Critique Of The Working Poor Essay

Critique Of The Working Poor Essay

Length: 1128 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

When writing a book that person is faced with not only the vulnerability of expressing their opinions, but also the acceptance of what another person’s opinion might be from reading the book. In fact critics have a very strong influence on what a person will take in when reading a book. Their critique will determine whether that person will take the time to buy and read the work that author spent many months or even years to write. “While agreeing with Shiplers points of the working poor, I also agree with the critics’ critique of the non-working poor who live at poverty in America and the faults in the lack of a broader study.”
Joel Schwartz, a critic who took the time to read Shiplers book, The Working Poor, to tell the world his opinion about the book, starts off explaining the important factors that he obtained while reading The Working Poor. He pulls in a man named Lawrence Mead a scientist who studied the results of the working poor and explained that Shipler further explained the meaning behind Meads explanations. “MORE than a decade ago, the political scientist, Lawrence Mead predicted that the passage of workfare legislation would move American politics to the left, because mainstream Americans would be more receptive to easing the lot of "a poor population working at higher levels." To the extent that welfare reform transformed the idle poor into the working poor, the poor would be viewed with greater sympathy. The publication of David Shipler 's study, “The Working Poor: Invisible in America” shows Mead 's prescience.”(Schwartz, Joel. "Work and Poverty." Public Interest 157 (2004): 131-135. Academic Search Complete. Web. 28 Sept. 2015.). Furthermore Schwartz explains how Shipler had interviewed many people of the work...


... middle of paper ...


.... Web. 28 Sept.2015.)
As a result Shipler had some great arguments and opinions when explaining different aspects of the working poor. He takes the reader into a world that some may have had no idea existed, but as Schwartz pointed out Shipler fails to acknowledge that a vast majority of people in poverty or living off of welfare are not working, whether it’s by a specific situation or by choice. Also Shipler limiting himself when interviewing only a few individuals could affect a convincing argument. Though that is a good direction to pull a reader in, it is not the most significant example when talking about a global issue. Both critics exemplified Shiplers points and outcomes that he was trying to get across and both had different disagreements with the book The Working Poor. I personally agree with the critics arguments with what they obtained from Shiplers book.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Political Process Model : A Critique Of Resource Mobilization Theory

- Political Process Model was developed as a critique of Resource Mobilization Theory, which tended to focus only on formal organisational networks. As Beinin and Vairel point out, since then several scholars have recognised the importance of informal networks. As they argue, informal factors shape social movements (10-11). As Baylouni (2013: 89) puts it, ‘[m]uch transformation occurs through both the dynamics of everyday life and member involvement in movement institutions that are not geared to formal politics’ (89)....   [tags: Social class, Working class, Middle class]

Better Essays
1684 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on "The Great Gatsby" - A Critique of Capitalism

- F. Scott Fitzgerald’s masterpiece, The Great Gatsby, can be read as a critique of capitalism. Fitzgerald created a world where class and money are the essence of everyone’s desire. The plot and the settings of unfolding events in The Great Gatsby are perfect examples of structures of capitalism, along class lines, which allows for a Marxist capitalist critique. Even though Fitzgerald wasn’t a socialist or Marxist himself, he shows in his book how capitalism creates and alienates different social classes....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Better Essays
1088 words (3.1 pages)

Critique : Why Tipping Is Wrong Essay

- Critique: Why Tipping is Wrong The idea of tipping has always been normal to myself, as I was a kid and still now I see my parents leaving tips for the waiter/waitress when we go out to eat. It never occurred to me until I got older that it was hard for these workers to get by as their salary depended upon their tips. Once I read Saru Jayaraman’s article on “Why Tipping is Wrong” I was unsure of what I was getting myself into. However, it brought light and told how we should be getting rid of tips and giving the workers a fair and decent salary....   [tags: Minimum wage, Wage, United States, Poverty]

Better Essays
887 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on Marx 's Critique Of Religion

