Critical Analysis of Peter Knight's Arguement on Secret Societies Essays

Critical Analysis of Peter Knight's Arguement on Secret Societies Essays

Length: 920 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Peter Knight is a senior lecturer in literature for the University of Manchester. Before his employment at Manchester he was a Postdoctoral Fellow at Nottingham University, as well as a Fulbright visiting fellow at the New York University, a study abroad fellow at Harvard. Dr. Knight has authored two books; “The Kennedy Assassination” and “Conspiracy Conspiracy Culture – American Paranoia from the Kennedy Assassination”. He has also edited, contributed to multiple books and journal articles. In his article “Trained as Traitors, Liars and Slavemasters!” that he authored for the “Freedom Networker he presents an argument that member of secret societies are all part of a plan to create a “New World Order”. Knight authored this article for the “Freedom Networker” which is a right winged, conspiracy minded, militia publication. (Knight). Because of the historical nature of this subject Knight was not able to effectively implement the Toulmins Model of Argumentation. The Toulmins Model asserts that most arguments contain six parts: 1.) Claims, 2.) Data/Grounds, 3.) Warrants, 4.) Backing, 5.) Qualifiers, and 6.) Rebuttals. (The Toulmin Model of Argumentation.).
Knight argues that there are over one million among us that he claims are trained to be traitors against freedom itself. He proceeds to tell his audience of his claims that these elite members of these secret societies are all intertwined and are working towards a common goal of a “New World Order”. Knight lists societies such as “Skull and Bones”, “The Knight Templars”, “Knights of Malta” ,”Order of the Eastern Star”, and “ the Council of Foreign Relations” but in the end chooses to only concentrate on the “Freemasons” and their roles in “The New World Order”. (Knight).

... middle of paper ...

...te fashion, as if the author believed that the words that he penned did not need any qualification. Knight believes that these secret society members are in all areas of the government and foundation of society and how the article is written makes it interpreted by its readers as an unqualified assentation that assumes that there will not be any argument given about the allegation that is being made.
In conclusion this article came off as a matter a fact argument that the author did not expect to receive any rebuttals on from his readers. It was written for a right winged, conspiracy minded, militia publication where the author assumed the readers would be like minded and would agree with his argument that all secret societies are out to set up a “New World Order” where the little man will be made slaves to the government and to those who have power and wealth.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Peter Singer Arguement That We are Speciesist Essay examples

- ... The examples he provides to substantiate this theory range from accounts of animal brutality during processing into flesh for consumption to sheer cruelty exhibited towards animals in their roles as the subjects of various experiments. While Singer reports a wide array of accounts of horrifying bestiality exhibited by the human experimenters on their animal subjects, the true inhumanity of the situation is revealed by some recent studies finding that “more than thirty years of animal experimentation have been a waste of time…quite apart from the immense amount of acute physical pain that they have caused” (Singer, Animal Liberation, p....   [tags: humans, cruelty, animals]

Better Essays
1138 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Peter Abelard ( 1079-1142 )

- The second half of the twelfth century, also known as the Middle Ages, was a time new schools, churches, and monasteries flourished, growing rapidly. A new learning style lead to the rise of the university. Since the Carolingian period in the fourth century, schools had been connected to cathedrals and monasteries. They served as an area monks and priests were trained whether by book or master. Masters were men who taught to a group of eager students that gathered around them thirsty for their knowledge....   [tags: Education, Philosophy, Critical thinking, Master]

Better Essays
882 words (2.5 pages)

Argument, Critical Thinking And Rationality Essay

- It would be accurate to suggest that Taha Muhammad Ali expresses an idea in poetry that Joseph Williams and Greg Colomb express in form in “Argument, Critical Thinking and Rationality”. In Williams and Colomb Essay (2012) they explain how arguments help us to critically think, arguments allow us to stop and think about what we want to say or what action we want to take. To persuade someone to accept what we are saying or the action we are going to take we can provide facts (p.117). In Taha Muhammad Ali’s poem Revenge Ali is in a way arguing with himself and persuading himself on what action he should take....   [tags: Critical thinking, Thought, Muhammad Ali, Human]

Better Essays
1176 words (3.4 pages)

