Critical Analysis of The Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan Essay

Critical Analysis of The Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan Essay

Length: 1831 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

This essay is a critical analysis that will explain the historical representation of two films that represent the World War Two Normandy Landings. The Normandy Landings took place on June 6, 1944 in France. The Normandy Landings also referred as D- Day, was an invasion by Allied forces on Normandy Beach by crossing by sea and air from English channel to Normandy Beach, which was captured by Nazi forces. The D-Day invasion is the largest war invasion by way of sea and air that included forces from twelve Allied countries. The objective was to reclaim Normandy from the Nazis and establish control over the area as the Germans were attempting to strengthen the position they had in Normandy, France . The general of the Allied forces Dwight E. Eisenhower planned and executed the massive invasion that was codenamed ‘Operation Overload’. Operation Overload involved that would involve transporting troops and supplies from the English Channel to Normandy Beach, this involved attacks from the air and troops on the ground . The Allies forces out number the Germans in Normandy and consequently reclaimed the area. The outcomes of this operation on D-Day ended with the Allied forces claiming Normandy from the Germans and in the process the loss of approximately 425,000 Allied and German soldiers. The invasions by the Allied forces were significant because it allowed access for the Allied forces to enter the border of Western Germany and fight against the Germans on their home turf. If D-Day had not occurred, the outcome for the war might have been different .
The films being assessed in the essay that both represent the events of the Normandy Landings are The Longest day a film released in 1962 and Saving Private Ryan a film released in 1998. T...


... middle of paper ...


...ents the perspectives of the war from both sides. It also is more accurate in telling the story in its entirety of the events that happened on D-Day. Saving Private Ryan only focuses only on a small number of American soldiers in the war and fails to present the entire story prior or after the Normandy Landings.
Despite representing the story of the D-Day invasion more accurately, the Longest Day lacks the more realistic nature of the effects war than Saving Private Ryan achieves (number of casualties, blood etc.). Saving Private Ryan shows soldiers who have lost body parts and that are covered in blood screaming in pain. The film also is more accurate in showing the number of Allied casualties on Normandy Beach. The Longest Day attempts to glorify the Allies in the film and doesn’t demonstration the accurate number of soldiers lying dead on the beach.
Conclusion

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Saving Private Ryan Vs. The Longest Day Essay

- Saving Private Ryan Vs. The Longest Day Both of these films, Saving Private Ryan (1999) and the Longest Day (1962), are representations of the D-day landings on Omaha beach in France. The war film genre was chosen due to its popularity, historical interest and the excitement and adventure involved in battle. The longest day could have easily been an English propaganda film, as it gave a very un-realistic view on the D-day landings, glorifying the British, and making the Nazis look incapable of winning the war....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1020 words (2.9 pages)

Analysis of Saving Private Ryan and Longest Day Essay

- Analysis of Saving Private Ryan and Longest Day On the beach in Northern France, an American Soldier searches frantically for his lost arm. Gunshots emerge from all angles of the screen. As this soldier helplessly goes from one place to another, there are more dead bodies piling up on Omaha Beach in Northern France. As this soldier collects his separated arm from the battlefield and walks off into the horizon, Tom Hanks enters a rather explosive battle. He leads his men into battle with nothing more than guns and a helmet....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
696 words (2 pages)

Critical Analysis of The Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan Essay

- This essay is a critical analysis that will explain the historical representation of two films that represent the World War Two Normandy Landings. The Normandy Landings took place on June 6, 1944 in France. The Normandy Landings also referred as D- Day, was an invasion by Allied forces on Normandy Beach by crossing by sea and air from English channel to Normandy Beach, which was captured by Nazi forces. The D-Day invasion is the largest war invasion by way of sea and air that included forces from twelve Allied countries....   [tags: The Normandy Landings, D-Day, Allies, film]

Powerful Essays
1831 words (5.2 pages)

Essay about The Events of June in The Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan

