Essay on The Davis Trial-Accused of Murder by Abortion

Essay on The Davis Trial-Accused of Murder by Abortion

Length: 1532 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Queen vs. Davis case concerns the murder trial of Arthur Paul Davis and Alice Davis that occurred in 1875. In it, they were tried and convicted of murder for conducting an abortion; the killing of a fetus and subsequently causing death of the victims, Catherine Laing and Jane Vaughn Gilmour. This essay will examine the historical context of the case, what the trial reveals about the nature of women’s lives in Toronto during the 1870s as subordinate women who are deemed as caretakers and how women managed to end unwanted pregnancies. During the late 19th century ending an unwanted pregnancy was an illegal offence because it was considered unethical to kill a fetus. Women were not able to access safer alternatives such as contraception, as it was an offence to sell or advertise them at that time. Women did not claim they wanted an abortion directly, but rather that they wanted to be fixed of their problem. They did not feel guilty as they thought it was acceptable to induce abortion before the 3rd month of pregnancy or quickening of it, which under the English common law, it was not wrongful to procure an abortion prior to the feeling any movement of the fetus. Doing an Abortion was a private matter but nonetheless a criminal offence. Beginning in the early 19th century, laws were passed to support the prohibition of abortions; these then continued on to the revision and creation of the 1892 criminal code for abortion.
In 1875, Dr. Arthur Paul Davis and Alice Davis of Toronto, feloniously and willfully murdered Catherine Laing and then subsequently a week following on Sunday morning murdered Jane Vaughn Gilmour. They were found guilty of the crime committed to victim Gilmour as the case with Laing did not preced...

... middle of paper ...

...936), Aug 10, 1875, 1875.
Canada, Criminal Code, RSC 1892, c 29 (Ottawa: Queen's Printer).
Archives of Ontario, RG-22-392, Attorney General of Ontario, Criminal Indictment Files, York County, 1875, R. vs. Davis. "Inquiry"

McLaren, Angus. Birth control and abortion in canada, 1870–1920. Canadian Historical Review Volume 59 (3): 319-40.

Backhouse, Constance B. "Involuntary motherhood: abortion, birth control and the law in nineteenth century Canada." Windsor YB Access Just. 3 (1983): 61.

----. Petticoats and prejudice women and law in nineteenth century canada. ACLS humanities E-book., eds. American Council of Learned Societies - York University., Osgoode Society. Toronto: Published for Osgoode Society by Women's Press.

Beahen, William. "Abortion and Infanticide in Western Canada 1874 to 1916: A Criminal Case Study." Canadian Historical Review (1978).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Is Abortion a Murder? Essay

- To begin, according to the Merriam Webster dictionary, “abortion is the spontaneous or induced termination of a pregnancy after, accompanied by, resulting in, or closely followed by the death of the embryo or fetus.” Frankly speaking, abortion is the deliberate act or termination of a life (pregnancy). Most often the abortion is performed during the first twenty-eight (28) weeks of the pregnancy. Life begins upon the sperm and egg culminating/conception, whether this implantation/merging is called an embryo or fetus, it is in fact a human being....   [tags: pregnancy, crime, death, murder, children, rights]

Term Papers
1236 words (3.5 pages)

Abortion Is Murder Essay

- The topic of abortion is an extremely controversial issue in today's society, there are many separate views on the morality of it. Abortion is defined as the deliberate termination of a human pregnancy (“Abortion”). In other words, it is the murder of an unborn child. Throughout the past there has been several court cases related to abortion, in attempt to resolve the debate. For example, Roe v. Wade declared that unborn children are neither ‘persons’ nor are they entitled to the same constitutional protection as born children (“Roe V....   [tags: Abortion Pro Life Essays]

Term Papers
1290 words (3.7 pages)

Abortion Is The Murder Of An Innocent Essay

- First of all, abortion is the murder of an innocent, unborn child. Pro-choice people will argue that a fetus is dependent on its mother and cannot survive alone; they contest that because a fetus lacks properties of a human being such as reason, consciousness, and self-awareness, they are not human and therefore it is just to “terminate” them (Jones). This wicked and corrupt thought process could not be more wrong. Much of the murder debate revolves around when life actually starts. Conservatives that are pro-life argue that life begins at conception, while pro-choice liberals argue it does not start until actual birth, when they consider the child to be “viable.” Jerome Lejeune is a French...   [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Human, Fetus]

