Cultural Morality: Comparative Analysis between a Fine Balance and the Poisionwood Bible

Cultural Morality: Comparative Analysis between a Fine Balance and the Poisionwood Bible

Length: 1306 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Cultural Morality
Comparative Analysis between A Fine Balance and the Poisionwood Bible

Cultural relativism really emphasizes the concept that each individual cultural belief differs from one societal class to another; in consequence, moral and ethical principles are related to what a certain culture perceives to be considered acceptable or unacceptable, right or wrong. Jack Donnelly, a teacher at the University of Denver, he states, "when internal and external judgments of a practice diverge," an uncontrollable rivalry, " cultural relativists give priority to be the internal judgements of a society" (89). Cultural relativism correlates with the idea that ones own personal religious belief is above anyone else's, thus, all beliefs in society should be assessed with the same principles that they themselves hold. Rohin Mistry, the author of the book A Fine Balance suggests that Muslims in India during the 1970's were discriminated upon, as Hindus they acted on their own religious beliefs trying to fix or turn "animals," into what they believe is proper, in an ethnocentric manner. It can be stated that the majority of the Hindus did not attempt to accept Muslims because of their religion during this period of time; consequently the the people of Islam living in India faced hatred and were almost entirely wiped out of India. Mistry focuses depicts Ishvar and Omprakash's relationships as only a smaller portion of what most Muslims went through during the 70's. Barbra Kingsolver, the author of the novel The Poisonwood Bible also discovers a parallel when discussing the methods in which Western society encounters unfamiliar foreign countries. Kingsolver creates an allegory where the Price family and the people of the Congo exemplify...


... middle of paper ...


...308) Anatole is trying to explain that the missionaries are pushing the Congolese down just as the ants are pushed down, and the result if enthocentrism can be detrimental.
The entirety of the two novels A Fine Balance and The Poisonwood Bible is a series of microcosms through which Kingsolver and Mistry advance their political agendas; that the practice of enthocentrism is destructive and that a cultural relativism is a more enlightened concept. In the novels, they portray a country and a foreign society in a different light than most are accustomed: in a light of equality. As shocking and and unsettling as unfamiliar rituals and characteristics can be, Kingsolver and Mistry suggest that one must not only tolerate them, but ultimately accept them. There us no foreigner, we are all the same: human beings suited to their surroundings and doing their best to survive.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Poisonwood Bible as a Catalog of Romanticism

- The Poisonwood Bible as a Catalog of Romanticism        In The Poisonwood Bible, by Barbara Kingsolver, the romantic standards that are associated with literature during the American Renaissance are evident. This popular novel, a New York Times Bestseller, embodies the concept of Romanticism with its gothic darkness, themes of loss and nostalgia, and a strong captivity narrative. The presence of a wise child and recurring double language are essential to the plot of the story. Nathan Price's misguided mission to save souls in the Congo is transformed into an evil that invades a type of Paradise and so, the reader realizes immediately that this twisted attempt to Christianize the savages...   [tags: Poisonwood Bible Essays]

Strong Essays
3766 words (10.8 pages)

Essay about Faith in Kingsolver's Poisonwood Bible

- Faith in Kingsolver's Poisonwood Bible Throughout the Poisonwood Bible, Kingsolver utilizes the experience of the Congo to enhance and rediscover the faith of three of the Price daughters. At the age of fifteen, Rachel, the Price's oldest child, reveals her true beliefs of her religion through her petulant remarks of the Congo. During her stay in Africa, Rachel only talks of possessions she left behind. Rachel misses items such as toilet paper and sets of clean clothes. She, however, doesn't mention the bible in the list of items she longs for....   [tags: Kingsolver Poisonwood Bible]

Strong Essays
660 words (1.9 pages)

To what extent is Cultural Arrogance a driving force of conflict in The Poisonwood Bible?

