Critical Analysis of Schulman's Article 'Gay Marriage and Marriage' Essay

Critical Analysis of Schulman's Article 'Gay Marriage and Marriage' Essay

Length: 949 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Marriage, for years has been argued that the rights to it or strictly only between a man and a women. Both sexes are assumed to marry someone of the opposite sex. What if, however, an individual wanted to marry someone of the same sex? Why is this debate so heavily heated amongst individuals? Is it that religion is a large structure base that those in society are guided by? Or is it that individuals do not understand that marriage is a union between two individuals who are in love? Whatever the case may be, there is always someone who has to argue that homosexual marriage is “wrong.”
Sam Schulman argues that homosexual marriage is about the duties or roles that these couples perform that would be different from that of heterosexual couples. In his article Gay Marriage -- and Marriage the author directs his argument towards those who are "passionately and instinctively opposed to the idea of homosexual marriage" (Schulman, 2003).
Schulman blames legalization of homosexual marriage as the cause for the possible permission of incest. However, this is like saying that if marijuana were to be legalized, it will lead to the acceptance of cocaine. Even when homosexuals do achieve their legal rights, currently only given to heterosexual married couples; it will not give rise to the legalization of incestuous relationships and incestuous marriages. Legalizing gay marriage will not pose any threat to the structure of society.
Society is created with both homosexual and heterosexual individuals. Previously when certain laws discriminated against others, such as law for women's rights to vote, these laws were changed. Changing the traditions of the country does not mean that it will lead to the legalization of other extreme issues. Each ...


... middle of paper ...


...an and they deserve equal treatment and protection under the law.

In conclusion his article is highly ineffective due to his illogical arguments. While many of his hypotheses may be readily accepted by the audience, his attempt to reason others his approach is faulty. While his goal of empowering others with his same beliefs might be effective, he still misses with persuasion. Schulman's argument could be strengthened if he removes the statements regarding female sexuality in marriage as well as contraceptives. Finally he should actually discuss the view points of those who support homosexual marriage, not simply the views of those who are against it.



Works Cited

Shulman, Sam. "Sam Shulman -- Gay Marriage -- and Marriage." OrthodoxyToday.org |. Commentary Magazine, Nov. 2003. Web. 31 May 2010. .

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Tragedy of Gay Marriage

- Sam Schulman’s “The Worst Thing About Gay Marriage” presents an interesting argument against gay marriage that hinges upon maintaining a traditional form of marriage. He actually claims that gay marriage is “unnecessary”(381). According to Schulman, there are 4 primary effects of marriage within his definition he calls the kinship system. First, marriage protects and controls a woman’s sexuality. Second, the possible pairings are limited by the kinship system to avoid incest or other taboos. Third, marriage creates a situation where licit sex can occur....   [tags: Sam Schulman, Marriage]

Better Essays
1743 words (5 pages)

A Critical Analysis Of Open Relationships Are Healthy Essay

- ... 251-252). Dyson mentions there are seventeen different lifestyles that people have adopted and adapted over the years to suit their intimacy needs. Dr. William R. Stayton, identifies out of the seventeen; polyamory, polyfidelity, open marriage, group marriage, swinging, synergamy, and family clusters these lifestyles include multiple partners. Donald Dyson argues that no matter what type of lifestyle or relationship choice, it is the behavior of the people involved that has the greatest effect on the relative healthiness of any given relationship style (Hall, 2010, p....   [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, Homosexuality]

Better Essays
935 words (2.7 pages)

Critical Analysis on The Scream by Edvard Munch Essay example

- Critical Analysis on The Scream by Edvard Munch Edvard Munch was born on December 12 1863 in Loten Norway. He moved to Christiana, and spent most of his childhood there. Both his mother and his oldest sister suffered from tuberculosis and died before he reached the age of 14. At 18 he became more serious about his art and started attending art school. Edvard finally found a release for the pain he felt from his sister’s death. In 1886 he painted “The Sick Child”. The painting was so emotionally charged that it received a lot of criticism from the press and the public....   [tags: a critical analysis]

Better Essays
1606 words (4.6 pages)

