The Death Penalty Should be Abolished in America

1308 Words3 Pages

American colonies were introduced to the practice of capital punishment through European colonization. The offenses punishable by the death penalty in each colony varied from stealing to denying the existence of God. During the Age of Enlightenment from the mid 1600’s to the early 1800’s, western philosophers such as Ceasre Beccaria began to use reason over religion to debate societal values. In 1776, Beccaria wrote On Crimes and Punishment; in which he questioned the logic behind the death penalty and asserted numerous reasons for the abolishment of the death penalty. Beccaria’s foremost reason for eradicating capital punishment was that it lacked rationalism since killing the criminal would only serve as a brief reminder to society of the consequences of breaking laws; whereas lifelong imprisonment would serve as a constant reminder to society that the punishment for crime is permanent. Beccaria’s essay acted as the chief catalyst behind the widespread abolition movement against the death penalty. Currently, the debate over capital punishment rages on with fervor on both ends. Those in favor of capital punishment find it necessary in deterring future murders, punishing murders, and bringing closure to victims. Although their argument seems of sound mind however, after close analysis of history and statistical data, the death penalty is proven to be an improper way of punishing criminals.

Although the flaws of death penalty are lucid, they are often times over looked by society. Innocuous people have been ruled to death based upon mistaken eyewitness testimonies, mistaken identity, and false confessions through coercion. Former Governor of Illinois, George Ryan, was a staunch proponent of the death penalty for 23 years. Howeve...

... middle of paper ...

...nstant reminder of the consequences of murder.

The death penalty is an irrational way of punishing criminals in trying to deter future murders. Although the death penalty is meant to provide justice to victims, its flaws have allowed it to victimize people such as Leonel Torres Herrera and the 4 people who were fortunately pardoned by the governor of Illonis, George Ryan. The most saddening part is that the death penalty provides freedom to killers from actual punishment, lifelong imprisonment. It is widely assumed that all members of NATO are civilized countries. However the United States is the only member which still has not abolished the barbaric death penalty. As American we should be obligated to advocate the abolishment of the death penalty and thus become a true member of NATO, showing the world we are civilized and not barbaric.

Open Document