Critique of Scholarly Article on Guns and Crime Essay

Critique of Scholarly Article on Guns and Crime Essay

Length: 1665 words (4.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Critique of Scholarly Article on Guns and Crime

Focus and Findings

In their article Gun Ownership as a Risk Factor For Homicide in The Home, Arthur Kellerman and his colleagues state that gun ownership increases the risk of violent crimes in the home instead of conferring protection. However, after reviewing their claims a number of flaws in their research and data collection methods are evident. There are a series of inappropriate conclusions and validity concerns throughout the article – having realized that these exist – it is impossible to sustain that gun ownership leads to higher homicide rates. Further research is needed to determine if a casual relationship is at all present and then to ascertain the true nature of the potential link.

Kellermann, et al. relies upon their analysis to call for stricter gun control measures but because of the unreliability of their conclusions, these findings cannot be accepted as valid. The memo will show these concerns and demonstrate how the analysis provided on Gun Ownership as a Risk Factor For Homicide in The Home is not appropriate for determining changes to policies in gun ownership regulations.

Key Policy Questions

Kellermann et al. attempt to address whether owning a fire arm increases the risk factors for violent crimes in the home instead of conferring protection against delinquency as commonly thought. In essence, the article seeks to examine whether a policy that reduces residential gun ownership would have a positive effect in decreasing violent crimes in homes.

Research and Data Methodology

The authors identified the incidences of homicide occurring in homes across three metropolitan counties by establishing proxies for the deceased people and selecting a contro...

... middle of paper ...

... not sufficient to current gun control policies.


1. Kellermann, Arthur L., et al. “Gun ownership as a risk factor for homicide in the home.” New England Journal of Medicine 329.15 (1993): 1084-1091. Print.

2. Nelson, LM., et al. “Proxy respondents in epidemiologic research.” Epidemiologic Reviews (1990): 12:71-86.

3. Mimi, C. Yu, et al. “Hepatitis, alcohol consumption, cigarette smoking, and hepatocellular carcinoma in Los Angeles.” Cancer research 43.12 Part 1 (1983): 6077-6079.

4. Kleck, G. “Crime control through the private use of armed force.” Social Problems (1988): 35:1-21

5. Rogot, E and D.D. Reid. “The validity of data from next-of-kin in studies of mortality among migrants.” International Journal of Epidemiology 4.1 (1975): 51-54

6. Federal Bureau of Investigation. Crime in the United States, 1992. Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1993

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Guns Are Responsible For The Prevalence Of Crime Essay

- A whopping 67.8 percent of the total crimes in the world were gun related. In the United States alone, 60 percent of all reported cases of homicides involved guns. This can be one reason that leads many to believe that guns are responsible for the prevalence of criminality across different countries. After all, the United States is the highest in gun ownership, with 88.8 percent per 100,000 people owning guns. Guns are weapons that encompass a high level of danger in the hands of those who have a criminal mind....   [tags: Crime, Firearm, Gun politics]

Powerful Essays
1666 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on Guns and Their Relationships to Crime

- Many of my personal views about crime have been changed by certain readings in criminology. One of the most important topics discussed is guns and their relationship to crime rates. In this paper, I will examine how my early views regarding guns and the gun control debate have been changed through criminology. The gun control debate has been swelling recently in the aftermaths of several mass shootings, notably Tuscon, Newtown, and Aurora. The argument about guns stems into more than just mass shootings, the large realm of the debate regards how guns affect crime rates, and whether more guns leads to more crimes or reduces crimes....   [tags: gun ownership, crime rates]

Powerful Essays
1527 words (4.4 pages)

Guns And Crime : Stop And Frisk Essay

- For decades, gun violence had been an extreme debated problem in the US. Over the past 200 years almost every day, the United States has more gun deaths from accidental or unintentional. Every time a firearms incident led to a tragic death, American politics and public debates over gun laws took place. However, there the voices of the people against guns were too little compared with the numerous supporters of gun. In fact, with 310 million guns in circulation in the market, the United States is one of the countries most used weapons in the world....   [tags: Crime, Police, Firearm, Constable]

