Critical Analysis of the Article, The Side Effects of NCLB and Horace’s Compromise

Critical Analysis of the Article, The Side Effects of NCLB and Horace’s Compromise

Length: 1258 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Critical Analysis of The side Effects of NCLB and Horace’s Compromise
In the article The side Effects of NCLB, Gordan Cawelti discusses his concerns regarding the focus of NCLB. The federal legislation focuses on math and reading test scores resulting in a narrowing of the curriculum in the schools. Although the purpose of NCLB is to diminish the gap among subgroups of students, the counter result is an imbalance that, in Mr. Cawelti’s opinion, “denies many students access to the high-quality curriculums that students in more affluent schools enjoy.”
An important piece of NCLB is the mandate that schools must show adequate yearly progress (AYP) in math and reading. Consequences are in place for those schools that do not demonstrate AYP. Teachers feel pressured to focus on raising test scores at the expense of time spent in creative teaching of other subject areas. Cawelti goes on to provide a review of models that might be employed to “create a balanced diet” in the curriculum.
Theodore Sizer presents a rather disturbing commentary on secondary schools in Horace’s Compromise. He speaks to curriculum choices, teaching methods, time allotment to teach a subject, and what the responsibilities of the state are regarding the education of our children. As schools attempt to provide a more broad range curriculum, perhaps the quality of the education suffers. Sizer puts forth the conclusion that “less is more” and “Information is plentiful, cheap; learning how to use it …requires a form of personal coaching of each student by a teacher.” Of course this takes time which is in short supply in the high school setting, perhaps due to broadened curriculum. Two themes that seem to recur throughout Horace’s Compromise...


... middle of paper ...


...ncourage teachers to find a novel ways to teach skills. Educators need to be cognizant of the fact that what works for one student may not work for another. It is important to teach to the learner by finding out what drives their quest for education. It has been my experience that enthusiasm is infectious and can go a long way to entice teachers to buy into new ideas.
Sizer’s passion for the learner is one I share. The New York Times included the following quote in his obituary last October. “Inspiration, hunger: these are the qualities that drive good schools. The best we educational planners can do is to create the most likely conditions for them to flourish, and then get out of their way.” In order to do this perhaps NCLB may require some “tweaks” but at the same time I think we have to be careful not to “throw out the baby with the bathwater.”



Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Effects And Side Effects Of Today's Legal Prohormones Essay

- “At his age, you have to ask, Did he accomplish all of this by rejuvenating his strength from day to day with those substances?” baseball great Hank Aaron asked regarding anabolic substance abuser Barry Bonds. Prohormones are a relatively new supplement said to be the “legal” form of steroids. (Aaron) Though some people see huge gains while on using prohormones, they don’t know the true damage prohormones really cause. Athletes and bodybuilders taking prohormones experience terrible side effects, muscular gains that are less than expected, depleted testosterone levels and destroyed endocrine systems....   [tags: steroids, side effects, body, supplement]

Better Essays
1247 words (3.6 pages)

The Side Effects Of Sexism Essay

- Side Effects of Sexism Sexism is a delicately described word that can have multiple meanings to many different individuals. The majority of the time it is against men and women, in the workplace, benefits, and the way the opposite sexes view one another. Many workplaces have laws which are supposed to prevent sexism, but sexism is still heavily absorbed into many human-beings mind. It’s definitely hard to avoid sexism when it is everywhere. Sexism is defined as attitudes or behavior based on traditional stereotypes of sexual roles....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Female, Male]

Better Essays
1103 words (3.2 pages)

The Side of Paradise by F. Scott Fitzgerald Essay

- In the book This Side of Paradise by F. Scott Fitzgerald, even though the main protagonist’s, Amory Blaine, character development is completely controlled by Fitzgerald's life, Amory goes through many changes through the story and they are born from the people Amory is around and Amory interactions with other characters are in relation to how Fitzgerald interacted and responded with others. Amory’s character seems to fluctuate throughout the novel, the more types of people he meets the more ideas he obtains and begins to view life differently or back to the same way multiple times....   [tags: This Side of Paradise, F.Scott Fitzgerald]

Better Essays
1115 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Music, an Alternative to Medicine?

