David Rudd’s ‘defence’ of the work of Enid Blyton Essay

David Rudd’s ‘defence’ of the work of Enid Blyton Essay

Length: 1140 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Critics view the books by Pullman and Ransom as examples of literary excellence. In order to evaluate this opinion it is necessary to discuss what aspects contribute to a good book and how these books illustrate them. The American Library Associate (ALA) uses the term eduo-brow to mean the middle ground of literature with an educational emphasis. This emphasis is on increasing the experiences of the reader through varied language, dynamic themes, rounded characterisation and comprehensive plots. The critics favour works that involve the reader in a non-passive manner to gain insights into universal aspects of human existence like love, identity, revenge, sexuality and betrayal.
Pullman has written a basic adventure story laced with multiple themes, metaphors and ideas. He uses intertextuality to enrich his text and enhance his ideas and arguments. His main critique is the theology surrounding Fall literature where experience replaces innocence. He compares this idea with the journey of his main female protagonists from an innocent childhood to the knowledgeable complexities of adulthood. Pullman questions the role of obedience in his novels and encourages the reader through the text to question and analyse in order to form their own opinions. Whereas Ransom has some intertextuality in his novel, his main strength is realism and practicality while seamlessly intertwining fantasy. He places the children at the centre of the story giving them a voice through focalisation with true to life dialogue. The reader interacts with the text through a powerful sense of place and detailed descriptions of practicalities like sailing.
In contrast, according to Rudd, critics view Blyton’s books as the embodiment of bad literature. Rudd argue...

... middle of paper ...

...sources with realistic setting into extended imaginative play is observable in children’s play. The support of the adults, providing the necessities for the adventure, allows the protagonists to play in a safe and secure environment. In this case, the mother also supports the fantasy and imaginative play by becoming Queen Beth and a native. The emergence of the child’s voice through focalisation and naturalistic dialogue creates a child’s viewpoint. Therefore, the other characters are on the periphery of this viewpoint creating a democratic feel to the text. This reflects children’s observable attitudes to others. Ransom not only characterises children’s play but also reflect the attitudes and values of his own world. The heavily gender specific roles of the children and minimal parental supervision is horrific by values of today’s inclusive and diverse society.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Analysis Of Enid Blyton 's ' The Secret Seven ' And ' Noddy '

- Controversial events can happen in this unstable and opinionated society at about anytime, and about anything as people with different opinions and views clash in order to get their viewpoint across. These include about racism, gender and political events that have happened. Enid Blyton is a typical example, as she was a very controversial English child writer, whose books have been among the top sellers in the world ever since the 1930’s. Blyton was mainly recognized for her works like ‘The Secret Seven’, ‘The Famous Five’ and ‘Noddy’, just to name a few....   [tags: Gender, Discrimination, Stereotype, Enid Blyton]

Strong Essays
1003 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Vic Wilcox in David Lodge's Novel "Nice Work"

- Vic Wilcox in David Lodge's Novel "Nice Work" In the opening chapter of "Nice Work" we are introduced to Vic Wilcox, Managing Director of "J. Pringle & Sons Casting and General Engineering". He lives in an upmarket house on the outskirts of Rummage with his wife Marjorie and his three children. Raymond, Sandra and Gary. Vic is man who is quintessentially British. So much so that he refuses to buy goods made out of the country, the reason for his annoyance at Marjorie wanting a microwave (96% manufactured in the East) and for buying a Japanese clock radio....   [tags: Nice Work David Lodge Essays]

Strong Essays
1730 words (4.9 pages)

My Life with SDS and The Weathermen by Mark William Rudd Essay

- Mark William Rudd has written Underground: My Life with SDS and The Weathermen. Mark Rudd is a political organiser, mathematics instructor, anti-war activist and counterculture icon. He is most well known for his involvement with the Weather Underground. Rudd became a member of the Columbia University chapter of Students for a Democratic Society (SDS), in nineteen sixty-three. By nineteen sixty-eight, he became a leader for Columbia’s SDS chapter. Rudd’s works’ include Truth and Consequences: The Education of Mark Rudd and Underground: My Life with SDS and The Weathermen....   [tags: vietnam war, loneliness]

