Critical Analysis of "Historiography in the Twentieth Century" by Georg G. Iggers

Critical Analysis of "Historiography in the Twentieth Century" by Georg G. Iggers

Length: 1705 words (4.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Historiography in the Twentieth Century: From Scientific Objectivity to the Postmodern Challenge, a book written by Georg G. Iggers, explores the transformation of modern trends throughout history using the influence of social science. Iggers combines his studies of German and American customs defined by social history to bring us in-depth highlights of pertinent information.
Iggers opens the book by talking about a revolutionary way that the Western world was taught about history. Throughout the book he ascertains the changes that take place throughout historiography and the nature of history itself. He also examines prior historical notions and the way that historiography was altered after World War II. History morphed from previous antiquarian teachings into a deeper, more evaluated approach. Historians gained a more intimate relationship with postmodern ideas and began looking at history in an objective manner using contemporary discipline. Iggers studies the way postmodernism was changed by new social sciences which allowed more detail into cultural influences and the problems surrounding globalization theories. He also explains the birth of microhistory which replaced macrohistory.
We are introduced to historical work done by North America, Germany, Great Britain, Belgium, Italy, France, Central Europe, and some minor reference to Poland and Russia. The three main divisions of the text are a gamut of information about the late 19th and early 20th century. It is during this time that Iggers talks about Leopold Ranke and the influence of his brilliant ideas. “It was Ranke's aim to turn history into a rigorous science practiced by professionally trained historians” (Iggers, 2005). Ranke initially introduced the ...


... middle of paper ...


...ry approach that Iggers produces in his book, mentioning important influences of both macrohistory and microhistory but I do not agree with his biased approach without further analytical detail in order to back up his arguments. I also agree that Iggers does provide an easy to read introduction to historiography for beginners or undergraduate students. Overall, his combination of intense studies and supreme understanding of historiography on a modern level makes Historiography in the Twentieth Century: From Scientific Objectivity to the Postmodern Challenge an enjoyable read that is highly enlightening for students and teachers or anyone interested in a quick background of modern social history.

Works Cited
Iggers, G. G. (1997). Historiography in the twentieth century: from scientific objectivity to the postmodern challenge. Middletown: Wesleyan University Press.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

American Literature of the Twentieth Century Essay

- The country as it was in the early part of the twentieth century was shaped toward regenerating and recovering from World War I, the Great Depression, and a lot of other socially-crippling disruptions that were forever altering the United States in a lot of different ways. Some of the changes were good, and others were not so good. The spirit of loyalty and patriotism were alive and thriving in the air and in everyone's hearts, and the literature of that time greatly reflects the influence that this surge of patriotism brought upon the American peoples....   [tags: 20th century twentieth literature]

Powerful Essays
1371 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on The Twentieth Century: Medical Advances

- A gradual evolution in medical advances has occurred throughout history. Illness and disease were of a mystical nature or considered divine penance in our early history as in the times of the early Babylonians. The Ebers Papyrus, which were dated approximately 1500 B.C.E. although focused on empirical medicine also provided for magical elements. The managed health care of today is not a modern development but actually one that had its early beginning within the Code of Hammaurabi thousands of years ago....   [tags: modern medicine, bioethics, Hippocrates]

Powerful Essays
3033 words (8.7 pages)

Twentieth Century Evolves to the Twentieth First Essay

- ... Kolff around the 1950's (Anderson, 2007). In relation to HIV/ AIDS, antiretroviral treatment is still being used as an effective measure to treat the disease. Antiretroviral therapy is being used in several ways to prevent the spread of HIV, to prevent mother to child transmission, post exposure prophylaxis, as well as pre-exposure prophylaxis(Avert, n.d.). With HIV being a major global epidemic, we are still seeing high numbers and new cases arise every year. In the twentieth century the syndrome was the most famous epidemic and still is considered to be so today with many people dying from the disease....   [tags: Teachnology, machines, healthcare]

Free Essays
738 words (2.1 pages)

