Critical Commentary on Urban Sustainability Essay

Critical Commentary on Urban Sustainability Essay

Length: 1689 words (4.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Since the late 1980s, the notion of ‘sustainable development’ has transcended beyond the eminent United Nations report titled Our Common Future, to mainstream dialogue throughout the globe at all scales within government and public spheres. This form of development seeks to balance current environmental, social and economic needs of the population, “without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” (World Commission on Environment and Development, 1987, 43). Used interchangeably with ‘sustainability’ (Seghezzo, 2009), the concept has been fastened to a plethora of themes, including that of cities where ‘urban sustainability’ speaks to negligent urban expansion and resource depletion. However, as the idea of urban sustainability has begun percolating into widespread discussions, so to have the obstacles and conflicts surrounding sustainable development. The following sections will examine these complexities, beginning with the ambiguity of sustainable development, followed by interpretations of urban sustainability, and finally, the political ecology of sustainable development in an urban environment.
Sustainable Cities or Cities that Contribute to Sustainable Development
Critique of the term ‘sustainable development’ has primarily surrounded its wide scope of interpretation, which is regarded as both a strength, in its ability to foster multi-stakeholder cooperation, and a weakness, in that anybody can claim they are contributing to sustainability goals (Dale, 2001; Robinson, 2009). Satterthwaite’s article entitled “Sustainable Cities or Cities that Contribute to Sustainable Development” (1997), alludes to the ambiguity of the term and explores the predicament rather than benefit th...

... middle of paper ...

...18(1), 67-85.

Redclift, M. (2005). Sustainable Development (1987-2005): An Oxymoron Comes of Age. Sustainable Development, 13(4), 212-227.

Robbins, P. (2004). What is Political Ecology? In Political Ecology (pp. 1-15).Malden: Blackwell Publishing.

Robinson, P. (2009). Urban Sustainability in Canada: The Global-Local Connection. In C. Gore, & P. Stoett (Eds.), Environmental Challenges and Opportunities: Local-Global Perspectives on Canadian Issues (pp. 159-181). Toronto: Edmond Montgomery Publications.

Seghezzo, L. (2009). The five dimensions of sustainability. Environmental Politics, 18(4), 539 - 556.

Satterthwaite, D. (1997). Sustainable Cities or Cities that Contribute to Sustainable Development? Urban Studies, 34(1), 1667-1691.

WCED. World Commission on Environment and Development. (1987). Our Common Future. New York: Oxford University Press.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Urban Village Is Gaining Popularity Of The Uk

- Formative essay: Drawing on specific examples, explore the ways in which ‘villages don’t make a city’ (Biddulph) As Biddulph (2000) acknowledges in his paper “Villages Don’t Make a City”, the urban village is gaining popularity in the UK. The polycentric city structure is by many regarded as a model for the future. However, there is an ongoing discussion on whether sustainable cities should be ‘monocentric’; built around a main body, or ‘polycentric’; consisting of several smaller, oftentimes independent entities or villages....   [tags: City, Village, Sustainability, Urban design]

Powerful Essays
1579 words (4.5 pages)

Sustainability, Environmental Sustainability And Economic Sustainability

- Early pioneer of ecological substantiality, Herman Daly, proposed a problem of environmental maintenance. He proposed, (1.) renewable resources of harvest should not exceed the rate of regeneration (sustainable yield), (2.) the rates of waste generation from projects should not exceed assimilative capacity of the environment and, (3.) non renewable resources should require comparable development of renewable substitutes for that resource. (Daly, 1990) Despite his insight and projections, human continue to over use natural capital....   [tags: Sustainability, Ecology, Natural environment]

Powerful Essays
933 words (2.7 pages)

Questions On Sustainability And Sustainability Essay

- Prior understanding about sustainability My initial understanding of the Sustainability was all only about saving the environment by adopting environment friendly “green” measures. My concepts of Sustainability measures limited to the companies spending in recycling and innovation in technology, which helps to do more with fewer natural resources, consumer behaviour and the legislations’ measures by framing the rules such as carbon tax to reduce the companies’ carbon foot print and from damaging the environment....   [tags: Sustainability, Sustainable development]

