The Day Of The Dead A Distinction Between Dia De Los Muertos And Halloween

The Day Of The Dead A Distinction Between Dia De Los Muertos And Halloween

Length: 894 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In digging the day of the dead a distinction between Dia de los Muertos and Halloween is made, the purpose, to highlight the differences and showing the importance and significance of Dia de los Muertos. This ethnography begins by loosely describing Halloween in American culture, it is described as a day where “children dress up as grotesque corpses” and a celebration empty of historic or cultural significance and knowledge. The author Juanita Garciagodoy, later goes on to describe Dia de los Muertos in a romanticized way, by statin that the dead “are not forgotten or excluded from recollections, prayer, or holidays because they are no longer visible” Garciagodoy then goes on to tell a heartfelt story about a couple one holding on to tradition, the other spouse ignoring tradition and facing consequences because if it.
As part of the Mexican culture, my self identifying as Mexican American, I was enthused to read this ethnography, specifically because my family and I have not practices the tradition of Dia de los Muertos, we, my family and I, know about the practiced but have loosed touch with the tradition. Because of this, I believed it would a great experience learning about this cultural practice. As I began reading the ethnography I began to loose my excitement, and began to feel singled out and as if my mix-culture was a disgrace.
Threw out the book the use of poetry, stories and historic accounts are used to provide truth or validity to the idea that Dia de los Muertos is a culturally important tradition honoring the dead, and one that is being forgotten by urban areas, but one that will never be eliminated. The continual use of stories and poetry allows a reader, who has no connection to the culture, become much more aw...


... middle of paper ...


...order to highlight and glorify her own. By having such a strong opinioned tone, the author has transformed the ethnography in to a rant or a targeted comparison between cultures.
An ethnography describes a culture and people; it shows a culture in a way that other means of expression fail to do. An ethnography should have a balance between opinion and research. This text had the potential to contribute truth, history, cultural practices and importance, about Dia de los Muertos. The information, poetry, and stories presented, where them selves, beautiful; however, the tone and language used, clouded and distracted from the purpose and content. A balance between personal ideas and what the cultural practice is, without personal bias would have transcended the message of the ethnography, and made it about the practice it self, not the authors feelings on the matter.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Death Of The Dead By Dia De Los Muertos

- Death and Life When you think of death, it usually connects with a million emotions at once, sadness, anger, regret, the empty feeling you have in your heart, or maybe even fear. But for the Mexican culture, death is happiness Of course everyone gets sad thinking about a loved one who has passed away, but they rather mourn in happiness than in sadness. Dia de los Muertos, or Day of the Dead is an old Mexican tradition that has been transformed throughout the years.This special holiday is considered one of the most important ones in Mexico....   [tags: Aztec, Mexico, Day of the Dead]

Better Essays
1022 words (2.9 pages)

The Day Of The Dead By El Dia De Los Muertos Parade Essay

- El Dia de los Muertos, or Day of the Dead, is a Mexican holiday celebrated throughout Mexico, the United States and the Central and South Regions. In most places it is celebrated on November 2nd. It is a day where families and friends come together to pray for their family and friends that have passed away to aid them in their spiritual journey. The celebrations begin from October 31st until November 2nd. They have a variety of traditions, but the most festive is the Dia de los Muertos parade. With an array of colorful lights, sounds and clothing, the parade creates a magnificent display that truly portrays the happiest moments for those who have lost someone special....   [tags: Day of the Dead, Death, Human skeleton, Brad Pitt]

Better Essays
889 words (2.5 pages)

Dia de Los Muertos Essay

- Scared of the dead. You shouldn’t be. Did you know throughout Mexico they celebrate the day of the dead. They call it Dia De Los Muertos. On This holiday, they celebrate the passing of their loved ones. In United States, on October 31 we celebrate Halloween, this day we dress up on our most scariest costume, trick-or-treat for candies, and scare others just for the fun of it. They say it’s the day where the dead rise, maybe that’s why most people are afraid of this day. In Mexico, this holiday occurs on the day of October 31 and ending on November 2....   [tags: souls, celebration, skulls]