Critical Analysis And Evaluation Of An Issue Essay

- ... We took a snippet of the essay and found out what each line meant. For Example: “Go placidly amid the noise and haste, and remember what peace there may be in silence.” (Max Ehrmann, 1927) This sentence stood out to me in the Desiderata because I love to be in silence. I feel when I am silent or in silence I am at peace. I find that I am more comfortable and relaxed when I am quiet and I get to focus on what is going on around me. There is nothing but peace in silence and with that comes so much more....   [tags: Critical thinking, Logic, Reasoning]

Better Essays
1000 words (2.9 pages)

Critical Evaluation Of Incident Analysis Essay

- Critical Evaluation of Incident Vachon and Leblac (2011) claim that reflective learning is facilitated by Critical Incident Analysis, the key components being a thorough analysis of an authentic, contextualised experience. In practise, through research, Kettle and Sellars (1996) established that peer reflection amongst groups of students, was integral to challenging preconceived ideas of their own pedagogy. In addition, Onjanen (1993), argues that the use of reflective journals, group discussion and own personal history are the most effective means to reflect, and subsequently improve on practise....   [tags: Education, Critical thinking, Teacher, School]

Better Essays
1222 words (3.5 pages)

A Critical Analysis of John Demos' The Unredeemed Captive Essay

- John Demos’s “the Unredeemed Captive” is a story about a man named John Williams, and his five children who were captured by Indians during a war in 1704. John Williams and his children are eventually released, but much to his disappointment, his youngest daughter Eunice remained with her captors, and married an Indian man. This story has a captivating storyline, and makes for a very compelling narrative. In this paper I will attempt to make a critical analysis of John Demos’s work. The major areas I am looking at are the evolution or the piece, from beginning to end, what the major sections of the book are and how they flow together, and how this work is and isn’t a conventional narrative....   [tags: Critical Analysis]

Free Essays
262 words (0.7 pages)

Essay about Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA)

- 1. Introduction Critical discourse analysis (CDA) is primarily inspired by Halliday’s (1985) Systemic Functional Linguistics (SFL) which describes language as ‘social semiotic’. According to Fowler et al. (1979), “language is social act and it is ideologically driven”. van Dijk (1988) also views language as being not only based on linguistic structures but also on a set of ‘complex communicative events’ which are embedded in social context. He introduces the socio-cognitive model of CDA where social and personal cognition mediates between society and discourse....   [tags: linguistics, analysis of texts]

Better Essays
1466 words (4.2 pages)

Winesburg Ohio Critical Analysis Essay

- Written by Sherwood Anderson in 1919, Winesburg, Ohio, a collection of short stories, allows us to enter the alternately complex, lonely, joyful, and strange lives of the inhabitants of the small town of Winesburg, Ohio. While each character finds definition through their role in the community, we are witness to the individual struggle each faces in trying to reconcile their secret life within. A perfect example of two characters are Alice Hindman and Enoch Robinson. The loneliness and illusion that encompass the lives of Alice Hindman and Enoch Robinson are the result of the discrepancy between their own capacity for intimacy and affection and the inability of others to truly understa...   [tags: Critical Analysis]

Better Essays
1064 words (3 pages)

Critical Analysis of Tintern Abbey Essay

- Wordsworth renews traditional themes through the device of characterisation. In Lyttelton's "Lucinda", his female character Lucinda "simply completes a definition of the good life, whereas Wordsworth's Dorothy offers a link with the past." The presence of a loved companion is linked to the stability and love that the poet feels for nature. "However, where Cowper is quiet in his sincerity, Wordsworth is much more earnest in his plea for Dorothy." Renewal for Wordsworth means a renewal of passionate emotions and a strong sense of loyalty to the landscape, as seen in his poem Tintern Abbey....   [tags: Poetry Analysis]

Free Essays
279 words (0.8 pages)

Critical Thinking Application Essay example

- Critical Thinking Application Teaching higher order thinking skills is not a recent need. It is apparent that students, at all levels of education, are lagging in problem-solving and thinking skills. Fragmentation of thinking skills, however, may be the result of critical thinking courses and texts. Every course, especially in content subjects, students should be taught to think logically, analyze and compare, question and evaluate. Implications for Teaching Thinking must be practiced in each content field at each educational level....   [tags: Education Critical Thinking Analysis]

Better Essays
1046 words (3 pages)