Critical Analysis Of George Orwell 's ' The Capitol ' And ' Fire ' Essay

Critical Analysis Of George Orwell 's ' The Capitol ' And ' Fire ' Essay

Length: 1721 words (4.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

For the characters within Nineteen Eighty Four and Catching Fire, Orwell and Collins use devices such as symbolism, imagery and language techniques to reflect how the characters are controlled within their dystopian societies by their totalitarian governments. The characterisations within the novels either reinforce this control or oppose it and push the boundaries. Although I agree that Winston and Julia are ultimately controlled mentally and physically by their totalitarian government, I believe that the character of Katniss is only restricted physically by her totalitarian government, yet, Collins ' characterisation of Katniss enables her character to loosen the "iron grip" of the "Capitol 's" physical control.
One way that Collins shows physical control in Catching Fire is through setting. Collins uses the setting of the arena where the tributes are required to fight to the death to show how physically controlled Katniss is within the novel by the totalitarian government of Panem. Collins places the character of Katniss inside an arena in the shape of a ring: "the force field has us trapped in a circle. A dome really". The circular shaped arena can arguably be a reflection of the governments control as the shape of a circle gives connotations of boundaries and enclosure. It can be argued that Collins ' idea of the "force field" around the perimeter of the arena emphasises the fact that the characters are physically controlled, although I believe that Collins ' use of the word "force" also reflects the nature of the totalitarian government known as the "Capitol" as being a strong "force" and a barrier that is very difficult to penetrate, controlling the character of Katniss. Collins also portrays the totalitarian governmen...


... middle of paper ...


...im]". I believe that this mind-set shows how the party still had an influence on the character of Winston during his short lived rebellion and therefore have a degree of control over him, as Winston kept the mind-set that "the individual is always defeated", a mind-set that Julia “could not accept” something that O 'Brien later in the novel proves to be true.
So, due to Orwell 's uses of language, narrative and structure, he shows that the characters of Winston and Julia are both physically and mentally controlled by their totalitarian governments, regardless of their efforts to be free from such control. On the other hand, Collins also shows that the character of Katniss is not mentally controlled but is physically controlled by the totalitarian government in Catching Fire however; the characterisation of the "girl on fire" begins to strongly oppose this control.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Critical Analysis Of George Orwell 's ' The Novel ' Essay

- Critical Analysis In the novel you will see that everybody in the whole society is watched and have no privacy of any kind. Every person is under surveillance. This makes people frustrated to live a free and individual life, but it seems to be an impossible task towards surveillance, self thought, and reality. Here we can observe the effects it portrays in today 's society and ways it also acts as a warning for the future. In 1984 a man named Winston lives in a world covered in cameras. He is under surveillance twenty/four seven....   [tags: Nineteen Eighty-Four, George Orwell, Newspeak]

Better Essays
740 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Critical Analysis of Shooting an Elephant by George Orwell

- Critical Analysis of Shooting an Elephant by George Orwell "Shooting an Elephant" is perhaps one of the most anthologized essays in the English language. It is a splendid essay and a terrific model for a theme of narration. The point of the story happens very much in our normal life, in fact everyday. People do crazy and sometimes illegal moves to get a certain group or person to finally give them respect. George Orwell describes an internal conflict between his personal morals and his duty to his country to the white man's reputation....   [tags: Shooting an Elephant George Orwell Essays]

Better Essays
848 words (2.4 pages)

Animal Farm By George Orwell Essay example

- Even those with the best of intentions can become corrupt when given power, as George Orwell so descriptively portrays in his allegorical novella Animal Farm. Animal Farm tells the story of a group of animals who, after living for years under the merciless rule of a drunk, careless farmer, one day rise up in rebellion. After driving the humans off their farm, the animals are left to create their own self-governed society. Based on the ideals of Communism, the animals’ gubernatorial structure at first seems appealing, promoting equality and a determination to create an independent, animal-only society....   [tags: Animal Farm, Leon Trotsky, George Orwell]

Better Essays
1308 words (3.7 pages)