The First Progressive President Of The Twentieth Century Essay

- Beginning with the birth of the twentieth century, the United States was in a dilemma. America needed amelioration; the country had a tremendous amount of potential but was unable to put forth the necessary actions without the correct guidance. It was vital that the United States was pointed in the right direction or more problems would occur. America required political reform and the elimination of corruption caused by the government, thus, the time prevailed for the Progressive Presidents. The first progressive president was Republican Theodore Roosevelt....   [tags: Theodore Roosevelt, Woodrow Wilson]

Powerful Essays
1211 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The Modernism Of The Twentieth Century

- The categorization of architecture in the twentieth century has been an ongoing process that relies, to a certain extent, on the subjective input of the classifier. Post-modernism in particular has only one definite classification; it is the movement of architecture that emerged following the Modernism of Europe and the International Style of the world. This literal definition is not only an implication of its chronological order in architectural history, but the notion of post-modernism itself depicts the twentieth century movement as a complete rejection of Modernist architecture....   [tags: Modernism, Postmodernism, International style]

Powerful Essays
1460 words (4.2 pages)

Dance In The Early Twentieth Century Essay

- The history of Jazz music is one that is tied to enslavement, and prejudices, and it is impossible to separate the development of Jazz music from the racial oppression that occurred in the United States as they are inextricably connected. Slavery was a part of our country’s development that is shameful and yet, lead to some of the greatest musical advances of the twentieth century. Slavery in the United States first began in 1619 when Dutch traders seized a Spanish slave ship and brought those aboard to the North American colony of Jamestown, Virginia....   [tags: history of jazz]

Powerful Essays
1481 words (4.2 pages)

The World Of The Twentieth Century Essay example

- The world of the twenty-first century is drastically different from what it was back in the twentieth century. The twentieth century dealt with two World Wars and a Cold War. That century had to navigate and strengthen its militaries in order to progress on the world stage. That much has not changed for either Bush or Obama. Weapons are being produced at a higher rate as more and more countries are becoming more industrialized. It is not just world enveloped by better and better weapons being mass produced, but there is the question of Biological weapons meaning communicable diseases, religious wars, terrorism, the rising poverty numbers in the United States of America and abroad, and educa...   [tags: United States, President of the United States]

Powerful Essays
2026 words (5.8 pages)

Russia During The Twentieth Century Essay

- The studies of Russia during the twentieth-century have been engulfed by a cloud mysticism and intrigue, since it has been characterised by intensely politicised agendas, creating a vast array of division within its history. Conflicts of interests arise on the approaches in regard to twentieth century Russia were a traditionalist approach along the lines of the totalitarian school emerges in opposition to the revisionist as well as the liberal modernist 's style. These debates have existed since the initial birth of the revolution, in terms of it being seen as a coup or just form of natural progressive redevelopment....   [tags: Soviet Union, Communism, Russia, Vladimir Lenin]

Powerful Essays
1416 words (4 pages)

Utopia for the Twentieth Century Essay

- Utopia for the Twentieth Century There are many utopias. No one has ever seen them except in imagination, and yet they are real enough, for they have influenced our destiny over the centuries. ----- Alain Martineau The socio-political philosophy of Marx and Engels emphasizes both the capacity as well as the inevitability of oppressed peoples to take up arms in a desperate effort to do away with conditions which do not correspond to their true material and psychological needs. This is the process by which the fulfillment of Marx's species-being may eventually become a reality --- a struggle which will annihilate those circumstances which produce a great deal of misery, ending them through...   [tags: Philosophy Marxism Essays]

Free Essays
4913 words (14 pages)

Italy in the Twentieth Century Essay

- Italy in the Twentieth Century Only thirty years after the Piedmontese army marched into Rome to unite Italy under one government, the country suddenly found itself on the brink of the twentieth century and a rapidly changing world. The twentieth century would mark the beginning of great changes throughout Europe, and Italy would not be left untouched. What set the stage for these changes, though, were the years just prior to, and directly after 1900. The decade before 1900 can be thought of in terms of its government leaders, most notably, Francesco Crispi....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
590 words (1.7 pages)