Critical Evaluation Of The Work Of David Nasaw Essay

Critical Evaluation Of The Work Of David Nasaw Essay

Length: 1111 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Academic writings are fundamental to expanding and solidifying knowledge and understanding. Axiomatic to the objective nature of the writing is the existence of persuasive source material acting to support the argument put forth. For this purpose, critical evaluation of sources should be meticulously undertaken so as to ensure a strong and competent argument has been assembled. The sources themselves can take on many different forms depending on the discipline being examined and written for, however all sources can be classified into two distinctive categories; either Primary or Secondary sources. The balance of this essay will discuss the types of sources available and using the literary work of David Nasaw (Children of the City) and the photographic work of Lewis Hines, that no one source, whether primary or secondary, provide the full scope of an event or situation and it is only when the two are consulted collectively, can one understand the full scope of an event.
To best understand how the two come together in support of an argument, it is important to appreciate the difference between primary and secondary sources. Primary sources are original, first-hand accounts of an event, created at the time of the event, or shortly afterwards . They represent factual information or personal accounts of an event and are thought to be free of bias and opinion. Secondary sources are created after the event or time period, often interpreting, critiquing and discussing primary sources and as a result will contain an opinion of the event and therefore contain bias . Another consideration when determine if something is a primary or secondary source rests in how it is (was) created. Art is a source that can be considered both a primar...


... middle of paper ...


...e time, newspapers, sociological studies, and notations from the reformers of the time, Nasaw provides agency for children such as those depicted in Hine’s photographs, showing them as actors, not simply (being) acted upon . By using the words of their contemporaries, Nasaw allows others working-class immigrant children to speak on the behalf of those photographed in Hines’s work. In doing so, he blends both primary and secondary sources and provides a balanced interpretation of their lives, including both accounts of risks and dangers encountered by these children as well as the triumphs and confidences gained during their work and play. Reinforcing, that no one sources provides a holistic representation of a situation or period in time, instead it is the combination of both that primary and secondary sources that merge together to provide a true interpretation

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Importance of Critical Thinking and Ethical Decision Making on Social Work

- It is my belief that in order for someone in the social work profession to serve vulnerable populations it was intended to serve, it is imperative to use critical thinking and ethical decision making in tandem to achieve the optimal result. The balance is a delicate and often complex. It requires a close examination or critically thinking, of all the issues not just within yourself, but the community as a whole, the individuals within it, and the client population that the social work serves. The social work profession is built on the foundation that each individual has equal worth and individual rights to self determination....   [tags: Social Work]

Better Essays
1159 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Evaluation And Evaluation Of A Rubric For Nursing Simulation

- Nursing simulation is a progressive method of education which nursing programs are utilizing to improve patient outcomes through giving students opportunities to practice and learn new nursing skills in non-threatening environments. Simulation experiences were first developed and utilized in the military and airline industries. However, many academic interest groups including medical and nursing education are adopting this technique. It is with hope that simulation experiences will allow students the opportunities they need to practice skill sets that will lead to the improvement of patient’s conditions....   [tags: Learning, Nursing, Nurse]

Better Essays
1433 words (4.1 pages)

An Evaluation Of An Employee John Schmidt Has Suffered A Serious Work Related Injury

- An employee John Schmidt has suffered a serious work related injury. There are a lot of concerns on who is to blame for the accident. This report, using the TGS Critical Thinking Rubric will serve as the framework for thinking to get to the bottom of the issue at hand. The TGS framework will help us to be able to make a more effective, and ethical decision, because the steps will enable us to consider all possibilities that led to the incident, and avoid any quick judgments. The framework also requires us to conduct checks, and balances by checking all information against the relevant criteria and benchmark....   [tags: Occupational safety and health, Ergonomics]

Better Essays
1224 words (3.5 pages)

