Critical Response of Duff and Pugh Essay

Critical Response of Duff and Pugh Essay

Length: 1350 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Critical Response

Carol Ann-Duffy & Sheenagh Pugh are both strongly opinionated politically – many of their poems are charged with a scornful, impassioned energy directed toward the Thatcherite days, resenting years of economic deprivation & ruin of many young lives in their generation – this sets the basis for a general distaste for politicians, illustrated in Duffy’s parody of parliament ‘Weasel Words’, mocking the meaningless socio-jargon that MPs use to wriggle and slither their way out of answering straight questions. The same jargon is used to greater, more realistic effect in Pugh’s ‘Official Briefing’ (a biblical parody of Jesus sacking the temple & casting out the money changers [Synoptic Gospels: Mark 11:15-19] & something of an exposé of the arrogant, above-the-law attitude synonymous with positions & abuse of positions of relative power in this country – such as Harriet Harman scraping another car in Marylebone, drove on, and upon being questioned by a member of the public to report her, was heard to remark “You know where I am, and where to find me” and drove away, implying she is far & beyond the law.) – Their approach to the theme & contextual emphasis differs. Pugh assumes a calmer, concluded air, laying out the rooted conservative - authoritarian attitude of these ministers – ‘clear contempt for law & order...Arrogant attempt to impose the whims of minorities upon...interference with private enterprise’. The parody is obvious, with the mention of the whip & the damaged property in question being mainly ‘currency & pigeons’, & dubbing him (Christ) a ‘disaffected itinerant’. This emphasises the ministers’ reckoning that they are aloof,. Duffy is more metaphorical and damning of the matter at hand, the very title ...

... middle of paper ...

...motional poetry, much of which is biased and embittered. Much of her poetry is insensitive – but not ineffective. ‘Shooting Stars’ seems to be set in a concentration camp (something I doubt Duffy has any experience of), and her use of indefinite, fragmented verse & scarce rhyme to convey the perpetual threat & faceless fear in the camp is powerful. The lasting anonymity of the narrator’s voice gives the verse poignancy as well as the tragic futile monologue, combined with the harrowing use of a metaphorical sunset – she is to die – this will be the last sunset, the onset of eternal darkness – There is no doubting the weight this poem carries. Duffy does not go as far as to be abstract or even observant here but she simply calms down a little, which lets a lyrical quality surface within her verse, which is not apparent in her other brash, misandry-fuelled works.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Language and Linguistic Features in Poems by Sheenagh Pugh and Carol Ann Duffy

- Sheenagh Pugh and Carol Ann Duffy are two poets that have written many poems on the topic of language using linguistic features to enhance meaning and depth. In this essay, I am going to discuss the similarities and differences in how they portray this theme on the reader and the effects it creates. I am going to create an in depth analysis of three poems with this theme, two written by Carol Ann Duffy and the other by Sheenagh Pugh. The first poem I am going to discuss is 'Poet for Our Times' written by Duffy; which expresses her views about prejudice and how society has changed along with 'the poems of the decade'....   [tags: immigrants, metaphors, sexy]

Strong Essays
786 words (2.2 pages)

A Critical Response to Hawthorne’s Puritans Essay

- Nathaniel Hawthorne (1804-1864) is critically acclaimed for the portrayal of New England Puritans in his fiction. The grim picture of the rigid and forbidding Puritan community in his works reflects the widespread attitude towards Puritans, yet Professor Deborah L. Madsen, in her paper, “Hawthorne’s Puritans: From Fact to Fiction” claims that this monolithic portrayal of Puritanism results in a ‘powerful misrepresentation of the actual puritans [and] of the dynamics of Puritan theology’ (Madsen 1999, p 510) ....   [tags: Literacy Analysis ]

Strong Essays
1593 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on Criitical Response to Baptized in Blood

- Baptized in Blood: An Interpretation and Critical Response If one were to take a quick glance at the cover, with its bold Rebel cross and equally bold title, one might mistakenly think Baptized in Blood: The Religion of the Lost Cause to be the propaganda of a backwoods racist asserting that “The South will rise again.” On the contrary, Charles Reagan Wilson’s Baptized in Blood is not a book by an author seeking to glorify the mythical past of a falsely idealized Southern People. Rather, it is an account which seeks to explain historically why ideas such as these came to be in the first place....   [tags: Literature Religion South Charles Reagan Wilson]

