Critical Analysis of Peter Coclanis’ Article: Atlantic World or Atlantic/World?

Critical Analysis of Peter Coclanis’ Article: Atlantic World or Atlantic/World?

Length: 1576 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

“The Atlantic World was a world Europeans, Africans, and Americans “made together” –together with peoples from without.” Such is the belief of Peter Coclanis, Albert R. Newsome Professor of History and Economics and Associate Provost for International Affairs at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. In his paper: Atlantic World or Atlantic/World? published in the William and Mary Quarterly in 2006, Coclanis argues that the study of Atlantic history is too narrow. He writes in this paper that there is no context in which the Atlantic world can be completely separated from the interactions with the rest of the world. The argument Coclanis believes if one is to study Atlantic history of the early modern period (circa 1500-1800 CE) one needs to focus more on other areas, such as the countries outside the Atlantic or their trading circuits in order to fully understand the history of the Atlantic. This idea that Atlantic historians need to change their focus is contradictory to what Atlantic history is. If Atlantic historians shifted their focus to include countries not connected to the Atlantic, can it still be called Atlantic history or if one was to believe what Coclanis suggests: should historians even focus on the Atlantic world at all?
Coclanis is writing in response to his article published four years earlier entitled: Drang Nach Osten: Bernard Bailyn, the World-Island, and the Idea of Atlantic History. He writes because he believes that now he is “a bit better informed” in that his critique has become “bit more nuanced and sophisticated.” Coclanis reveals his feeling toward the study of Atlantic history by being underwhelmed and unconvinced about the arguments made the historians. He states that the “scholarshi...


... middle of paper ...


...lude outer-Atlantic areas as well. This idea is contradictory to what Atlantic historians, and arguably historians in general study. The focus of any history is to understand developments which took place in the Atlantic. To include other areas outside of the Atlantic does nothing to improve Atlantic history. In effect it does quite the opposite; it becomes world history removing the importance of the Atlantic from Atlantic history. What Coclanis argues is that for one to fully understand a history of the Atlantic one must understand what is happening simultaneously across the globe.



Works Cited

Coclanis, Peter A.. “Atlantic World or Atlantic/World?” The William and Mary Quarterly 63.4 (2006): 725-742.

Coclanis, Peter A.. “Drang Nach Osten: Bernard Bailyn, the World-Island, and the Idea of Atlantic History” Journal of World History 13.1 (2002): 169-182.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Atlantic World

- While micro histories focus on exposing larger patterns with case studies of specific individuals or regions, Atlantic history looks to connect one region to another through the movement of people, goods and ideas. Using the Reynier’s as a lens Fogleman examines four central and possibly universal structures of the Atlantic world. The difficulties of travel and displacement experienced by immigrants in the Atlantic, interactions with slave and Native American cultures and the resistance and the role of resistance in cross cultural exchange, and finally, the place of Protestant religious ideals in a world with such diverse ethnicities and belief systems....   [tags: Africa, Slavery, Atlantic slave trade, Europe]

Powerful Essays
784 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about Slavery Of The Atlantic World

- Slavery in the atlantic world become associated with Africans because the demand for strong African slaves to work on sugar plantations. Slavery was already a traditional part of the African society so trading with the Europeans was not a new concept. During the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, plantation became a profitable investment. Sugar cane was booming cash crop. The demand for sugar grew, the Europeans fell in love with the taste of sugar. They came up with new ways to use sugar as sweetener and making rum....   [tags: Atlantic slave trade, Slavery, Caribbean]

Powerful Essays
767 words (2.2 pages)

The Atlantic World Economic System Essay

- To a large extent the Atlantic World economic system was fundamental in causing or at least accelerating the British Industrial Revolution. However, there were other elements that contributed to the Atlantic World economic system’s success. The Industrial Revolution was a time of great economic prosperity and technological advancement in Europe. Between 1550 and 1850, Britain made a shift from a mainly agrarian subsistent economy to an urbanised, large-scale mechanised manufacturing one. The Atlantic World economic system is a term used by Joseph Inikori to explain the triangular trade between Western Europe, Western Africa and the Americas through the Atlantic Ocean....   [tags: Atlantic slave trade, Slavery, United Kingdom]

Powerful Essays
731 words (2.1 pages)

