The Criticisms of John Stuart Mill and Its Applications in Today's Society

The Criticisms of John Stuart Mill and Its Applications in Today's Society

Length: 2145 words (6.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

“Absolute liberty is the absence of restraint; responsibility is restraint; therefore, the ideally free individual is responsible to himself” - Henry Brooks Adams. There has been great debate, past and present with regards to what constitutes as an individuals liberty. It has been subject to constant ridicule and examination due to violations of civil rights. Freedom, liberty, and independence are all important human rights represented within John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty.
In his essay, Mill explores the two dimensions to liberty; individual and social. Carefully he analyzes the variance between the individual and social sphere through freedom of expression, more specifically, freedom of speech. Throughout the novel, he expresses that freedom of expression is one of the greatest social utilities, not only a valuable asset to the individual but also to society. Thus, this essay will prove that freedom of expression is a privilege, when violated, has serious repercussions on the offended. To healthily exercise liberty, one must responsibly censor degrading comments and actions that could infringe upon the rights of another individual.
Mill advocates for free speech on several grounds, first and foremost on the basis of the protection of an individuals social liberty. He states that the entirety of the essay is not about the “liberty of the will” but more the “civil or social liberty of an individual” (Mill,1) This characterizes that Mill cares more about the individual and their needs than what the majority is in favor of. His belief that the weaker should have constant protection against the stronger affirms that government should preferentially guard and support those being attacked by a greater force. This will be furthe...


... middle of paper ...


...y are stifling the students an opportunity to defend themselves. Essentially, their argument and what they said could have been correct, and although what Steyn said was highly unjust it was clearly a depiction of his lack of responsibility.
In conclusion, it can be proven that social freedom of expression is a privilege constantly taken for granted, and is unjustly violating minorities with whom suffer the consequences. Evidently, through the Mark Steyn case, responsibility is restraint, a characteristic, Steyn clearly doesn't posses, and the repercussions severely effected the Muslim students. Mill outlines freedom as a human right and demonstrates without this freedom society does not have the chance to flourish and evolve into a great nation. As stated by Henry Adam, a free individual is responsible for himself, a trait that society needs to grasp more of.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Comparison of the Economic Philosophies of Adam Smith, John Stuart Mill, and Karl Marx

- As far back as man has been on earth, he has been driven towards building a community among his peers. Whether that is a community of hunters and gatherers who share whatever the day has brought to them within their tribe, or a larger community which within its structure lie the inner dwellings of division of labor and societal classes. Adam Smith (18th Century), John Stuart Mill (19th Century), and Karl Marx (19th Century) are of the same cloth, but in modern terms their community is referenced as a government, and they each have their own distinct opinions on the 'drive' instilled within human nature that shape their personal economic theories....   [tags: Adam Smith, John Stuart Mill, Karl Marx]

Powerful Essays
1775 words (5.1 pages)

John Stuart Mill And Immanuel Kant Essay

- There has been an ongoing debate regarding torture and ethical reasoning to determine when or if its ever ok. Modern scholars such as Alan Dershowitz, Sam Harris, and Charles & Gregory Fried, have expressed different ideas on ethical torture. Ideas of ethical reasoning were established by John Stuart Mill and Immanuel Kant. Even though they did not specifically use torture as an example of ethical reasoning for decision making their rational can still be applied to this topic. Immanuel Kant believed our moral decisions are based on categorical imperative....   [tags: Ethics, Immanuel Kant, Morality]

Powerful Essays
1202 words (3.4 pages)

Edmund Burke vs John Stuart Mill Essay

- The ideology of Edmund Burke and John Stuart Mill were some very widely known and very well accredited philosophers that influenced a large majority of the people and how they thought about certain things. Edmund Burke has been seen as the father of conservatism, (Harris, 2010) which is the belief in the value of established and traditional practices in politics and society. (Merriam-Webster, 2013) Second, were his thoughts and concerns about the religious aspects of society, and how if we have too many it could lead to problems....   [tags: classic, phylosophy]

Powerful Essays
1379 words (3.9 pages)