Strong Essays
3723 words (10.6 pages)

Essay on Sunset Song: A Critical Explication

- 'Sunset Song' Critical Essay Choose a novel or short story in which a conflict between two of the main characters is central to the story. Explain how the conflict arises and go on to discuss in detail how the writer uses it to explore an important theme. 'Sunset Song' by Lewis Grassic Gibbon is set in a place called Kinraddie, in Kincardineshire, in the first part of the twentieth century, leading up to the first world war. The main character in the novel is a young woman named Chris Guthrie....   [tags: Critical Essay ]

Strong Essays
614 words (1.8 pages)

Assessment of Critical Thinking Essay

- Assessment of learning can be a meaningful tool for teachers and students during a course to provide feedback to the student about the type and quality of work that is being completed in the course and for the instructor to find areas where the student is having difficulties and so additional materials can be provided or the course modified. The aim of this paper is to define assessment and critical thinking skills, and then review a State University course and suggest different assessments that could be used to demonstrate learning....   [tags: Critical Thinking Essays]

Strong Essays
969 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Critical Response: Jack London

- Critical Response: Jack London Jack London, a well known American author, has written a fair share of truly classic works.  The Call of the Wild and White Fang are staples of middle and high school reading requirements.  His other novels, such as The People of the Abyss and Sea Wolf are not as well known, but are still regarded as brilliant pieces of literature by many scholars.  Lesser known are his many volumes of short stories; "To Build a Fire" being the most popular.  I cannot say that I have read even a small percentage of London's works, but from what I have read, I noticed some recurring similarities.              During the semester in class, we have learn...   [tags: Biography Biographies Essays]

Free Essays
3494 words (10 pages)

Applying Critical Thinking Essay

- Introduction On August 12, 2010, the Governor of Illinois notified the Federal State Employee Union (FSEU) Local 343, of the state’s intent to outsource and privatize the Department of Transportation (DoT) information systems management function (B. Glenn, personal communication, August 20, 2010). In response, Mr. Padilla, the president of the FSEU Local No. 343, requests the FSEU Director of Human Resources, Ms. Glenn to evaluate the notification. The memorandum dated August 20, 2010, includes Ms....   [tags: Critical Thinking Essays]

Strong Essays
2629 words (7.5 pages)

A Critical Response to Lady Chatterley's Lover Essay

- A Critical Response to Lady Chatterley's Lover         Lady Chatterley's Lover by D. H. Lawrence examines the human condition in the modern era.  Through the experiences of the novel's characters, Lady Chatterley's Lover advances techniques for coping with the modern world:  retreating from society and engaging in phallic sex.  However, the application of these techniques is problematic as phallic sex necessitates the abandonment of social convention, while retreating from society conflicts with phallic sex....   [tags: chatterley]

Strong Essays
1884 words (5.4 pages)

Reader Response Criticism Essay

- Fish’s Reader Response Criticism is composed of two interdependent ideas: first, that the meaning of texts is shaped by the reading experience itself, and second, that these meanings cannot be judged to be correct or incorrect, but merely belonging to one “interpretive community” or another. The first idea may be identified as the executive aspect of Reader Response Criticism because it analyzes the act of reading, while the second idea is the epistemological aspect of the theory because it circumscribes the knowledge we can acquire about a text to the merely relative....   [tags: Literary Response]

Strong Essays
967 words (2.8 pages)

Critical Thinking Essay

- We often refer to critical thinking as someone who can think very clearly, with reason and complex ideas. This is somewhat true. Yes that does help to begin and mend a critical thinker but critical thinking also includes a combination of skills. Those main characteristics are self awareness, honesty, open-mindedness discipline, and judgment. Using these characteristics daily and with practice develops an amazing critical thinker. That person can live life solving hard problems, creating new ways of solving them, and using new ideas and techniques when needed....   [tags: Critical Thinking Essays]

Free Essays
952 words (2.7 pages)