans. The controversy of capital punishment can be understood by knowing what capital punishment is, why people are for capital punishment and understanding why people are against capital punishment. Capital punishment was common throughout the ancient world (Henderson 6).The term death penalty is sometimes used interchangeably with capital punishment, but is not always followed by execution.Capital punishm...   [tags: Crime, Capital punishment, Prison, Murder]

Better Essays
1127 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Death Penalty Should Not Abolish Capital Punishment

- Lethal Justice “I believe that more people would be alive today if there were a death penalty.” (Reagan 1). Capital Punishment is the authorization of killing a person for a crime, and has been around since the eighteenth century. Approximately 400 years later many states in the United States have abolished this penalty of death. After all those years many states have yet to abolish the death penalty, because those remainder states know the effectiveness of Capital Punishment. I strongly agree with not abolishing Capital Punishment, simply because it will reduce the temptation of a criminal wanting to commit a felony, it is a good Christian viewpoint, the Death Penalty is just, and it brings...   [tags: Capital punishment, Murder, Crime, Prison]

Better Essays
1224 words (3.5 pages)

Capital Punishment Essay: Death Penalty Should Be Reconsidered

- Death Penalty Should Be Reconsidered      The Death Penalty is among one of the major punishments given by the United States Department of Justice. The following facts were given by the Office of Justice Program, Bureau of Justice Statistics, and the United States Department of Justice themselves. During the year of 1995, Texas was the leading state with nineteen executions. This is about thirty-four percent of the executions in the United States. Also in that year, out of 56 persons who were executed, there were 33 white, 22 black, and one Asian....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]

Better Essays
1138 words (3.3 pages)

The Death Penalty Of The United States Should Federally Ban Capital Punishment

- In 1986, Randy Steidl was convicted of the murder of Dyke and Karen Rhoads. After spending seventeen years in prison, twelve of which were on death row, he was freed from his sentence. The police had discovered that he had been framed through fabricated testimony in an effort to keep the real killer hidden from the police. When the jurors found no solid evidence of his relation to the crime, he was released and now contributes in an effort to repeal the death penalty (Exonerees). Capital punishment is the legal authorization to kill someone for committing a crime of a certain status....   [tags: Capital punishment, Prison, Crime, Murder]

Better Essays
1286 words (3.7 pages)

Capital Punishment Essay - Should the Death Penalty be Abolished?

- Should the Death Penalty be Abolished. Everyone has different beliefs about the death penalty. Some people believe it is barbaric and inhumane to put someone to death who has been convicted, while others feel that the death penalty gives resolution to the victim's family and friends. The death penalty is used to punish criminals for the wrong they have done. However, I believe that killing a person to "punish" them is not enough. People cannot suffer and think about the anguish they have caused people if they are put to death....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays]

Better Essays
692 words (2 pages)

Essay on Should the Death Penalty be Abolished?

- Should the death penalty be abolished. The death penalty does one thing it “kills.” It temporarily takes away the pain for someone’s loss, but in the end it does not bring back the person you loved. The death penalty has been considered to be one of the most cruel and unusual punishments for sentencing criminals. I do not believe the death penalty should exist, even when the most heinous crimes have been committed. The death penalty will always be a debatable topic because no one should have the right to decide who should live or who should die....   [tags: capital punishment, death penalty]

Better Essays
3060 words (8.7 pages)

Essay about Capital Punishment: Should it be Legal?

- Capital Punishment: Should it be Legal. After the Timothy McVeigh execution over 80 percent of viewers polled supported the decision the courts made to put McVeigh to death, and even a handful of the people who supported the execution thought it was preformed in a way that was too humane. Some people say that the death penalty is the most effective way to control serious crimes such as murder, while others say that it is extremely unethical and should not be legal in a country as developed as the United States....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Better Essays
954 words (2.7 pages)

The Death Penalty Should Be Used Essay

- To Die or Not to Die A Gallup Poll shows that “61% of Americans view the death penalty as morally acceptable” (Muhlhausen 1). Despite this statistic, much controversy revolves around the topic of capital punishment. However, the issue very complicated. Questions related to morality, deterrence, and cost are all part of the debate. Professors David Muhlhausen and Philip Holloway take different stances on the death penalty debate in two articles. David Muhlhausen believes the death penalty should be used, whereas Phillip Holloway thinks capital punishment is not appropriate....   [tags: Capital punishment, Murder, Death row]

Better Essays
1151 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on The Death Penalty Should Be Abolished

- In recent discussion of capital punishment, one issue has been whether the death penalty should be abolished or not. On the one hand, some argue that the death penalty is a humane method of punishing brutal killers by granting them a quick and painless death. From this perspective, supporters claim the death penalty is an effective deterrent to violent crimes. On the other hand, opponents argue that the death penalty is an irreversible denial of human rights. In the words of Kenneth Jost, one of this view 's main proponents, “the irrevocable nature of the death penalty renders it an unsustainable and indefensible remedy in an imperfect justice system” (Jost "Death Penalty Debates" 984)....   [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Death row, Murder]

Better Essays
1146 words (3.3 pages)

The Death Penalty Should Be Abolished Essay

- Capital punishment is a legal process where the state sends a death row inmate to be executed as punishment. The death penalty should be abolished, because it’s morally wrong, some have been wrongly convicted, and people can change. As human beings, it is morally wrong to take the life of another human being. In the past 15 years, 441 people have been executed in the U.S. All people were raised to believe that killing is wrong, but also live in a country where the government puts people to death....   [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Prison, Death row]

Better Essays
834 words (2.4 pages)