- Music is used in a variety of different ways. Some are very simple and logical, many others are creative and complex. Music is used to give emphasis to movies and advertisements, commercials and TV shows. Music is also used to express feelings and to communicate ideas and thoughts, without the barrier of language. People who cannot understand a language, can respond to music by singing, dancing, beating on a drum, in whatever way; people respond to music, and they like it (Weiss). A song may mean totally different things to different people with their own preferences and cultures....   [tags: Side Effects, Cheerful, Anxiety]

Better Essays
1451 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on Critical Analysis On Critical Practice

- Define critical practice in academic essay writing It is considered that critics love to take sides. As compelling as it may be, being critical is not about trusting one’s instinct and taking a one-sided decision, but rather investigate, evaluate and consider different opinions and only thereafter cultivate one’s own perspective. In practice, critical thinking can be referred as an ‘active process’ that implies raising questions and finding information yourself, contrasting with the ‘passive process’ of receiving ideas and information from someone else.(Dewey, 1910) The ultimate question is why would a critical approach be better in an academic environment....   [tags: Critical thinking, Thought, Reasoning, Logic]

Better Essays
1314 words (3.8 pages)

The Side Effects Of Antidepressants : An Overview Essay

- Marina Eskandrous Senior Project: Assignment 1: Article: “Side effects of antidepressants: An Overview” According to the DSM5 major depressive describes a person who is in a depressed mood for most of the day, nearly everyday. The person also has a diminished interest or pleasure in all, or almost all, activities most of the time. There may be significant weight loss or gain as a result of decrease or increase of appetite, respectively. The person may also experience insomnia or hyper insomnia nearly everyday....   [tags: Antidepressant]

Better Essays
949 words (2.7 pages)

Horace Miner’s Body Ritual Among the Nacirema Essay

- Horace Miner’s Body Ritual Among the Nacirema In Horace Miner’s article, “Body Ritual Among the Nacirema”, he talks about a tribe and describes their odd behavior. He tells about how the tribe performs these strange daily rituals and how their peculiarity is extreme, but in fact he is actually speaking of Americans as a whole (Miner). Miner uses this style of writing to more effectively prove his point: that Americans are ethnocentric. Miner does an exceptional job in disguising the Nacirema as Americans....   [tags: Horace Miner Body Ritual Among the Nacirema]

Better Essays
580 words (1.7 pages)

Alarming Side Effects of Artificial Sweeteners Essay

- Alarming Side Effects of Artificial Sweeteners NutraSweet, Equal, Spoonful, and Equal-Measure are all brand names for aspartame, a low calorie sugar substitute used in more than 90 countries to sweeten foods and beverages. Aspartame is a synthetic chemical that is created through the combination of the amino acids phenylalanine and aspartic acid, and a small amount of methanol. Aspartame can be found in several products, such as soft drinks, over-the counter drugs, vitamin and herb supplements, instant breakfasts, candy, breath mints, cereals, sugar-free chewing gum, coffee, juice, and tea beverages, tabletop sweeteners, and gelatin desserts....   [tags: Exploratory Essays Research Papers]

Better Essays
1090 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Side Effects of Prozac

- Side Effects of Prozac Unlike earlier forms of antidepressants, such as MAO inhibitors, Prozac and other SSRIs tend to produce fewer and less severe side effects (Hockenbury, 200). According to Prozac's manufacturer, Eli Lilly (2005), side effects caused by Prozac may include nausea, difficulty sleeping, drowsiness, nervousness, weakness, loss of appetite, tremors, dry mouth, sweating, or yawning. Other side effects listed included a change in sexual desire or satisfaction and a formation of a rash or hives....   [tags: Antidepressants Depression Essays]

Free Essays
1492 words (4.3 pages)

Horace Mann Essay

- 	Horace Mann was the father of the American School System. Horace Mann’s had many reforms on education. He was born in 1796. Mann determined what the purpose of education should be based on his own experience and observation. Mann also had many ideas how education could be improved. Many of these ideas have been followed by schools today as well. Mann also had ideas on topics which one considers today to be controversial. The public should take into account what Mann’s ideas were on these issues....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
678 words (1.9 pages)