Essay The Power Of An Atlantic World And The Imperial Slave Economy

- My arguments, observations and opinions over chapter 3 are very strong. During the period of the British Atlantic World many events in the American history had occurred. It is disappointing to know that the British Atlantic world was made by migration on both sides of the ocean. This chapter demonstrates the power of an Atlantic World and the Imperial Slave Economy. Chapter 3 was full of interesting and useful topics. This chapter helped me understand that the Imperial Slave Economy was inhuman....   [tags: Atlantic slave trade, Slavery, Caribbean, Africa]

Powerful Essays
973 words (2.8 pages)

Critical Review of Peter Dickens' Global Shift: Mapping The Changing Contours of the World Economy

- Critical Review of Peter Dickens' Global Shift: Mapping The Changing Contours of the World Economy When the term “Globalization” is discussed, most academics, scholars, professionals and intellectuals attempt to define and interpret it in a summarized fashion. My main concern with this approach is that one cannot and should not define a process that altered decades of history and continues to, in less than 30 words. Global Shift is a book with remarkable insight. Peter Dicken rather than attempting to define the commonly misused word, explains Globalization in a clear and logical fashion, which interconnects numerous views....   [tags: Peter Dickens Global Shift Analysis Review]

Free Essays
1167 words (3.3 pages)

Analysis Of Fogleman 's Research On The Early American And Atlantic World

- Microhistory Fogleman’s research focuses on the Early American and Atlantic World, from 1492 to 1867. He is a major historian on the study of Moravian Church in America. Before Two Troubled Souls, Fogelman has written two books on the German immigration in North American and Moravians respectively . Fogelman’s language skill(he can read both German and Dutch ) enables him to tap into sources in archives on both sides of the Atlantic. Building on his previous two books, Fogleman is able to write this compelling work on the transatlantic journey of a spiritual couple....   [tags: Atlantic Ocean, Africa, Slavery, Transatlantic]

Powerful Essays
885 words (2.5 pages)

The Atlantic World And The Pacific World Essay

- The Atlantic world came together of four continents (North America, South America, Europe, and Africa) in the mid fifteenth and sixteenth centauries. The Atlantic world had different main jobs with its construction, such as creation, encounters, trade, immigration, and revolution. The creation of the Atlantic began with in the fifteenth century with navigators that shipped across the ocean. Later, navigators and people constantly crossing the ocean to explore the Atlantic it developed a route of highways taking people to different parts of the world....   [tags: Slavery, United States, Africa, British Empire]

Powerful Essays
996 words (2.8 pages)

The Atlantic Trade Essay

- The Triumphs and Tribulations of the Development of the Atlantic Trade The inception and continuance of the Atlantic trade marked the most principal aspect of the Age of Exploration that helped create the world and society of the present day. Vastly spanning from the ports of London to the coastlines of West Africa and Brazil, the Atlantic trade route created trading relationships that still has an impact on how countries today trade. The devolvement of the Atlantic trade forever changed and impacted each area under its realm of influence....   [tags: Africa, West Africa, Atlantic slave trade, Slavery]

Powerful Essays
1225 words (3.5 pages)

Creating Other Worlds in Fly Away Peter Essay

- Creating Other Worlds in Fly Away Peter         In the novel Fly Away Peter, David Malouf explores the individual’s ability to transcend the immediate, and create ‘other worlds’ of his or her own: "Meanwhile the Mind, from pleasure less, Withdraws into happiness: ...it creates,... Far other worlds..." Malouf uses the continuity of life to highlight the importance of the individual’s mind set against the meaning of human existence. Malouf’s three main characters, Jim Saddler, Ashley Crowther and Imogen Harcourt, are used to present Malouf’s themes in a unique and sensitive manner....   [tags: Peter]

Powerful Essays
1687 words (4.8 pages)

Passion in Peter Shaffer's Equus Essay

- In Peter Shaffer's Equus, A psychiatrist, Martin Dysart, is conducting an investigation on Alan Strang. He is learning, through his investigation of Alan's horrific crime, about what it really means to make someone "normal" and what a psychiatrist really does. It is the job of Dysart to find the motive of Alan's actions, but he is not prepared for what he learns. After meeting Alan, Dysart has a dream. This dream is of a ritual sacrifice in Greece. Dysart's passion lies in Greece. He has always wanted to believe in something greater than himself....   [tags: Peter Shaffer, Equus]

Powerful Essays
2286 words (6.5 pages)