- The Events of June in The Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan The two clips we saw didn't have the same things being shown in them or in other words, they were different. There's a major difference between the camera angles and camera and lens movements. The focus of the two clips are also different as the second clip, "Saving Private Ryan" focuses a bit more on the individual aspects and it showed more different emotions as compared to the other clip. And also the first clip was focusing more on the army as a whole and showed it as an open event....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1147 words (3.3 pages)

The Media Techniques Used to Produce D-day Landing on the Saving Private Ryan and The Longest Day

- The Media Techniques Used to Produce D-day Landing on the Saving Private Ryan and The Longest Day The D-Day landing must have been one of the most brutal battles between the Americans and the Germans during the World War 2. Both "Saving Private Ryan" and "The Longest Day" were produced as films to represent the brutality of what the D-Day was like. However, although both films were similar in the perspective of the factual storyline, their standards of filming and production were different due to the time they were filmed....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1279 words (3.7 pages)

Examining the Different Ways in Which D-day Landing at Omaha Beach is Depicted in Saving Private Ryan and The Longest Day

- Examining the Different Ways in Which D-day Landing at Omaha Beach is Depicted in Saving Private Ryan and The Longest Day ‘ Saving Private Ryan’ was made in 1998 by Stephen Spielberg and gives a graphic depiction of the events at Omaha beach on D-day, focusing on a small section of the army and portrays it on a more personal level. ‘The Longest Day’ was made 17 years after the war in 1963 by director Darryl Zannuck. This gives us more of an overview of the entirety of D-Day depicting army, navy and air force as well as the German army and French resistance....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1577 words (4.5 pages)

Comparing The Media Techniques Used to Present the D-Day Landings in the Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan

- Comparing The Media Techniques Used to Present the D-Day Landings in the Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan The heroism and bravery of those who took part in the D-Day has been brought to the big screen from several perspectives. 1939-1945 were some of the most horrific times in the broad spectrum of human conflict ever seen by mankind with unmatched weapons of devastation and the senseless slaughter of millions of lives both on and off the fields of battle. The Longest Day (1962) is a brilliant rendition of the famous D-Day invasion of Normandy....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1341 words (3.8 pages)

Comparing The Longest Day Directed by Andrew Martin and Saving Private Ryan Directed by Steven Spielberg

- Comparing The Longest Day Directed by Andrew Martin and Saving Private Ryan Directed by Steven Spielberg These two directors were trying to achieve different goals, 'The Longest Day' was made post-war in 1962 and when the war may still of been in peoples thoughts and where many of the people who fought in the war would still be alive. However 'Saving Private Ryan' was made much later on in 1999, by then the world has gladly put this terrible event behind it. Steven Spielberg is not as biased because his audience now do not have the same attitude as in 1962, only 17 years after the war....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
710 words (2 pages)

Essay on Analysis of the Opening Battle Sequence in the Film Saving Private Ryan

- Wartime adventure film, ‘Saving Private Ryan’ was first released in 1998 by ‘Paramount’ and ‘Dreamworks’ Pictures. It internationally achieved a long lasting effect as it became the winner of five academy awards and five Oscars; the film won these awards because the first 24minuites captured people’s imagination and interest. It tells the story of a squad of American soldiers led by Captain Miller (Tom Hanks) on a dangerous mission to find ‘Private James Ryan’ whose three brothers have already been killed in the D-day landings....   [tags: movies]

Powerful Essays
884 words (2.5 pages)

Film Analysis of Saving Private Ryan and It's Depiction Essay examples

- Film Analysis of Saving Private Ryan and It's Depiction The D-Day landings were a significant event in history, so significant that two films have been made about it. The first one is The Longest Day directed by Darryl Zanuck in the 1960s and the second one is Saving Private Ryan directed by Steven Spielberg in the 1990s. AS these films were made in different decades the audiences expectations and tolerances of films differ considerably. The aim of Spielberg was to shock audiences from the very beginning of the film whereas the D-Day landings don’t feature until an hour into the film, The Longest Day is more informative than Saving Private Ryan as it features actu...   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
905 words (2.6 pages)