Essay on Customary Law and the Status of Indigenous Australian's

Essay on Customary Law and the Status of Indigenous Australian's

Length: 1162 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

It is important to always show respect towards the indigenous, acknowledge their laws, their practices and their customs further paying respects to the original custodians of the land. This however does not mean that recognition of aboriginal customary law is essential to improving the status (social position) of indigenous Australians; on the contrary it poses more problems than solutions. Although law is seen as the fabric of existence and intrinsic to living, it is impossible to judge one legal system in terms of another. As such, while there are many positive aspects of aboriginal customary law, which is merely just different and in no means (worse) or (better) than English common law, its enforcement is not essential to improving the status of indigenous Australian’s in society. Many other legal and non-legal remedies have sought and provided better support and status for the indigenous community.
Aboriginal customary law emphasises harmony, entwines the land and the people and ensures surviving. It looks towards the needs of the tribe much like the common law looks towards the needs of society and uses that as the basis for its decisions. However unlike common law, aboriginal customary law is unwritten, unchanging and can vary between the many different indigenous tribes – “there are over 500 indigenous nations in Australia with different cultures, languages and needs”. Consequently, due to the wide spread vast amount of indigenous nations, it would be merely impossible to add just one set of aboriginal customary laws and that one set would have to remain unchanged leaving no room for reform in order to aid the community when scrutiny over the matter occurs. The customary law is also unrecorded and would become diff...

... middle of paper ...

... other legislation and institutions have successfully improved the gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australian’s promoting change, harmony and providing support. The Australian government aim to improve social inadequacies and although the results at times may be limited are ultimately improving Non indigenous and Indigenous Australian’s relations as well as improving the social position of Indigenous Australian’s. Thus recognition of customary law is not essential to improving the status of indigenous Australians and the proposal itself provides the possibility of negative outcomes which could perhaps worsen their status and lead to a decline in their social position.

Works Cited

Michael Sanson et al, Connecting with the law (Oxford University Press, 2d ed, 2010)
Catriona Cook et al, Laying down the law (LexisNexis Butterworth’s, 2012) 79.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Indigenous Australian Land Rights For Indigenous Australians Essay

- ... O’Connor (1992) states that the High Court recognised that Indigenous ownership of the land had survived on Mer as the Meriam people had maintained traditional law and connections to the land, thus, granting the Native title rights over their island. Native title rights over Mer indicated the High Court agreed that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people have rights to the land and that these rights existed before the British arrived (O’Connor, 1992). Following the High Court decision, the Australian Government passed the Native Title Act 1993, to ensure legislative protection to the native title and created the Native Title Tribunal to permit the Federal Government to process any f...   [tags: Australia, Indigenous Australians, Native title]

Strong Essays
1635 words (4.7 pages)

Indigenous Australian Land Rights On Aboriginal And Torres Strait Islanders

- ... Australian Museum (2015) and Creative Spirits (2011) acknowledge the struggle to gain legal recognition and ownership of Indigenous land is difficult and expensive. Furthermore, the history behind the struggle in earlier years often resulted in violence as Indigenous Australians were dispossessed of their land (Australian Museum, 2015). Subsequently, the struggle for land rights continued through the legal and political systems; as demonstrated in 1982 when Eddie (Koiki) Mabo and four other Meriam people decided to pursue declaration of their customary land rights in the High Court of Australia (Hill, 1995)....   [tags: Australia, Indigenous Australians, Native title]

Strong Essays
1722 words (4.9 pages)

Aboriginal Customary Law VS European Law Essay

- Aboriginal customary law and European law have been at odds since the first years of the European invasion, but only recently has the clash come into the open. Stuart MacMillan of the Aboriginal Resource and Development Services in the Northern Territory says that remote Aboriginal communities there and in Western Australia, South Australia and Queensland see no reason why they should submit to "whitefella law". The governments of the Northern Territory and Western Australia are investigating how indigenous law can be incorporated into state law....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
2499 words (7.1 pages)