- Is Marx’s critique of religion for the most part correct, partially correct, or too simplistic (black and white) to be right. In my opinion Marx 's investigation into the realm of religion is for the most part correct, but his views do imply very black and white reasoning; he said all feedback starts with the feedback of religion. The portrayal of religion as the heart of a cutthroat world in this way turns into an investigation not of religion essentially but rather of the world as it exists. What this shows is that his thought of religion, governmental issues, financial aspects and society in general was not just a philosophical activity, but rather a dynamic endeavor to change the world,...   [tags: Karl Marx, Marxism, Philosophy, Religion]

Better Essays
2142 words (6.1 pages)

Article Critique : Work Life And Patient Safety Culture Essay

- Summary Article Critique: Work Life and Patient Safety Culture in Canadian Healthcare Introduction Poor job satisfaction can lead to potential burnout and reduced productivity and quality of work, is an accepted fact in most of Canada. However would the same be true about healthcare workers and their effects on patient care and outcomes. Health care workers are held to high standards and strict policies about the care that they provide. The argument is that due to these high demands and decreased time and support, the patients of healthcare staff that have a poor work life and suffer from burnout are also suffering....   [tags: Health care, Health care provider, Patient]

Better Essays
1219 words (3.5 pages)

Critique of Infant Determinism Essay example

- Critique of Infant Determinism Do experiences during early years solely determine later development. In the second chapter of his book "Three Seductive Ideas" (1998), Kagan questions the overemphasis on the first two years of an individual's life. While not doubting its importance, Kagan suggests that perhaps more crucial to human development is the construction of experience, perception, and comparison of ourselves to others which begins during the fifth or sixth year of life. His argument is a valid one, regarding the fact that infant determinism overrates the importance of first two years in a person’s whole lifetime....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
636 words (1.8 pages)

Documentary Critique Essay

- This is a critique of" Roger And Me", a documentary by Michael Moore. This is a film about a city that at one time had a great economy. The working class people lived the American dream. The majority of people in this town worked at the large GM factory. The factory is what gave these people security in their middle working class home life. Life in the city of Flint was good until Roger Smith the CEO of GM decided to close the factory. This destroyed the city. Violent crime became the highest in the nation, businesses went bankrupt, people were evicted from their rented homes....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
959 words (2.7 pages)

The Working Poor By David Shipler Essay

- Poverty is a tremendous problem in the United States. Unfortunately, many of the families who are living in poverty have much more difficulty finding good jobs than those who are not. In The Working Poor, by David Shipler, there are many different circumstances that cause people to get to that point. Many of those in poverty have too many barriers in their way for them to be able to rise above the poverty line and support themselves. Some circumstances that cannot be avoided like disabilities or being born into a poor household can create biases that make it more difficult to get employment....   [tags: Poverty, Family, Disability, Working poor]

Better Essays
1315 words (3.8 pages)

The Working Poor By David Shipler Essay

- The Working Poor Stories about life 's struggle to survive in everyday America can make one think twice of the American dream. In David Shipler’s book The Working Poor, David tells many different tales of people living in poverty and also analyzes what 's wrong and why. The book’s portrayal of the poor is not for the meek however, as one reviewer exclaims, “Through a series of sensitive, sometimes heart-rending portraits”, (Lenkowsky). In the book a lot of American ideologies are turned on its head as The Red Phoenix explains how our poor are viewed as, “Wealth and decadence are the tell-tale signs of hard work and brilliance paying off, while poverty is a sign of laziness, irresponsibility...   [tags: Poverty, Wealth, Working poor, James Truslow Adams]

Better Essays
1079 words (3.1 pages)

Literary Critique of Langston Hughes Essay

- Langston Hughes’s writing showcases a variety of themes and moods, and his distinguished career led his biographer, Arnold Rampersad, to describe him as “perhaps the most representative black American writer.” Many of his poems illustrate his role as a spokesman for African American society and the working poor. In others, he relates his ideas on the importance of heritage and the past. Hughes accomplishes this with a straightforward, easily understandable writing style that clearly conveys his thoughts and opinions, although he has frequently been criticized for the slightly negative tone to his works....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
812 words (2.3 pages)