Essay on Critique of an article from the Journal of Applied Physiology

Essay on Critique of an article from the Journal of Applied Physiology

Length: 1108 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Critique of an article from the Journal of Applied Physiology

"Effect of different protocols of caffeine intake on metabolism and endurance performance"



Introduction
In 2002, a group of Australian researchers published a paper entitled the "Effect of different protocols of caffeine intake on metabolism and endurance performance". Caffeine use during sporting events has become much more popular and has widely studied. The purpose of the research was to examine the work increasing (ergogenic) effects of differing regiments of caffeine on metabolism and performance while simulating the typical nutritional preparation an athlete would do for a race. The study also sought to examine the effect of timing of caffeine intake, comparing results when caffeine was given before an event (precaf) to results from caffeine given during an event (durcaf). In addition, the researchers wanted to understand the practice of endurance athletes drinking defizzed Coca-Cola towards the end of a race. It was widely observed that many triathletes and marathoners feel they derive a boost from consuming Coca-Cola in the final stages of an event as a replacement to sports drinks.

Participants and Overall Research Design
Two similar, but separate studies were conducted. The first study (A) used 12 highly trained athletes, either triathletes or cyclists. The second study (B) used a smaller sample of 8 athletes with similar backgrounds. While training histories were similar, caffeine intake histories varied from occasional to regular intake of up to ~150 mg/day (2mg/Kg). Subjects first performed a maximal incremental power test to determine their VO2 peak, a measurement of the body's ability to taken in O2 and turn it into work. A work rate of ...


... middle of paper ...


...e that negated some or all of the impact of the caffeine. 5) Test method variation (for blood or urinary tests) was not a factor. No data was given indicating the reproducibility of the test methods used.
A proposal to improve the design is examining the results versus pre-trial caffeine use. Would individuals who habitually use caffeine have the same performance enhancement as those who occasionally
use it or would the effect be lower? Another suggestion is to include a statement discussing test method variation and the impact (or lack of impact) on the test results. Finally, a larger sample size can help determine if borderline data is significant. While cost is almost always a consideration in research, the text discusses changes in muscle metabolism as not detectable. Additional data from more test subjects could produce results with statistical significance.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Effect Of Exercise On Exercise Physiology Essay

- My exposure to exercise physiology is far from conventional. Rather than engaging it as an academic hobbyist, I was drawn to it out of necessity and utility in the U.S. Army. Rather than following anachronistic military physical training, I took it upon myself to learn more about exercise science. What started as tool for my job soon turned into my passion. I understood how exercise physiology was more than a foray into the underpinnings of strength and conditioning, but something that had a meaningful purpose in a very tangible way....   [tags: Physical exercise, Obesity, Exercise physiology]

Strong Essays
788 words (2.3 pages)

Journal of Teacher Education Critique Essay

- Introduction The Journal of Teacher Education has been in existence since March of 1950. According to the journals website (http://jte.sagepub.com/) it has an impact factor of 1.891 and is ranked 18 out of 184 in Education & Educational Research. The purpose of this paper is to critique issue 64 volume 3 of 2011. This paper is organized so that description of information is presented about the authors, institutions and topics of each paper, then a synthesis of the teacher education articles, and finally implications for the field of teacher education. Description This journal issue included seven total articles; four were research articles, two were literature reviews and one was an edito...   [tags: Education, teaching]

Strong Essays
1353 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Personal Journal: Pregancy, Childbirth, and Childhood

- When thinking about having a baby, I have to consider the financial, physical, and emotional/cognitive effects it will have on me, my partner, and my family. • I am an elementary school teacher and my husband is a golf pro manager for Troon Golf Course Management Company. We presently live in the United States. Together, we make enough money to live a little more than comfortably. However, we have been saving for a new addition to our family for 2 years now. Taking into consideration that we have many friends and an extended family, it is safe to assume that we will have a fair boost in baby supplies from our shower....   [tags: Journal]

Strong Essays
2139 words (6.1 pages)