Better Essays
813 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Dia de Los Muertos

- I am going to tell you about a famous, yet kinda eerie celebration that takes place in mexico. This is a tradition celebrated by the Mexican Natives, most Mexican Americans (including myself) don’t even acknowledge this day, unless they happen to be visiting mexico at the time of this event. Foreigners have more trouble understanding Dia de Los Muertos than any of Mexico's other celebrations. At first glance, they see Day of the Dead decorations which are colored paper garlands, little skeletons performing daily tasks and sugar skulls inscribed with names, which remind them of Halloween....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
949 words (2.7 pages)

El Dia de los Muertos Essay

- In this Essay, I will enlighten you about the “Dia de los Muertos” in the Spanish culture. It will contain the history of the holiday, the events that go on during it, and the food eaten on that day. One thing that you must remember is that Dia de los Muertos traditions vary from town to town because Mexico is not culturally monolithic. El Dia de los Muertos goes back to the Aztecs, who had not just a few days but an entire month dedicated to the dead. When the Spanish conquistadors vanquished the Aztecs, they changed the tradition so it was at the same time of All Saints’ Day and All Souls’ Day....   [tags: Spanish Culture]

Free Essays
306 words (0.9 pages)

Class Distinction Shown in The Prince and the Pauper Essay example

- In his book, The Prince and the Pauper, Mark Twain highlights class distinction very often. It plays an immensely important role in his novel, because Twain places his two main characters in the total extremes of the social class. Through these characters, Edward and Tom, Twain illustrates the vast difference between the high and low ends of the social class in England, shows how ignorant they were of each other, proves that a person's social status was determined by his appearance, and demonstrates that social status does not show the true worth of a person....   [tags: classism, class distinction, Mark Twain]

Better Essays
2543 words (7.3 pages)

The Day Of The Dead Essay

- The Day of the Dead also known as Dia De Los Muertos occurs on November 2, the day after the Dia De lots Inocentes which happens to fall on November 1st ,which in translation means the day of the innocents or the day of the little angels. These rituals are highly known in Mexico, Latina America, Spain, Italy, South America , Philippines and some parts of the United States, they are mainly celebrated in Catholic based countries and people. It 's been a ritual and tradition that many indigenous people have been celebrating for the past 3000 years....   [tags: Death, Afterlife, Day of the Dead, Life]

Better Essays
1054 words (3 pages)

The Day Of The Dead Essay example

- Gone but never forgotten :The Day of the Dead Thomas Campbell once said “ To live in hearts we leave behind ,Is not to die.” I am sure at a point we have all wondered what happens after death .Reincarnation , afterlife , and heaven or hell are all things we have heard of . It is only natural because death is inevitable. While some presume they have to mourn the death of their loved ones , the Aztecs believed death was something to celebrate. Today i will inform you about the origins of the day of the dead , how it is celebrated in the Mexican culture , and its transformation in the US through migration....   [tags: Mexico, Aztec, Day of the Dead, Mexican American]

Better Essays
1209 words (3.5 pages)

Class Distinction in Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice Essay

- Class distinction is one of Jane Austen’s themes in the novel, and the differentiation related to it is evidently depicted. Reading the novel from the first chapter, I realize that the author clearly illustrates that class is what matters most in many of the incidences displayed by the characters. Unless an individual is of a given class, the idea that he or she has money is not valued, since only birth in a certain background is what is of value. When a person openly values money over class, such a person is frowned upon....   [tags: class distinction, darcy]

Better Essays
996 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Ethnic Makeup Of Los Angeles

- Since 1965 many people of different ethnic backgrounds have immigrated to the greater Los Angeles area than anywhere within the United States. These immigrants have rapidly and profoundly transformed the city’s ethnic makeup and spared heated debate over their impact on the region. Unfortunately within many areas of Los Angeles there are those who have been pushed out of their homes, which have been passed through generations of ethnic minorities in other areas due to gentrification. These gentrified areas have been renovated by the city to allow for a much more comfortable living experience....   [tags: Nutrition, Health, Los Angeles]

Better Essays
1578 words (4.5 pages)