Critique of Lars Eighner's Essay "Dumpster Diving"

Critique of Lars Eighner's Essay "Dumpster Diving"

Length: 852 words (2.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Yesterday, I threw out an old jar of peanut butter with only about an inch of it left. It had not expired yet, but we had gotten a new jar, and that one simply tasted better. I wasn't supporting the homeless community, or being wasteful, I was just trying to make room in the cabinet. If I would have kept that inch of peanut butter, it wouldn't have made the world's population of homeless people try to find work, nor want to get off the streets. Lars Eighner is suggesting that when we throw away things, homeless people can find a way to make use out of whatever it is. Therefore, if we don't want there to be bums on the street, it is inferred that we shouldn't throw anything extra out if we want to change that. To me, that is simply ridiculous. We all know, that if someone is desperate enough, they can make use out of almost anything, and some of those things "non-homeless folk" can't use anymore. We're not feeding or clothing the homeless intentionally, we can't help if people dig through our trash. So, not throwing away anything "extra" is not going to turn the vagabonds of the world into a fine, upstanding, or hard-working citizen of America.
Obviously, I completely disagree with Eighner's purpose in writing "Dumpster Diving". I think the whole thing is preposterous. The way he makes a general assumption about how everybody's is wasteful is pure ignorance. It seem as if he is saying that the reason why people are homeless is because we throwing out things. Eighner is trying to tell us that people will remain homeless until we start saving more and wasting less, but that's not how it works. Most people don't choose to be homeless. Some even start out having their own companies, or just simply having jobs and comfortable live...


... middle of paper ...


... out and got a job. He stopped relying on the trash of people, and simply started working. People weren't throwing out more or less, he just simply applied himself. Who cares what we throw out, it's not going to make a difference.
All-in-all, Eighner fails at his attempt to get us to stop "wasting" what we can't use. It is easy to see that it's not our faults if people are homeless, because we are not contributing to that. Removing clutter and getting rid of junk does not keep people on the streets! Some people are just down-and-out, and there's nothing we can do to help or hurt that. Eighner needs to look at the man in the mirror and realize that if he didn't get a job because people cut off their garbage, then that's not the case. Even though Eighner disagrees with me, today, tomorrow, and the day after that, I will always throw away that inch of peanut butter.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about A Critique Of On Dumpster Diving

- A Critique of On Dumpster Diving According to Mayberry (2009) Lars Eighner, a graduate of the University of Texas, became homeless in 1988 and again in 1995 (p. 351). Some of the accounts from Travels with Lisbeth (1993), a book by Lars Eighner, depicted what he went through and what he found during his homeless state. A homeless person must eat and sleep but may not know where or when this might happen next. The human will to survive enabled Eighner to eat food from a dumpster, reach out to other for handouts, and sleep in places other than a bed with covers....   [tags: Homelessness, Poverty, Homeless shelter]

Better Essays
743 words (2.1 pages)

Exposing Our Wasteful Nature in Lars Eighner's On Dumpster Diving Essay example

- ... By having an attitude that dumpster diving is not uncommon or is unethical makes the reader somewhat view it differently. It persuades the reader into thinking that maybe dumpster diving isn’t as bad as people make it out to be. Also by writing the essay in an informal yet very educated way makes the reader respect his work and gives him great credibility. His first main point in his essay is “What is safe to eat?” At first it is very hard for him to determine what is edible and what was thrown away for a real reason....   [tags: homeless, food, scavengers]

Free Essays
555 words (1.6 pages)

On Dumpster Diving by Las Eighner Essay

- Homelessness is increasing every year and effecting Americans of different age, ethnicity and religion. In Lars Eighner “On Dumpster Diving” he explains what he went through while being homeless. He describes how and what foods someone should be looking for and to always be conscious of what one is eating because there is always a reason why something has been thrown out. He continues to go into detail about other items that can be found in the dumpster like sheets to sleep on and pieces of paper to write on....   [tags: homelessness, food, garbage]

Better Essays
1119 words (3.2 pages)