Term Papers
1080 words (3.1 pages)

Abortion Is An Act Of Murder Essay

- In 1973 the Supreme Court was presented with Roe v. Wade. The ruling on this case caused an addition to be made to the the 14th Amendment, extending the right to a woman’s decision to have an abortion. Abortions can currently be done legally, yet out of the 44 million abortions done each year, half are done unsafely. Regardless of this statistic, many religious beliefs oppose the idea and condemn an individual who decides to have one. However, while many people believe abortion is an act of murder, abortion should remain legal because a large percentage of the female population will always need this option available for reasons such as a lack of income, family support, or medical issues....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Fetus, Childbirth]

Term Papers
956 words (2.7 pages)

Abortion is a Murder Essay

- ... It causes suffering and the act of killing is generally terribly painful. Not only does it put the victim in grief, but it also greatly impacts the victim’s family, friends, and loved ones. Mostly everyone believes that deliberately taking someone’s life is simply wrong. No religion permits one to kill a human being for any reason whatsoever. No human has the power and the right to take another person’s life. Murder is usually done for selfish reasons, such as for money or for property. Moreover, murder is done without the consent of the person....   [tags: debate, society, killing, unethical]

Term Papers
730 words (2.1 pages)

Is Abortion Murder Be Outlawed? Essay

- Is Abortion Murder. Throughout the decades, women have planned out their family. They have designed the size, gender, and how far apart they want their children. Unfortunately in today’s society many women are using abortion as a type of birth control. A large portion of society believes that an abortion is the wrong action to take, and it should be made illegal. This consists of not only in the United States but throughout the entire world. Abortion should be outlawed everywhere because it is murder to an innocent child, it is a health risk to the mother, family problems, and it causes women to have emotional, physical, and, mental abuse after the procedure....   [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Woman, United States]

Term Papers
1050 words (3 pages)

Abortion Is Murder Essay

- Abortion is one of the most controversial issues in the United States. I feel that the pro-life side of this argument needs to be addressed and further explained. There are some babies that die by chance , but they should never die because of someone's else choice. All of us alive today could have been an aborted baby and never been given the chance to live life. But luckily for us, our mothers chose life. The definition of abortion according to the Merriam Webster Dictionary is the deliberate termination of human pregnancy....   [tags: Anti Abortion Essay]

Term Papers
925 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Abortion is Murder

- In this paper I plan on showing you my point of view as well as the opposite point of view using a point by point basis. Each paragraph will be a statement from the opposite point of view and then my rebuttal.      The pro-choice side of this argument says that abortion should be kept legal for cases in which the baby’s birth endangers the life of the mother. This is an argument that is basically trying to create sympathy among uneducated voters to try to woo them to the pro-choice side of the argument and to elect pro-choice politicians....   [tags: Abortion, argumentative, persuasive]

Term Papers
507 words (1.4 pages)

Abortion is Not Murder Essay example

- Abortion is Not Murder Is abortion murder?  Murder is defined as "illegal killing with malice aforethought." Abortion fails this definition for two reasons. First, abortion is not illegal, and second, there is no evidence to suggest that expecting mothers feel malice towards their own flesh and blood. Not all killing is murder, of course. Murder is actually a small subset of all killing, which includes accidental homicide, killing in self-defense, suicide, euthanasia, etc. When pro-life activists call abortion "murder," they are suggesting that abortion fits the definition of murder, namely, "illegal killing with malice aforethought." However, abortion fails this definition for two reaso...   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]

Term Papers
1201 words (3.4 pages)

Partial Birth Abortion is Murder Essay

- Partial Birth Abortion is Murder Partial birth abortion is a controversial method of abortion late in a woman’s pregnancy in which the baby is aborted by a craniotomy. Two organizations are commonly affiliated with abortion: Pro-choice supports abortion saying that what is in a woman’s body is her “property”, while Pro-life believes it is murder of innocent babies. Partial birth abortion is murder of innocent children and an abomination to basic human rights and values. Thesis Statement: Partial birth abortion is murder of innocent babies and an abomination to basic human rights and values....   [tags: Argument Argumentative Persuasive Abortion Essays]

Term Papers
1447 words (4.1 pages)