Critique of Research Design

Critique of Research Design

Length: 603 words (1.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Critique of Research Design
The purpose of this critique is to analyze the design of a research study conducted by; Donna Kazemi, Maureen Levine, Jacek Dmochowski, Mary Nies, and Linman Sun called “Effects of Motivational Interviewing Intervention on Blackouts Amoung College Freshman”. It was accepted in January 21st, 2013 and was published in the Journal of Nursing Scholarship.
This study was conducted on 188 volunteer freshmen at a southern university. Kazemi et al. (2013) state the goals of the study were to see if motivational interviewing (MI) worked as an effective intervention to reduce blackouts among freshman, who partook in high-risk drinking or drug use, during a sixth month period. Additionally the study sought to see if there was an association between blackouts among freshman based on race or gender. The research design was a longitudinal study in which students were given motivational interviewing (MI) as an intervention at baseline, two weeks, three months, and. six month time periods while enrolled in school. Assessments of participants drinking and blackouts were taken on baseline day and at six months. Researchers assessed for changes to participants number of blackouts, drinking or drug use (Kazemi et al., 2013).
Longitudinal design was used in this study to monitor the same participants over six months. A threat to the validity of this design can be drop out of participants. This can be attributed to the length of a longitudinal study. However in this study researchers were successful at maintaining all participants. The researchers asked all participants in advance if they could commit to all four sessions and if they could not then they were not used as part of the study. Therefore, all 188 participants selected completed the entire program (Kazemi et al., 2013).
Longitudinal design validity is also dependent upon using set time intervals that make sense with the research being performed. This study does not say explicitly express how intervals for MI instruction were chosen. Furthermore, the study does not explain why or how intervals for pre and post assessments were decided. This is important because past research may have told how long it takes for MI to be successful and at what intervals it needs to be performed in order to yield the best outcomes for participants. This data may have changed the length of the study or the time intervals and potentially changed results.
Furthermore, the time intervals for the design didn’t mention how students’ academic calendar and time off of school may have affected data gathered at certain intervals.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Critique of Research Design." 14 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

M3 Research Design Critique Report Essay

- M3 Research Design Critique Report Correlational research and causal-comparative research are two widely used research designs of a variety of types. An example of correlational research would be if the district benchmark scores would predict the success of the STAAR test. An example of causal-comparative research would be how does Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) affect students’ STAAR results. Causal-comparative research is used to compare groups and observe the differences based on a variable....   [tags: correlational and causal-comparative research]

Research Papers
1285 words (3.7 pages)

Evidence Based Practice : Research Design Essay

- Introduction Evidence-based practice utilizes research design analysis from arrays of studies design, it is imperative for research scholars to understand how to read, and how to comment on the quality of research design utilized. There is three major research designs, namely quantitative, qualitative and mixed method; however; mostly utilized in evidence-based practice are quantitative and qualitative. The quantitative and qualitative research designs are exclusive in the description and generate distinct outcomes....   [tags: Qualitative research, Scientific method]

Research Papers
1134 words (3.2 pages)

Critique of a Contemporary Kindergarten Design From Japan Essay

- INTRODUCTION The benefit and value of architecture and urban design is required to raise quality and profile of the built environment. In the pursuit of design excellence, it is important to exude collaboration, creativity and also accountability in architectural marvels. The basic and core elements of architecture includes quality of experience and quality of space. These, although being the core elements, are often difficult to achieve in the two dimensional realm of procedural documents. On one hand, a poor design may be too apparent; a good design, on the other, may go unnoticed (Alperovich, 2013)....   [tags: Architecture, Urban Design]

Research Papers
1760 words (5 pages)

Research Critique Essay

- Research Critique According to Petrofsky et al. (2010) obesity has become a predisposition to numerous chronic diseases such as diabetes and heart disease. Women tend to have additional factors that promote being overweight such as pregnancy, overall decreased muscle mass, and hormonal factors in comparison to men who have increased muscle mass and lack the hormonal and pregnancy impact that may cause weight gain. In addition to the factors previously mentioned, recent studies have shown that women who are overweight going into a pregnancy tend to remain, or become even more overweight following pregnancy....   [tags: Research Analysis ]

Research Papers
2230 words (6.4 pages)

Research Article Critique: A Critique on Bitchener Essays

- The objectives of this study were: “(1) to investigate whether targeted corrective feedback on ESL student writing results in improved accuracy in new pieces of writing over a 2-month period and (2) to investigate whether there is a differential effect on accuracy for different corrective feedback options.” (p.103) Methods and results This study aimed to answer the following questions: 1. Does accuracy in the use of two functions of the English article system vary over time. 2. Does accuracy in the use of these features vary according to the type of corrective feedback provided....   [tags: Corrective Feedback, Metalinguistic]