Powerful Essays
1129 words (3.2 pages)

Crime Is The Basic Problem, Not Guns Essay

- In salinas it 's no doubt that it has a problem with crime especially ones that are committed with firearms, such as robbery, murder, and gang violence. All of which has caused damage to this community. Salinas needs to stricken up with its guns laws to a degree in that it wouldn 't infringe on people 's rights of ownership; but to keeping them out of the hands of dangerous or inexperienced people. Guns do make self defenses easier on those who seek safety and security, but it also makes potential crime more easy to turn from a bad situation to a extremely dangerous one....   [tags: Firearm, Gun politics in the United States]

Powerful Essays
1231 words (3.5 pages)

Guns in American History Essay

- Guns have played a big part in American history. The first settlers found an abundant amount of edible game when they came to this continent. Guns were very useful in hunting for food in this vas landscape. Familiarity with a rifle was an essential skill which also helped the Colonist of the new world to defeat the British troops during the Revolutionary War that was fought from 1775-1783. After the Revolutionary War was over, guns became even more important to American history in the taming of the west....   [tags: america, USA, history, guns, ]

Powerful Essays
1077 words (3.1 pages)

Why the U.S. Should Legalize Guns Essay

- There are many points that can be argued about whether guns should be legal or not on the topic of gun control. I think guns should be legal due to the lack of self-defense people are left with in dangerous situations and have no way of protecting themselves. Though with many pros on the subject come many cons. There are many crimes in today’s society and with those crimes innocent people are involved, but sometimes guns are used improperly that’s why the U.S. should legalize guns, but with a strict restraint against how they have to be stored and carried....   [tags: gun control, guns, self defense]

Powerful Essays
723 words (2.1 pages)

Do Guns Necessarily Lead to Crime Essay examples

- Crime and guns. The two seem to go hand in hand with one another. But are the two really associated. Do guns necessarily lead to crime. And if so, do laws placing restrictions on firearm ownership and usage stop the crime or protect the citizens. These are the questions many citizens and lawmakers are asking themselves when creating gun control laws. Guns have been a part of American history for as long as people can remember. For most individuals guns are supposed to be very dangerous and unsafe; Though, that is not true....   [tags: second amendment,gun control,gun ownership]

Powerful Essays
1243 words (3.6 pages)

Stop Shootings from Happening on Campus: Unsettle Guns Essay

- You sit towards the back in Art and Design at eight-forty in the morning, trying to stay awake, an early class your advisor convinced you to take. The teacher is charismatically lecturing on Modernism and its implements on society. He suddenly trails off. There is a stunned silence; screams can be heard from down the hall along with gun fire and it is getting louder. Goosebumps rise on your arm. The teacher, with help from the students, closes the door and attempts to barricade the door with a table and desks....   [tags: students, teachers, guns, violence]

Powerful Essays
2024 words (5.8 pages)

Essay on The Legalization Of Guns Ownership

- After the civil war, military soldiers were allowed to go home with their rifles. Crime during that period was not very high because the government was working towards creating job opportunities for the citizens. Besides, there was greater demand for skilled workers at that time because there were very few individuals who were educated. However, with the government development projects, schools were built, hospitals, and many other projects were completed that created job opportunities and improved the standard of living in America....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Crime statistics, Firearm]

Powerful Essays
2171 words (6.2 pages)

Hand Guns and Conceal Ability Essay

- Hand Guns and Conceal Ability The debate of hand guns is highly argued among American citizens. The article "Handgun Bands" from, and the article "Concealed Carry and its Effect on Crime" from, advocate the legal possession of a concealed handgun. They attempt to show that legal handguns actually deter crime and violence. The first article "Handgun Bands" takes an emotional approach followed by statistical information to prove the point that handgun bands, or limitations on the ability to purchase and carry a hand gun, do not effectively counter violence....   [tags: Guns Weapons Violence Essays]

Free Essays
742 words (2.1 pages)