- The Poisonwood Bible is a novel written by Barbara Kingsolver, portraying the life of the Price family, coming from Georgia to the Congo as a missionary family. By analyzing the cultural arrogance Kingsolver includes in the novel, it is possible to understand the many compositions the bring books, in relation to how the people live in comparison to different geographical and economical locations of the country, why certain things are necessary to happen and the relation of nature and man. Analyzing the cultural arrogance allows the readers to understand the two major perspectives in the book, and how they interact with each other....   [tags: Barbara Kingsolver, Congo, man vs nature]

Strong Essays
3363 words (9.6 pages)

The Poisonwood Bible and the Life of Barbara Kingsolver Essay example

- Humans have the unique ability to create artwork. Be that in the form of a painting, musical composition, or work of fiction, creativity is the ability to rearrange available materials to create something unique and innovative. Many writers view writing as a way to express their deepest ideas and emotions creatively. American journalist Earnest Hemmingway believed that “There is nothing to writing. All you do is sit down at a typewriter and bleed.” Writers often will use their own life experiences to re-experience important parts of their lives and translate it into a story to share with the world....   [tags: literary and biographical analysis]

Strong Essays
1132 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Interpretation of "The Poisonwood Bible" in the Humanities

- Since its 1998 publication, The Poisonwood Bible has primarily been seen as a statement against American exceptionalism. Upon analyzing the novel it is obvious that subjects such as imperialism, religion, the burden of guilt, and the use of, or lack thereof, voices, contribute to multiple points and themes found in the novel. In Susan Strehle’s current article on American exceptionalism explicitly relating to The Poisonwood Bible, she manipulates the topics and themes found in the novel to support her opinion....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Strong Essays
2092 words (6 pages)

Essay about The Poisonwood Bible by Barbara Kingsolver

- Explication of theme: The Poisonwood Bible exemplifies the importance of language, especially foreign languages. It is fairly obvious that language plays a role in this work- an English-speaking white Christian family moves to a rich, multicultural society. This new society has picked up on “easy” English phrases, but also speaks French, and its native African languages. Language can be seen as not only a sign of knowledge and scholarship, but a sign of close or open-mindedness. Language is associated with imperialism (especially in this novel, and especially relating to the United States)....   [tags: Importance of Language, Literary Analysis]

Strong Essays
1610 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on The Poisonwood Bible by Nathan Price

- ... The story reads, “Women are expected to wear just one style of garment and no other. But the men, now that is a course of different color” (44). By this, Rachel is explaining how the men in the Congo get to wear whatever they want to wear, whereas the women are segregated and made to wear the same thing every single day. In the novel, Orleanna says, “I was his instrument, his animal. Nothing more. How we wives and mothers do perish at the hands of our own righteousness” (89). Orleanna is stating that she is a like a slave to her husband and must drop everything for him....   [tags: congo, feminist characteristics]

Strong Essays
745 words (2.1 pages)

The Poisonwood Bible by Barbara Kingsolver Essay

- ... She never truly comes to terms with it and gains exponentially more regrets as she ages. Leah shows an example of someone unable to let go, who instead carries the guilt and lets it eat away at her. Because she was never able to come to terms with any of the past events, her soul will forever be burdened. Forgiveness of one’s self is freeing but first one must accept that the past is irreversible. Another way to deal with one’s past regrets is to find ways to cooperate, such as searching for logical explanations and finding peace in logic instead of letting feelings take over....   [tags: repressing memory, past regret]

Strong Essays
915 words (2.6 pages)

Nathan Price: The Poisonwood Bible Essay

- The Poisonwood Bible is the story of an evangelical Baptist preacher named Nathan Price who uproots his wife and four daughters from the modern culture of America and moves them to the Kilanga Village in the Belgian Congo as missionaries. He is bullheaded and obstinate in all his ways. His approach is inflexible, unsympathetic, and unaccepting of the culture and customs of the people of Kilanga. Nathan Price exemplifies the words of Romans 2:4 that says, “Or do you despise the riches of His goodness, forbearance, and longsuffering, not knowing the goodness of God leads you to repentance?” He did not share the goodness of God, but sought to spread his uncompromising pious agenda....   [tags: god, modern culture, pious agenda]

Strong Essays
683 words (2 pages)

Poisonwood Bible Essay

- Poisonwood Bible Barbara Kingsolver is the author of many well-written pieces of literature including The Poisonwood Bible. This novel explores the beauty and hardships that exist in the Belgian Congo in 1959. Told by the wife and four daughters of a fierce Baptist, Nathan Price, Kingsolver clearly captures the realities this family and mission went through during their move to the Congo. The four daughters were raised in Atlanta Georgia in the 1950’s therefore entering the Congo with preconceived racial beliefs, and a very different way of life than they would soon experience....   [tags: English Literature Essays]

Strong Essays
1936 words (5.5 pages)