Critical Examination of Brooks' The Formalist Critics Essay

Critical Examination of Brooks' The Formalist Critics Essay

Length: 1028 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Brooks starts his essay by listing “articles of faith I could subscribe to” (Brooks 19) and pointing out statements about literary criticism that might go with a formalist criticism. Yet, he questions that list its end, and seems to complain that his that his writings have been largely misunderstood. What his statements have to do with faith in connection with literature is up to the reader, since in one of his articles he specifically mentions, “literature is not a surrogate for religion” (Brooks 19). He seems to contradict himself on purpose and keep his central thesis hard to reach. In evaluating some of his “faith articles”, the reader can have a critical examination of his critique of his formalist criticism.
His first statement is that “Literary criticism is a description and evaluation of its object” (Brooks 19). The literary critic reports on the work that he is criticizing and picks out the meaning that he deems important, which might be different from what the next critic would pick out. Describing the work it is then already a subjective exercise, such as in Doctor Faustus, in the A-version of the text, some people might think Faustus being led away by devils means that they lead him into eternal hell, whereas others might think that he could go into purgatory and eventually repent. The author often wants an ambiguous reading of his texts, and those are often the most challenging and enjoyable works. When Brooks writes that the next step is “evaluation of its object”, the subjective nature of literary criticism becomes apparent. Who criticizes seems to be the first step in a long subjective path, and therefore one evaluation might differ from another evaluation completely. Experience in literary works seems to make thos...


... middle of paper ...


...ve artist is better off for being in touch with a vigorous criticism” (Brooks 22). While obviously, the critic would encounter some problems having a healthy, critical relationship with Shakespeare, for example, this might be beneficial for a currently still living artist, but would mean that the critic would have to review the work during its creation and have an direct impact on the work.
Cleanth Brooks writes in his essay “The Formalist Critics” from 1951 continuously about “intensely at work upon the recalcitrant stuff of life” (Brooks, 23). Cleanth Brooks argues that we lose the intrinsically obvious points of works of literature if we view the work through the different lenses of literary theory, however we are always viewing the literary work through a subjective lens, since the author and the critic cannot subjectively separate themselves from themselves.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Formalist Critics, by Cleanth Brooks Essay

- Cleanth Brooks writes in his essay “The Formalist Critics” from 1951 about criticism that formalist critics encounter and tries to show these arguments from his point of view and even indicates common ground with other literary critics. Cleanth Brooks argues that we lose the intrinsically obvious points of works of literature if we view the work through the different lenses of literary theory, however we are always viewing the literary work through a subjective lens, since the author and the critic cannot subjectively separate themselves from themselves and in making these points he contradicts himself....   [tags: the formalist critics, cleanth brooks]

Strong Essays
1507 words (4.3 pages)

How Critical Hermeneutics and Descriptive Sociology Disavow Traditional Humanist Categories

- An examination of Humanist Hermeneutics in Literary Studies- the practice of close reading- but from a distance presents a room for relation between Literary Studies and other disciplines. Such practices lead to possibilities for renewed interdisciplinary exchange. Viewed within the framework of present day social constructionist theory or simply post- theory, the current essay Close but not Deep: Literary Ethics and the Descriptive Turn show how both Critical Hermeneutics and Descriptive Sociology disavow Traditional Humanist categories....   [tags: Humanist Hermeneutics in Literary Studies]

Strong Essays
2546 words (7.3 pages)

An Examination of Rubyfruit Jungle and Her Critics Essay

- An Examination of Rubyfruit Jungle and Her Critics            Rita Mae Brown's first novel, Rubyfruit Jungle made waves when it was first released in 1973. Its influence has not gone away over the years and is in its seventh printing. While mainstream critics failed to acknowledge Rubyfruit Jungle in their papers, magazines and discussions on contemporary literature, there are plenty of non-mainstream voices to fill the void. While these lesser-known sources are not always credible, and certainly not always accurate they have created a word-of-mouth reputation of the novel and have facilitated its continuous success....   [tags: Rubyfruit]

Strong Essays
1943 words (5.6 pages)