Strong Essays
1478 words (4.2 pages)

Northern Lights and Swallows and Amazons Essay

- Rudd’s (2009) essay evaluates Enid Blyton’s work offering a different perspective to account for the appeal and popularity of the author. This essay looks at the aspects raised by Rudd. How Blyton, Pullman and Ransom illustrate the different aspects of a good or a bad book. The way critics confer prestige on a book or author and the arising criticism. How the agenda of the committees affects the selection of prize-winners. Finally, looking at the factors involved in success. The set books used in his essay are Pullman (1995) Northern Lights and Ransom (2001) Swallows and Amazons....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Blyton, Pullman]

Strong Essays
1983 words (5.7 pages)

What Makes a Successful Children's Book? Essay

- Northern Lights and Tom's Midnight Garden which are both prizewinning, children's books will be discussed in relation to David Rudd's 'defence' of the work of Enid Blyton. This will be achieved by answering the following questions and tying them into Rudd's essay. How can the success of a children’s book best be quantified. What criteria are used for judging children’s books. How do the chosen texts stand up to this criteria. Who are different groups that judge children's books and what criteria do each of them have....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Strong Essays
2279 words (6.5 pages)

Essay on The Accomplishments Of Henry David Thoreau

- Henry David Thoreau was born on July 12th, in Concord Massachusetts. Thoreau was many things, not simply just a writer; but he was one of the most influential writers America knows today. Early on in his life he grew up in a simple home with hard-working parents, and an abundance of siblings. His father and mother both had worked as teachers as well as investing in many other trades to get by. Henry started developing his talent for writing early on, by age ten he had written his first piece of writing, “The Seasons,” as well as many other academic achievements for somebody his age....   [tags: Henry David Thoreau, Walden, Concord]

Strong Essays
1471 words (4.2 pages)

Essay Walden By Henry David Thoreau

- The novel Walden by Henry David Thoreau is a complex piece of literature. The entirety of the book evaluates how we live life with too much luxury, and how we are not truly living. Thoreau uses his experience of only living with the bare necessities which he gets only by hand to explain how the way we live is unnecessary. He makes many points in his novel, most of which vocalize how we live in a world in which we live our lives based on what society tells us to do. Thoreau believes that we do not live for ourselves but more for the mere aspect of surviving....   [tags: Henry David Thoreau, United States]

Strong Essays
1231 words (3.5 pages)

Charles Dickens' Hard Times and David Lodge's Nice Work Essay

- Charles Dickens' Hard Times and David Lodge's Nice Work ----“Fact, fact, fact, everywhere in the material aspect of the town; fact, fact, fact everywhere in the immaterial.” – Charles Dickens In the early 1851, London staged the Great Exhibition to show the world, the achievements and inventions of the Industrial Revolution. Many people believed that this showed how much better, safer and healthier Britain was than its neighbours in Europe. People living in mansions amid lawns and fountains, with horse drawn carriages certainly felt that life couldn’t be better....   [tags: Lodge Dickens Hard Times Nice Work Essays]

Strong Essays
2458 words (7 pages)

Essay on David Copperfield by Charles Dickens

- David Copperfield by Charles Dickens David Copperfield by Charles Dickens is a heartwarming story that takes place in the 1800's in England and is about a young boy named David Copperfield. Who goes through many struggles growing up.. This story teaches the importance of love and how it is greatly needed. David was born on a Friday at twelve o'clock midnight. His father's aunt Miss Betsy was present at his birth and when she found out he was a boy she left and never came back. David lives with his widowed mother and nurse Peggotty, who both love him dearly....   [tags: David Copperfield Charles Dickens]

Free Essays
1028 words (2.9 pages)

Henry David Thoreau Was a Fool Essay

- Lincoln has been credited as being a person that fought for equality between races, when he himself believed that African Americans were inferior, the image people give him is unreal, propaganda by the Radical Republicans in the reconstruction era. Many people have ideas that do not hold up when put to the test, or even their own reasoning. Henry David Thoreau’s ideas and ideals do not hold up when compared to reality. Thoreau believed that if a man did less work, the better it would be for the man and his community....   [tags: Henry David Thoreau Essays]

Free Essays
592 words (1.7 pages)