Stereotypes about Homelessness in America in Dumpster Diving by Lars Eighner

- Stereotypes about Homelessness in America in Dumpster Diving by Lars Eighner Lars Eighner's short essay, "Dumpster Diving," reveals the stereotypes about homelessness in America. In order to confirm these known stereotypes about American culture, Eighner includes autobiographical accounts of the economically inferior class, as well as revealing his elitist rules that governs the life of a homeless person. According to Eighner, homeless people fall into the following categories, 'can scroungers', 'Dumpster divers', and 'scavengers.' (Eighner, 1993)....   [tags: Homeless Poverty Papers]

Better Essays
666 words (1.9 pages)

Analysis Of The Article ' On Dumpster Diving ' Essay

- Can you ever imagine yourself being homeless or penniless and having to dumpster dive. In the essay, “On Dumpster Diving”by Lars Eighner, he explains his experience in dumpster diving and what he has gone through, from getting sick to being successful. If I were Lars Eighner the location that I would have chosen to dumpster dive is Pleasanton because of the high percentage of wealthy people, low percentage of homeless people, and a strong chance of finding food. To begin, there is a high percentage of wealthy people who live in Pleasanton, which is why it is the perfect place to dumpster dive....   [tags: Poverty, Homelessness, Dumpster diving, Dumpster]

Better Essays
1235 words (3.5 pages)

Perception as a Defining Factor in Our Lives Essay

- Perception is a defining factor in all of our lives. Perception affects the way every action, choice, and decision we make is perceived. Though societal influences perception can be shaped based upon bias. The world is filled with it religious, political, sexual, and gender bias just to name a few. It is because of these biases that peoples perception is narrowed and what is deemed as “civilized” or the “right” thing to do may not always be one hundred percent true. In the book Walden by Henry David Thoreau we see a man who has looked past social norms and blazed his own path towards individual enlightenment....   [tags: Thoreau's Walden, Eighner's On Dumpster Diving]

Better Essays
780 words (2.2 pages)

Recreational vs. Technical Diving Essay

- After two years of recreational diving I have learned some of the ins and outs of the dive community. Diving has become such an enjoyable experience for me that I have decided to make a career change and work towards my dream of being a commercial diver. Before making such a life altering decision, it is important to understand the differences between the two in order to further understand the depth of my decision. In this essay, I will compare portions of recreational diving to its equivalent in technical diving....   [tags: Diving]

Better Essays
1425 words (4.1 pages)

Scuba Diving Snorkeling Diving Scuba Snorkeling Essay

- Scuba Diving Scuba diving is a really interesting and exciting activity to do if someone loves the ocean as much as I do. My boyfriend Justus and I traveled to the beautiful Florida Keys for a week and a half last summer. When we got to the keys we had already planned on going scuba diving. We bought our tickets before we even left the state of Indiana. We were both super excited to experience something we had never done before. The morning of our scuba diving trip we had to go meet our scuba diving instructor for him to go over rules....   [tags: Scuba diving, Underwater diving, Debut albums]

Better Essays
1193 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on Scuba Diving For The First Time

- I remember when I went scuba diving for the first time. It was the summer of 2002. My Dad, his two friends Mark and Bob, and I went on a scuba diving trip to San Carlos, Mexico with a group of scuba divers from June 21st-29th. It was June 22nd, a beautiful day. The temperature was at about 90 degrees and it was very sunny. I was on big nice scuba diving boat along with the other eight divers on the trip and captain and co-captain. The boat was headed to an island about two hours away called "Seal Island"; it was called that because of all the sea lions that inhabit it....   [tags: Scuba diving, Underwater diving, Scuba set]

Better Essays
824 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on The Art of Diving in Britain

- 33 feet up, looking down at the water, trying to determine if this trick will make or break a diver from the rest of his or her career is a heart pounding experience. He jumps, spins, flips, and then hurdles 62 miles per hour toward the unforgiving water head first. The loud splash the diver makes as he enters the water perfect. He disappears into the dark obis of the water for what feels like forever, as he mentally prepares himself for either applause or boos. He finally has no choice but to come up....   [tags: Diving, British Athletes, Sports]

Better Essays
1008 words (2.9 pages)