Research Papers
1047 words (3 pages)

Critique of a Research Article about Incarceration in the Household by Loper & Nichols (2012)

- Background In a study of children that had a family member or family associate incarcerated prior to their 18th birthday, Loper & Nichols (2012) attempted to address the impact that such incarceration had on such children. It was expected, consistent with previous literature, that household incarceration would have an impact on academic outcomes. The purpose of the study was to evaluate the relationship between household incarceration and two outcomes: failure to graduate high school and extended school absence....   [tags: Journal Article Critique Example]

Research Papers
2304 words (6.6 pages)

A Critique of a Qualitative Research Paper

- This paper will critique the qualitative research paper, “The use of grammatical terminology in the second language classroom: A qualitative study of teachers’ practices and cognitions” by Simon Borg (1999). Borg investigates four English teachers’ cognitions regarding the use of grammatical terminology and their actual practices in the classroom. In order to clarify the relationship between the teachers’ cognitions and their practices, Borg conducted lesson observations and interviews as data collection methods....   [tags: grammatical terminology, teacher's practice]

Research Papers
1865 words (5.3 pages)

Design Critique : An Undergraduate Nursing Textbook Essay

- Design Critique - Typography The textbook or printed instruction I chose to review is an undergraduate nursing textbook. I chose this type of book because I am most familiar with the subject and have read and studied from several different publishers while obtaining my nursing degree. The textbook is Medical-Surgical Nursing: Assessment and Management of Clinical Problem by Lewis, Dirksen, Heitkemper, and Bucher (2014). I found this book on and am able to preview several pages. This textbook focuses on medical-surgical nursing which covers basic topics such as concepts of nursing to more complex issues such as fluid balances within the body, oxygenation and blood perfusion, and b...   [tags: Nursing, Bachelor of Science in Nursing]

Research Papers
935 words (2.7 pages)

Quantitative Research Article Critique Essay

- Quantitative Research Article Critique This paper is an academic critique of an article written by Lautrette, et al. (2007) titled: “A Communication Strategy and Brochure for Relatives of Patients Dying in the ICU” and accurately reflected the content of the article and the research study itself. The abstract explained the article in more detail, while remaining concise. The type of research study, sample size, variables, intervention, measurement method, findings, and conclusion were all mentioned in the abstract....   [tags: Healthcare]

Research Papers
1647 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on Critique of an article from the Journal of Applied Physiology

- Critique of an article from the Journal of Applied Physiology "Effect of different protocols of caffeine intake on metabolism and endurance performance" Introduction In 2002, a group of Australian researchers published a paper entitled the "Effect of different protocols of caffeine intake on metabolism and endurance performance". Caffeine use during sporting events has become much more popular and has widely studied. The purpose of the research was to examine the work increasing (ergogenic) effects of differing regiments of caffeine on metabolism and performance while simulating the typical nutritional preparation an athlete would do for a race....   [tags: Physiology Journal Article Critique]

Research Papers
1108 words (3.2 pages)

For example, if a student traveled home right before their post assessment, at the sixth month interval, the participant may have different drinking habits. This change in routine may have made the students report different data than if the interval for post assessment had been at a different time.
Longitudinal design validity also depends on the professionals that are administering the motivational intervention and assessments to maintain consistency, knowledge, and be involved for the duration of the study. This study’s design included using six different MI instructors that did complete the entire program. The study does a good job of mentioning the professional’s qualifications, training, and background for consistency. However it is important to note that the study doesn’t say whether the same interventionist met with the same group of students each time. This is important because a trusted relationship during intervention therapy may have affected the results differently than if participants had a new interventionist each time.
Longitudinal design was chosen for this study and was well suited for this type of research due to the nature of the intervention. However this study’s design could have been strengthened if the longitudinal design was experiential. This could have been done by having a control group that either received no intervention or a different intervention. Additionally it would have strengthened validity to have an experimental design that allowed for a random selection of participants as this studies participants were self-enrolled volunteers.

Works Cited

Kazemi, D. M., Levine, M. J., Dmochowski, J., Nies, M. A., & Sun, L. (2013). Effects of Motivational Interviewing Intervention on Blackouts Among College Freshmen. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 45(3), 221-229. doi:10.1111/jnu.12022
Return to