Aboriginal And Torres Strait Islanders Essay

- ... The Coalition government proposed that all children in an Aboriginal community were at risk and all Aboriginal men were potential abusers. The concept suggested by the government was that Aboriginal children are at risk due to their Aboriginal culture, the government encouraged a ‘normalization’ of the communities and an integration into settler society (Lovell 2012). A significant negative impact of the Emergency Response has been that on Aboriginal men and families. The perception that child sexual abuse and violence is prevalent in Aboriginal families and communities has had a demonising effect on Aboriginal men and families, within the community and the wider Australian community....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Australia]

Strong Essays
1202 words (3.4 pages)

Indigenous Speeches: Exploration of the Mabo Case, Stolen Generation and Reconciliation

- Exploration of the Mabo Case, Stolen Generation and Reconciliation Both Keating’s and Rudd’s speeches are firmly based on the ideas of recognition and reconciliation for the wrongs that European settlers, and their decedents, have inflicted on Indigenous Australians. To explore this idea I believe that it is necessary to take a closer look at both the plight of Eddie Mabo and the stories of the Stolen Generation. The Mabo Case Eddie Mabo is widely known for his plight to regain land rights for both Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people....   [tags: european settlers, stolen generation ]

Strong Essays
1838 words (5.3 pages)

Essay Australian Aborigines

- Australian Aborigines For Aborigines, Australia was a marginally better place in which to live in 1945 then in 1900. At the turn of the century, the Australian state governments neither had a uniform nor clear Aboriginal policy. Treatment of Aborigines was consequently decided by society’s individual attitudes, not law. While many people (white) were aggressive towards Aborigines till well past 1945, a general more sympathetic attitude towards them started to slightly ease the strong oppression they were shackled by....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
2538 words (7.3 pages)

Indigenous Australians And The Australian Criminal Justice System Essay

- Police discretion is the power to make a decision on a police officer’s own judgement. These decisions can range from how serious they think a domestic violence complaint is or if they should pursue a minor offence such as racism toward themselves. The ability to make decisions like these leaves a clear indicator as to why Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples are over represented in the Australian criminal justice system. Many factors related to discretionary decision making are responsible for this representation....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Indigenous peoples]

Strong Essays
2349 words (6.7 pages)

The National Indigenous And Non Australian Indigenous Essay

- ... Another prominent individual used was Adam Goods, an AFL legend, who is respected by the wide Australian community as an Indigenous football player. Adam Goods, (2016) reflected how even his other Indigenous football teammates who came on board were so far behind everyone else when it came to their literacy and numeracy skills, they had to educate them to understand what was happening in the meetings (as cited in …., 2016). This demonstrates how some Indigenous are lacking in their basic skills as the system of teaching may not have been right for them....   [tags: Australia, Indigenous Australians]

Strong Essays
2184 words (6.2 pages)

The Representation And Understanding Of Indigenous Australians Essay

- The representation and understanding of Indigenous Australians is shaped by various values, events, and methods in the Australian community. Three strong forces of this representation are the topics which will be discussed in this essay: the historical timeline from colonisation to resistance, race and racism, and the media. These topics encompasses themes of knowledge, power, and genuine discernment and compassion in in the Australian community. These topics are all interlinked extensively, as it is virtually impossible to speak of one without bringing forth the other issues....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Australia, Racism]

Strong Essays
1994 words (5.7 pages)

Indigenous Australians Health And Leisure Essay

- Indigenous Australians are defined as inhabitants of the land prior to colonization of Australia (Mooney, 2013). For the purpose of this paper indigenous Australians health and leisure will be further explored. Leisure and health are important components an individual must maintain through out their life. Whether an individual participates in leisure is based on mental, social, physical and environmental factors. These factors may be positive influences or negative influences on the group. The health of an individual is based on physiology, unfortunately for indigenous Australians there are particular diseases, which are more commonly diagnosed....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Australia, Health]

Strong Essays
1022 words (2.9 pages)