Powerful Essays
1542 words (4.4 pages)

An Analysis of Policy Levers for Increasing Sustainability of the City of Ottawa’s Urban Transportation System

- Introduction Cities are the epitome of regional, national and international hubs that represent the congregation of people, a healthy social vitality, and are the symbol of wealth. They are economic, social, and environmental metropolises that are the aim of smaller, striving municipalities. Nonetheless, most cities are plagued by urban unsustainability where the car is the focal point of transport, making traffic denser than numerous buildings and car ownership greater than the city’s population....   [tags: Canada, urban planning/issues]

Powerful Essays
7175 words (20.5 pages)

A Critical Commentary On Water Crisis Essay

- In recent days, water crisis has been regarded as one of the catastrophic environmental issues beside pollution and biodiversity loss since the water itself is truly important for sustaining all beings living on the planet. When people overestimate the power of the knowledge of science by which they think all of problems can be solved, they overlook to analyze why and where are the problems coming out. In the other words, we can totally address the environmental issues only if we had found out the main source from where they are originated....   [tags: Water, Water resources, Indigenous peoples]

Powerful Essays
953 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Critical Commentary On The Franco Ballad

- Critical commentary on Rico Franco ballad. There can be no exact definition of ballads; they are poems of varied length from as short as 16 verses to even 1366. Most often they are expressed through an oral media and narrated musically to accompany dances, portray traditions or historical events. ‘A caza iban, a caza’ is a Novelesque Spanish ballad as it depicts the feelings of honour and justice; a European folklore theme widespread at that time. This ballad paints a story of huntsmen, who overtake a castle called ‘Maynés’ where Rico Franco kidnaps a damsel to take away with him....   [tags: Poetry, Rhyme, Ballad, Refrain]

Powerful Essays
1483 words (4.2 pages)

Evolution Of Urban And Urban Development Essays

- For thousands of years, humans have lived together in cities. The concept of urban entities predates recorded history. The role of cities in everyday life has changed throughout human history. This evolution has never appeared more evident than now. With the majority of the world’s population living in cities, they have taken a new prominence in the study of geography. Cities serve as cultural and economic hubs from which new ideas and businesses diffuse. Their control reaches far beyond the immediately surrounding areas....   [tags: City, Urban area, Developed environments]

Powerful Essays
924 words (2.6 pages)

Sustainability in the City of Portland, Oregon Essay

- Along with a thorough enough discussion of anything comes the inevitable unearthing of its strengths and weaknesses. The Portland Plan has a number of strengths: it is comprehensive, well thought out, inclusive, and should ultimately lead to a well-planned and sustainable city. How in-depth the Portland Plan is, is a testament to its preparedness to face any challenges to lead the Portland of today into becoming the Portland of tomorrow, as any potential question that may arise is likely addressed within the text of the plan....   [tags: Urban Development ]

Powerful Essays
2123 words (6.1 pages)

Urban Deisgn Essay

- Urban design continues to exist in our everyday lives. The elegance of buildings and their architectural structure stand out in cities competing to show their uniqueness and radiance. Not every urban design can show off their styles. The buildings people pass by in every day urban areas manage to connect with people. The urban design has different forms; it can be either contemporary or futuristic. It is interesting to investigate about just how futuristic can a design be and how acceptable it can become to the public....   [tags: Urban Development ]

Powerful Essays
2320 words (6.6 pages)

Urban Transportation Essay

- Most people take the urban public transportation system for granted. It is used in every aspect of our daily lives: work, education, medical necessities, recreation, etc. It is also important for the transportation of goods and services, which aids the growth and maintenance of our economy. Urban public transportation is the critical component of our quality of life and economic stability. The MBTA, the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority, is Boston and Eastern Massachusetts’s major transportation service....   [tags: Urban Research ]

Powerful Essays
1041 words (3 pages)