George Orwell 's Animal Farm Essay

- Despite the United Kingdom’s alliance with the Soviet Union George Orwell, the author of Animal Farm despised Stalin; he felt that Stalin was an oppressive power in Russia, forcing his people through trials and tribulation that were completely unnecessary. Many of his constituents starved and faced exactly what he promised would not happen under his communist policy. George Orwell being a democratic socialist felt hostility towards Stalin’s greedy policy. Seeing its effect on his homeland, he was out raged and motivated to write the novel Animal Farm to properly criticize the Soviet Union....   [tags: Communism, Soviet Union, George Orwell]

Better Essays
1324 words (3.8 pages)

Animal Farm by George Orwell Essay

- Animal Farm Book Review Summary Animal Farm is a novel by George Orwell. It is an allegory in which animals play the roles of Russian revolutionists, and overthrow the human owners of the farm. Once the farm has been taken over by the animals, they are all equal at first, but class and status soon separates the different animal species. This story describes how a society’s ideologies can be manipulated by those in political power, to cause corruption by those in leadership. Plot The story begins with old major, a boar, who tells the animals of manor farm, his dream of freedom and life without humans....   [tags: George Orwell]

Better Essays
906 words (2.6 pages)

Animal Farm by George Orwell Essays

- Animal Farm by George Orwell The story of Animal Farm takes place in a farmhouse, somewhere in England. The farm animals are property of the "cruel" and "evil" farmer Mr. Jones. Old Major, a wise pig, and one of the oldest animals on the farm, calls for a secret meeting to take place later at night. At the meeting, Old Major tells the animals about a dream he recently had. In his dream, he sees a revolution taking place against Mr. Jones, and the freedom of all animals. Old Major points out to the animals that the cause of their miserable existences is the tyranny of man, who is a lazy, useless creature who steals the fruits of the animals for his own advantage....   [tags: George Orwell]

Better Essays
1890 words (5.4 pages)

George Orwell's Shooting an Elephant Essay

- George Orwell's "Shooting an Elephant" In 'Shooting an Elephant,' George Orwell finds himself in a difficult situation involving an elephant. The fate of the elephant lies in his hands. Only he can make the final decision. In the end, due to Orwell's decision, the elephant lay dying in a pool of blood. Orwell wins the sympathy of readers by expressing the pressure he feels as an Anglo-Indian in Burma, struggling with his morals, and showing a sense of compassion for the dying animal. Readers sympathize with Orwell because they can relate to his emotions in the moments before the shooting....   [tags: George Orwell Shooting Elephant]

Better Essays
792 words (2.3 pages)

Biography: George Orwell Essay

- George Orwell was the pen name of British author Eric Arthur Blair, born on June 25, 1903 in Motihari, India where his father, Richard Walmesley worked as a civil servant for the British Empire. Orwell's mother, Ida Mabel Blair, moved him and his sister Marjorie to England a year later as that they could be brought up in a more traditional Christian environment. Orwell went to prep schools and went on to Eton College. Orwell went to prep schools and went on to Eton College from 1917 to 1921. He began to write and publish some work in college periodicals....   [tags: George Orwell Author Biography Eric Blair]

Better Essays
955 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on George Orwell's 1984

- George Orwell's 1984 What look on humanity and human nature, if any, can be seen through this book, 1984. 1984 examines a future under the rule of a totalitarian society. One of the unique notes about Orwell's 1984, is the views that Orwell presents on humanity, and human nature....   [tags: George Orwell 1984]

Better Essays
707 words (2 pages)

Essay about George Orwell's 1984

- George Orwell's 1984 “No one is free, even the birds are chained to the sky.” This quote is not from 1984 but it may as well could be. Bob Dylan said this probably not knowing the connection it has with George Orwell’s 1984. 1984 depicts a dystopian world in which the civilians are watched and brainwashed constantly. There is no conventional freedom, there is no real individual in this world, there is a sense of coldness in 1984. The main character Winston is trying to figure out his past and what is real and what is propaganda in this world....   [tags: 1984 George Orwell]

Better Essays
1032 words (2.9 pages)