Lord Gawain And The Green Knight Essays

- In Gordon M. Shedd’s “Knight in Tarnished Armour: The Meaning of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight”, he argues that Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is truly about the strength and weaknesses of human nature. One particularly interesting part of his argument asserts that Gawain’s humanity broke medieval romance tradition. Shedd’s central argument is that Sir Gawain’s true conflict is internal; it is with the duality of his own humanity. He starts by explaining that “man stands midway between the angels and the animals, partaking of both natures” (Shedd 245)....   [tags: Sir Gawain and the Green Knight]

Better Essays
745 words (2.1 pages)

Critical Review of Peter Dickens' Global Shift: Mapping The Changing Contours of the World Economy

- Critical Review of Peter Dickens' Global Shift: Mapping The Changing Contours of the World Economy When the term “Globalization” is discussed, most academics, scholars, professionals and intellectuals attempt to define and interpret it in a summarized fashion. My main concern with this approach is that one cannot and should not define a process that altered decades of history and continues to, in less than 30 words. Global Shift is a book with remarkable insight. Peter Dicken rather than attempting to define the commonly misused word, explains Globalization in a clear and logical fashion, which interconnects numerous views....   [tags: Peter Dickens Global Shift Analysis Review]

Free Essays
1167 words (3.3 pages)

Lady Bertilak And The Green Knight Essay

- While To His Coy Mistress and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight share very little in the way of genre and structure, the theme of seduction plays a prominent role in each poem. But in neither Marvell 's work nor the work of the anonymous Gawain poet is traditional, successful romance to be found; both seducers find themselves spurned, one in the name of knightly "chastity," the other under the guise of ladylike "coyness." Lady Bertilak and Marvell 's unnamed narrator do not pander and defer to their desired partners-- rather, the tactics employed in the two poems are negotiation and intimidation, the use of leverage and pressure....   [tags: Sir Gawain and the Green Knight]

Better Essays
1062 words (3 pages)

Essay on Seven Components Of Critical Thinking

- Seven Components of Critical Thinking By Timothy F Bednarz | Submitted On October 08, 2012 Recommend Article Article Comments Print Article Share this article on Facebook Share this article on Twitter Share this article on Google+ Share this article on Linkedin Share this article on StumbleUpon Share this article on Delicious Share this article on Digg Share this article on Reddit Share this article on Pinterest Expert Author Timothy F Bednarz Critical thinking is a powerful process if understood and applied effectively....   [tags: Logic, Critical thinking, Reasoning, Argument]

Better Essays
908 words (2.6 pages)

Passion in Peter Shaffer's Equus Essay

- In Peter Shaffer's Equus, A psychiatrist, Martin Dysart, is conducting an investigation on Alan Strang. He is learning, through his investigation of Alan's horrific crime, about what it really means to make someone "normal" and what a psychiatrist really does. It is the job of Dysart to find the motive of Alan's actions, but he is not prepared for what he learns. After meeting Alan, Dysart has a dream. This dream is of a ritual sacrifice in Greece. Dysart's passion lies in Greece. He has always wanted to believe in something greater than himself....   [tags: Peter Shaffer, Equus]

Better Essays
2286 words (6.5 pages)

Essay on Love and Prowess in The Knight with the Lion

- Love and Prowess in The Knight with the Lion        The chivalric ideal demanded many things of a knight. To the military ideals of prowess, loyalty, and honor it added the aristocratic ideal of largesse and, with the rise of the troubadour lyrics and romances, the ideal of courtly love. At times a knight could find these demands in conflict with one another. Such is the case with Chrétien de Troyes's romance The Knight with the Lion. In this story, the hero Yvain finds love while pursuing prowess; but, continuing to pursue prowess, he loses that love....   [tags: Knight with the Lion Essays]

Better Essays
3493 words (10 pages)

Creating Other Worlds in Fly Away Peter Essay

- Creating Other Worlds in Fly Away Peter         In the novel Fly Away Peter, David Malouf explores the individual’s ability to transcend the immediate, and create ‘other worlds’ of his or her own: "Meanwhile the Mind, from pleasure less, Withdraws into happiness: creates,... Far other worlds..." Malouf uses the continuity of life to highlight the importance of the individual’s mind set against the meaning of human existence. Malouf’s three main characters, Jim Saddler, Ashley Crowther and Imogen Harcourt, are used to present Malouf’s themes in a unique and sensitive manner....   [tags: Peter]

Better Essays
1687 words (4.8 pages)