Critical Assessment Of The Author 's Effectiveness Essay

Critical Assessment Of The Author 's Effectiveness Essay

Length: 763 words (2.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A critical analysis essay is an overall assessment of the author’s effectiveness in conveying his or her purpose. (Wilhoit 95) There are several different aspects of critique writing: analysis, evaluation, and explanation. The analysis requires you to break down the reading into essential parts, evaluation requires you to assess the quality of those various parts, and the explanation should link your judgments to specific aspects of the readings and make those connections clear and convincing to your reader. (97) Such writing requires you to know the criteria or certain expected aspects of a reading (such as thesis, support, genre, or style), and to use standards which are the basis for evaluating. (95) To do so, use your textbooks, especially Dialogues to remind you of what a good argument must include (Ch 1-2).


You will be required to write a one to two page paper critical analysis on an argumentative article. You will be able to choose any article from the thematic readings in Dialogues. You will need to: identify a principle or definition relating to argument (See Ch. 1 & 2 of Writing Arguments), ask a question concerning the principle, answer the question by apply the principle or definition chosen.

Ex. Effective Arguments are based on logical facts rather than mere emotion.
Question: Does the emotional appeal presented in this article invalidate its argument?
Answer: If effective arguments are based on logical facts rather than mere emotion, the article must use facts to support its emotive claims.

You will go into specifics by identify the claim or argument, stance the author is taking (pro or con), and support the author provides. You will need to establish a principle or standard of what is an effective...

... middle of paper ...

..., and without logical fallacies (doesn’t use faulty generalization, slippery slope etc.)
Body Paragraphs: The body paragraph(s) will provide the syllogism for the standard or criteria with explanation and overall reference to the weakness or strength of the paper, identify the aspects (claim, stance, and support), explain how your identification is correct (how did you find or figure out what the thesis was), and evaluate.
Conclusion Paragraph: Restate your thesis: Author is successful/unsuccessful because…
Remind your reader of your conclusions, wrap up, and end with a concluding statement.

APA Format:

Double spaced, Times New Roman: 12 font. Should have title page, but not abstract. Title centered on page two. Running head and full capitalized head with page number in proper position. Proper in-text citations including author’s name(s), year, and page number.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Teams And The Mbti Assessment

- Teams and the MBTI Assessment A successful team environment is dependent upon understanding the purpose of the team, knowing the characteristics of the team, making necessary adjustments through change and education, and keeping an open mind to unfamiliar ideas and concepts. The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) personality assessment can provide individuals with an understanding of various characteristics in people. Understanding your own personal characteristics, was well as those of your team can aid in bringing balance to a team environment, which is key to success....   [tags: Myers-Briggs Type Indicator]

Better Essays
900 words (2.6 pages)

Critical Review of Mechanisms Used to Monitor and Audit the Quality in Care Services

- Critical Review of Mechanisms Used to Monitor and Audit the Quality in Care Services Task 1 ====== For professionals working with clients it may seem that quality of care has always been an issue of importance. Most work places will have some sort of quality assurance system in place and it is assumed that quality can therefore be measured. As definitions relating to quality tend to be less concrete, measuring quality is a complex matter. One mechanism used to monitor quality is the audit....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
2612 words (7.5 pages)

Teaching Literacy Across Secondary Classrooms Essay

- Every Teacher is a language Teacher. This statement is both simple and complex, and requires all teachers to collaborate across curriculums and classrooms to promote academic literacy. The case for promoting literacy across secondary classrooms is essential. Promoting and providing literacy is not only essential for students, but also imperative for instructors, administrators and school districts alike. When thinking about literacy, we may automatically veer in the direction of reading, but literacy includes writing, comprehension, vocabulary, morphology, phonemes, phonics, spelling, syntax, written expression and even speaking and listening....   [tags: Learning, Critical thinking, Education, Thought]

Better Essays
1427 words (4.1 pages)

Assessment of Critical Thinking Essay

- Assessment of learning can be a meaningful tool for teachers and students during a course to provide feedback to the student about the type and quality of work that is being completed in the course and for the instructor to find areas where the student is having difficulties and so additional materials can be provided or the course modified. The aim of this paper is to define assessment and critical thinking skills, and then review a State University course and suggest different assessments that could be used to demonstrate learning....   [tags: Critical Thinking Essays]

Better Essays
969 words (2.8 pages)

Analysing the Environmental Impact Assessment Systems around the World Essay

- ... The authors carried out the assessment of the EIA process and identified the following weakness in the system. • There are comprehensive guidelines, legal and legislative provisions but administrative setup is very weak. EIA is just a formality as most of the time EIA is conducted after start of construction. • Coordination among the consultants and planners are very weak. • Involvement of stakeholders into ToR process during scoping is inadequate which results in a thin coverage of socio-economic and environmental issues in the EIA reports....   [tags: significance, effectiveness]

Better Essays
1704 words (4.9 pages)

Questions On Assessment Strategies And Timing Essay

- Assessment Strategies The key to assessment strategies and timing is balance. Garrison and Ehringhaus (2014) claim that “when a comprehensive assessment program at the classroom level balances formative and summative student learning/achievement information, a clear picture emerges of where a student is relative to learning targets and standards.” Specifically throughout s course’s sequence or semester, there will be a summative assessment at the conclusion of the course. Other than the final or culminating assessment for the course, summative assessments should be kept to a reasonable number, in order to reduce the possibility of increasing student anxiety....   [tags: Summative assessment, Assessment]

Better Essays
1043 words (3 pages)

A Definition Of Formative And Summative Assessments Essay

- A Definition of Formative and Summative Assessments When one thinks of the term assessment, they will most likely think of a test. This is what we know as summative assessment. Summative assessment can be defined as evaluation of student learning at the end of a unit (Formative vs. Summative). For more than 20 years, formative assessment has been highly researched and even accredited as a critical part of a teacher’s pedagogy. In the last decade it (formative assessment has become something of a buzzword and in some cases a mandate in k-12 schools across the country....   [tags: Summative assessment, Formative assessment]

Better Essays
718 words (2.1 pages)

The Author Function Essay

- Those literary critics and conventionally minded readers who seek to critically engage the many texts which shape the canon of Western knowledge too often ask the same, misguided questions. Their discourse is, according to Michel Foucault, trapped within parameters established by a dominant mode of thinking with grants the “author” absolute primacy. Even the recognition of this paradigm too often produces a similarly misguided interrogation: “Who really spoke. Is it really he and not someone else....   [tags: Author]

Better Essays
1823 words (5.2 pages)

Assessment Plan Evaluation Essay

- Introduction Effective assessment of higher education institutional effectiveness is still in a stage of relative infancy, and to date has developed as a reactive response to external pressures. Assessment planning and institutional improvement have taken shape as a result of accrediting body influences on member institutions. However, even various accrediting bodies have yet to settle on common criteria and standards other than very general guidelines typically focused on evidence, validity, sustainability, and an improvement process....   [tags: Assessment ]

Better Essays
1359 words (3.9 pages)

Keyboarding Assessments Essays

- It is important to ensure that the Learning Objectives have been achieved and that learning by the students have mastered the course. To decipher the level of learning, assessments are developed to make such determinations. This paper will provide examples of assessments of the learning objectives created in the previous Module. It will also discuss the use of Outcome-Based Assessments (OBA), and provide an outcome based assessment for an adult keyboard course. It will define and discuss the purpose of an Outcome-Based Assessment, the challenges such an assessment, and describe solutions that can be utilized when implementing this assessment into a program....   [tags: Assessment ]

Better Essays
1027 words (2.9 pages)