Intro Teaching Portfolio Essay

- In fulfilment of the requirements for this assessment I taught two 3-hour-seminar sessions which were part of a course on Southeast Asian Theatre convened by a professor of Drama & Theatre at Royal Holloway. The course was designed for a group of ca. 20 second year BA students. I carried out the planning for my two sessions which was then also approved by the course leader who gave feedback on the overall concept. I was not involved in the essay marking but was asked to assist students who wished to write their essays about the topic discussed in my sessions....   [tags: teacher evaluation peaper]

Better Essays
907 words (2.6 pages)

Evaluation Of A Joint Venture Essay example

- The planning stage is important stage in which involves the decision on, specifying the objectives and goals, determination of product and market, market analysis, technology decision, revenue prediction, cost benefit analysis and personal SWOT analysis. 2. Partner selection Partner selection is main task in JV which includes; financial resources of the prospective partners, technological capabilities, presence in market and selection of partners for the feasibility study. 3. Feasibility study Affirmation of the culture and structure of the Joint Venture, analysis of partners comfort with and adaptability to the new technology and culture of the JV, analysis of the authority, responsibility...   [tags: Risk management, Project management, Construction]

Better Essays
703 words (2 pages)

Essay on Critical Evaluation Of A Social Work

- Critical Social Work practice is an ideological framework that bridges the gap between a dichotomous approach, in which there is struggle between delivering services to the individual or targeting social structures (Salas et al., 2010, p. 91). A practitioner analyzes both the macro and micro levels to determine the best course of action (Hayden, 2016). York University uses critical social work as their framework to avoid a dichotomous practice by presenting an innovative mission statement which is in align with the theory’s principles shaping the profession....   [tags: Sociology, Social work, Social class]

Better Essays
1075 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Ubah Medical Academy

- The Evaluation of Ubah Medical Academy Fathi A. Yusuf Ubah Medical Academy Introduction Schools around the nation are attempting to find new ways to get their students college ready. The whole country is now focused on educational reforms. Many schools in the state are not providing the essential skills needed to prepare their students for college. Ubah Medical Academy is one of those schools. A self proclaimed “culturally sensitive” school, Ubah Medical Academy is located in Hopkins, Minnesota....   [tags: Critical Analysis, Performance Quality]

Better Essays
1117 words (3.2 pages)

Performance Evaluations : Performance Evaluation Essay

- There are several reasons organizations initiate performance evaluations, however the standard purpose for performance evaluations is to discuss performance expectations; not only from the employers perspective but to engage in a formal collaboration where the employee and the manager are both able to provide feedback in a formal discourse. There are many different processes an organization should follow when developing its performance evaluation tool; in addition essential characteristics that must accompany an effective performance appraisal process....   [tags: Human resource management, Evaluation, Management]

Better Essays
896 words (2.6 pages)

Evaluation Of A Team Evaluation System Essay

- Team Evaluation System Because college teams are composed of individuals who come from many various backgrounds, educational level, and cultures, it is always a challenging task to implement a rating system that not only provides a sense of fairness and equity but, also helps ensure the success of the team. Team 1 has developed a system comprised of meaningful metrics which allows all members to assess how well a team member is performing. The results will be used to improve quality, increase efficiency, and enhance overall productivity....   [tags: Evaluation, Assessment, Work ethic]

Better Essays
746 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Vic Wilcox in David Lodge's Novel "Nice Work"

- Vic Wilcox in David Lodge's Novel "Nice Work" In the opening chapter of "Nice Work" we are introduced to Vic Wilcox, Managing Director of "J. Pringle & Sons Casting and General Engineering". He lives in an upmarket house on the outskirts of Rummage with his wife Marjorie and his three children. Raymond, Sandra and Gary. Vic is man who is quintessentially British. So much so that he refuses to buy goods made out of the country, the reason for his annoyance at Marjorie wanting a microwave (96% manufactured in the East) and for buying a Japanese clock radio....   [tags: Nice Work David Lodge Essays]

Better Essays
1730 words (4.9 pages)