John Stuart Mill And Plato 's Categorical Imperative Essay

- ... She knew her sister would have done whatever she’d asked and take the blame. This act not only earned her her father’s trust, it also weakened his relationship with her sister. Ridjie’s action were solely for her personal benefit. The possibility of how it could affect Sammy were the least of her concern. Additionally, Kant would also view Sammy’s action immoral. Although she lied to save them from a horrible punishment, she lied nonetheless. John Stuart Mill may not have shared Kant’s views....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Immanuel Kant, Philosophy]

Powerful Essays
759 words (2.2 pages)

John Stuart Mill Essay

- Who is John Stuart Mill. John Stuart Mill was born on May 20, 1806, in London, England. He was mostly known for his radical views. For example, he preached sexual equality, divorce, universal suffrage, free speech, and proportional representation. He had many works of writings such as Principles of Political Economy, On Liberty, The Subjections of Women, and the Three Essays of Religion: Nature, the Utility of Religion, and Theism. John Mill was the eldest son of James Mill who was a philosopher, economist and a senior official in the East India Company....   [tags: essays research papers]

Powerful Essays
1828 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on On The Subjection Of Women by John Stuart Mill

- Struggle For Equality Throughout history women have been subjected to cruel and unfair treatment in an unequal society designed to oppress the physically inferior woman. Men's superior strength has too often debacled a woman's ability to strive for success and reach one's full potential. A man's strength is an insufficient reason to suppress the powerful voice, and intellect of women. Throughout their struggle for equality, being oppressed, women have shown that they have the drive to persevere and come out on top in an unjust society....   [tags: Sociology Gender]

Powerful Essays
513 words (1.5 pages)

Filling the Void: Karl Marx, John Stuart Mill and Others on Identity Essay

- ... The continuation of the chapter, which states that classes are created by capitalism, it is stated that the bourgeois exploits the proletarians with lower wages because of the idea of private property. The chapter goes on to say that revolutions happen and society will be restructured, but with capitalism in the country history is doomed to repeat itself. Only with communism, the essay states, can there be class equality among Europe. The next three chapters, "Proletarians and Communists", "Socialist and Communist Literature", and "Position of the Communists in Relation to the Various Opposition Parties", just speak more specifically about the political party of communism and what it had...   [tags: philosophical beliefs and concepts]

Powerful Essays
1147 words (3.3 pages)

The Philosophies of John Stuart Mill as a Guide for the World Essay

- The Philosophies of John Stuart Mill as a Guide for the World Dr. Pest's comments: This student's term paper is a model of how to apply the philosophical concepts of a previous century to our present society. She showed how the ideas of John Stuart Mill can be used by intelligent people to construct a society with more opportunities for women and to insure respect for intellectual freedom. As the world moves into the twenty-first century, it faces many problems. War, disease, over-population, and starvation are examples of problems that have yet to be solved....   [tags: Philosophy Religion Essays]

Powerful Essays
4251 words (12.1 pages)

Essay about Jeremy Bentham 's Philosophy Of Law And The Principle Of Utilitarianism

- ... Much of what appeared in his lifetime and for decades thereafter involved more or less active intervention of editors” (Ferguson 534). Bentham was “a hedonistic utilitarian that argued when attempting to evaluate the pleasure or pain produced by an action, there are various aspects of the pleasure and pain that we should consider” (DeGeorge 46). Using the utilitarian approach, one weighs the good and bad consequences when considering an action. If the good outweighs the bad, it is generally a good decision....   [tags: Utilitarianism, Ethics, John Stuart Mill]

Powerful Essays
718 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Utilitarianism : An Ethical Theory

- ... I would have normally only considered my own personal happiness in the matter, asking myself, “Would becoming a doctor make me happy?” Now I know better, to consider the happiness of those around me when making this decision. Would becoming a doctor make my parents, friends, and future spouse happy. I must consider the consequences of each possible decision, focusing specifically on their future implications and how they would affect the happiness of the others involved in the situation. Next, Mill establishes the three types of higher pleasures: (1) acts involving intellectual complexity, (2) acts engaging the aesthetic imagination, and (3) acts engaging the moral sentiments....   [tags: Utilitarianism, Ethics, John Stuart Mill]

Powerful Essays
1388 words (4 pages)