Essay on Critique of Three Journal Articles on Substance- Abuse Prevention

- New Directions For Substance- Abuse Prevention In the article, New Directions For Substance- Abuse Prevention (2011), Anderson (2011) stated that his main purpose was to describe the problem of substance abuse among college students, discuss strategies that have already been in effect, discuss ways in which college campuses can be more effective in prevention and finally, discuss what things campus leaders should know, say and do in order to help with substance abuse prevention. The article starts of discussing the nature and significance of the substance abuse problem among college students....   [tags: article critique]

Strong Essays
3055 words (8.7 pages)

Literacy Journal And Events : Literacy Essay

- Literacy Journal and Events Literacy events occur quite often throughout my day. My mornings are usually repetitive with me waking up to an alarm sound and hearing the microwave ding due to my suitemate cooking breakfast. On my way out the door I always take a look at the kitchen trashcan because I hate a dirty kitchen. When closing the door, I insert my key in the door to lock it because I am not use to a door not automatically locking. Since I am a full time student, throughout the day I am involved in literacy events that involve anything that is school related....   [tags: Reading, Literacy, Applied linguistics, Writing]

Strong Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)

Critique of Research Design Essay

- Critique of Research Design The purpose of this critique is to analyze the design of a research study conducted by; Donna Kazemi, Maureen Levine, Jacek Dmochowski, Mary Nies, and Linman Sun called “Effects of Motivational Interviewing Intervention on Blackouts Amoung College Freshman”. It was accepted in January 21st, 2013 and was published in the Journal of Nursing Scholarship. This study was conducted on 188 volunteer freshmen at a southern university. Kazemi et al. (2013) state the goals of the study were to see if motivational interviewing (MI) worked as an effective intervention to reduce blackouts among freshman, who partook in high-risk drinking or drug use, during a sixth month per...   [tags: critique of research design]

Free Essays
603 words (1.7 pages)

Journal Article Critique Essay

- Research Article 1 Roberts, T. (2003). Effects of Alphabet-Letter Instruction on Young Children’s Word Recognition [Electronic Version]. Journal of Educational Psychology, 95 (1), 41-51. Title The title of the article gave a fair representation of the topic as it was clear and concise in the wording. The title encompassed the idea that alphabet letter instruction on young children’s word recognition would be explored through experiments and analysis. Reading on through the article it was evident that the effects of alphabet letter instruction on you children’s word recognition were addressed....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
1911 words (5.5 pages)

Critique of Two Journal Articles on Motivation Essay

- Critique of Two Journal Articles on Motivation Expectancy theory is one of the most widely used motivation theory. It is first proposed by Victor Vroom Yale School of Management in 1964. This theory is well supported by many evidence, and believe that the degree how people would act in a certain way depends on the strength of an expectation that the act will be followed by a given outcome, and on the attractiveness of that outcome to the individual.(Robbins et al. 2008) Two research-based articles which used expectancy theory to examine the factors impact target object in different circumstances are compared in this critique article....   [tags: Motivation Theory Article Analysis Compare]

Strong Essays
1411 words (4 pages)

The Anatomy and Physiology of Lipids Essay

- The Anatomy and Physiology of Lipids Abstract When you get up each morning and look outside your window looking out at the beautiful plants and adorable little animals, have you ever wondered what makes all living things. Lipids are what help create all the living things we see everyday. Lipids are found in all membranes, mainly plasma membranes, meaning animals and plants contain lipids. In this paper I will display and explain the formation of micelles and bi-layers from lipid amphiphilicity....   [tags: Anatomy Physiology Lipid]

Strong Essays
1275 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Journal of Love

- Journal of Love *If you've been hurt in the past by people dont assume that you will always be hurt, open your heart to someone who you can trust and you will find true love, dont deny yourself of that feeling* *You don't come across that many people that give you butterflies, you just dont* "If two past lovers remain friends, they are either still in love, or never were." "You always overlook the little things in a relationship. It's the times when you wake at 4am and smell his cologne when you know you have made a mistake." "Isn't it funny how you can think you're completely over someone, but if you drive past his house, stumble upon a meaningful song you both shared, or even catch...   [tags: Journal Entries Love Relationships Essays]

Strong Essays
6299 words (18 pages)