The Culture of and Prejudice Against African Americans as Depicted in Gwendolyn Brooks' Poetry and Stories

- African American’s have faced a great deal of harsh and cruel treatment throughout our society. From being stripped from their homeland of Africa and being brought to America as slaves, African Americans have seen and been through it all. Author and renowned poet Gwendolyn Elizabeth Brooks discuses and describes many of the cruel and unfair treatment that African Americans have faced throughout our civilization. Brooks’ not only speaks on the racial prejudice of African Americans, but she also discusses the heartaches, the life, and the growth of African Americans as a people....   [tags: Poems, Gwendolyn Brooks, racism]

Strong Essays
1921 words (5.5 pages)

An Examination of the Music of Garth Brooks Essay

- ... However, it reveals that they found her diary in which she wrote about a fight that she had had with him before he left for Cheyenne. After hearing the news that her husband had been killed, it drove the woman crazy because she had told him she did not care if he never made it back home to California. The final verse of the song gives a very dreary feeling that the woman’s soul was never able to be put to rest because of the pain, love, and regret that she went through after her husband had passed....   [tags: country music greats]

Strong Essays
2026 words (5.8 pages)

Gwendolyn Brooks' We Real Cool Essay

- Gwendolyn Brooks' "We Real Cool" The poem 'We Real Cool' by Gwendolyn Brooks is a stream of the thoughts of poor inner city African-Americans who have adopted a hoodlum lifestyle. Though many can have different interpretations of this poem, it is fair to look at the life and career or the works and influences of Gwendolyn Brooks. The life and art of the black American poet, Gwendolyn Brooks, began on June 7, 1917 when she was born in Topeka, Kansas. She was the first child of Keziah Corine Wims and David Anderson Brooks....   [tags: Gwendolyn Brooks Real Cool Poem Poet Essays]

Strong Essays
1359 words (3.9 pages)

A Critical Examination Of The Professional Development Essay

- A Critical Examination of the Professional Development Literature Related to Business Introduction Knapp (2003, p.112) treats professional development in its broadest sense as ‘the full range of activities, formal and informal, that engage teachers or administrators in new learning about their professional practice’. The University of Management and Technology notes the use of this phrase from 1857 onwards, which has been the focus of the education system for teachers to learn and change (Garet et al., 2001)....   [tags: Educational psychology, Learning, Psychology]

Strong Essays
1074 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Critical Analysis On Critical Practice

- ... Everyone thinks, but being critical requires a person to take charge of their own mind and minimize prejudice, narrowness and deception. This process has its roots as ancient as its etymology, being established by Socrates using the “elenchus” method, or Socratic method, of logically questioning people’s beliefs, whilst getting them to think about the limits of their knowledge and eventually leading them to conclusions to show the faults in reasoning. To follow, Plato’s belief was that one must subject his ideas to examination rather than acting on impulse....   [tags: Critical thinking, Thought, Reasoning, Logic]

Strong Essays
1314 words (3.8 pages)

Brooks, Gwendolyn Essay

- Brooks, Gwendolyn Poet, writer. Born June 7, 1917, in Topeka, Kansas. Throughout most of the twentieth century, Gwendolyn Brooks was a lyrical chronicler of the black urban experience in America. In 1950, she became the first African-American poet to win the Pulitzer Prize. Brooks grew up on the South Side of Chicago, Illinois. She began writing poetry as a young girl, and by the age of 16 had begun publishing her poems regularly in The Chicago Defender. She attended the Woodrow Wilson Junior College in Chicago before marrying a fellow writer, Henry L....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Strong Essays
621 words (1.8 pages)

Gwendolyn Brooks Essay

- Gwendolyn Brooks Although she was born on 7 June 1917 in Topeka, Kansas--the first child of David and Keziah Brooks--Gwendolyn Brooks is "a Chicagoan." The family moved to Chicago shortly after her birth, and despite her extensive travels and periods in some of the major universities of the country, she has remained associated with the city's South Side. What her strong family unit lacked in material wealth was made bearable by the wealth of human capital that resulted from warm interpersonal relationships....   [tags: Biography Biographies Essays]

Free Essays
1578 words (4.5 pages)