Criminal Procedure Essay

Criminal Procedure Essay

Length: 1407 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The due process and crime control models, both created by Stanford University law professor Herbert Packer, represents two opposing method of principles functioning within criminal justice system. Although the models describe the important facets of the politics and practice of criminal justice, both have been criticized since presented by Packer in 1964. Presently both models are acknowledged as imperfect standards to explain the politics and law of criminal justice. The crime control ideal represents traditional principles, whereas the due process belief reflects moderate values; therefore generating conflict evident throughout the years. This paper discusses models, crime control and due process, and how each affects the criminal procedure; as well be an inclusion of the review and assessment of several amendments and how each applies to both models.
Contrast between crime control and due process models
The crime control model incorporates upholding principles that demonstrate the traditional values of the criminal justice system. Supporters of this model believe criminal justice should center on maintaining victims’ rights instead of protecting the rights of defendants. The suppression of crime, an imperative task of criminal justice, is a vital provision for a liberated society. According to this model establishing the true culpability of the accused or ascertaining the truth is an essential point of the criminal justice process. Cases validated by this model proceed very quickly according to disposition and are controlled by law enforcement and prosecutors. The end result is the plea of guilt.
The due process model incorporates modernized principles of the criminal justice system. Supporters of this model believe the c...


... middle of paper ...


...ce remains obligatory for American citizens. A hasty assessment would show that the two models signify common and unfailing principles. On the contrary, both models in general differ from one another.



Works Cited

Packer, Herbert L. Two Models of the Criminal Process. Stanford UP, 1968. Retrieved June 16, 2010 from www.hhs.csus.edu/.../Packer%20-%20Two%20Models%20of%20the%20Criminal%
Roach, Kent. "Four Models of the Criminal Process." Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology 89.2 (Winter 99): 671
Sociology Index. (2010). Crime Control Model. Retrieved June 17, 2010 from http://sociologyindex.com/crime_control_model.htm
Sociology Index. (2010). Due Process Model. Retrieved June 17, 2010 from http://sociologyindex.com/crime_control_model.htm
Zalman, Marvin. Criminal Procedure: Constitution and Society. 5th ed. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson Education, 2008.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Criminal Procedure Essay

- The due process and crime control models, both created by Stanford University law professor Herbert Packer, represents two opposing method of principles functioning within criminal justice system. Although the models describe the important facets of the politics and practice of criminal justice, both have been criticized since presented by Packer in 1964. Presently both models are acknowledged as imperfect standards to explain the politics and law of criminal justice. The crime control ideal represents traditional principles, whereas the due process belief reflects moderate values; therefore generating conflict evident throughout the years....   [tags: Criminal Justice ]

Powerful Essays
1407 words (4 pages)

Essay about The War on Drugs and Criminal Procedure

- The criminal procedure has many aspects that can protect people’s rights from illegal practices of the law. Just to name a few of the aspects of the criminal procedures; the fourth amendment states that a citizen is secure in their home and property from unreasonable search and seizure. Another aspect and the aspect that I will be talking about in this paper is the exclusionary rule. The exclusionary rule bans introduction of “good” evidence obtained by “bad” law enforcement. This basically means that evidence that could be used that would otherwise determine that the defendant was/is guilty is inadmissible due to bad police conduct....   [tags: exlcusionary, rule, evidence, enforcement]

Powerful Essays
524 words (1.5 pages)

The Fourth Amendment in Criminal Procedure Essay

- ... The search happened because of the arrest warrant not because of the illegal traffic stop. If Frierson had been pulled over and not had an arrest warrant for him then the search would have never happened and he would have left with no issue. However since he did have an arrest warrant on file and it had to be served upon discovery and the gun was then found because of a search incident to arrest as mentioned above. Another example a lot that was use to help make the ruling more sound was that police will often canvas high crime neighborhoods and ask random people for their I.D....   [tags: right to privacy]

Powerful Essays
1504 words (4.3 pages)

Civil Procedure Vs. Criminal Procedure Essay

- Civil Procedure VS. Criminal Procedure: The Breakdown The Civil procedure begins when a person, or persons, feels like they were wronged by another person and seeks an attorney in hopes to resolve the underlying issues between them. This is not the case for criminal procedures. In civil procedures, the attorney and the staff would interview witnesses, perform legal research and then decide if the client has a legitimate reason for litigation. If the attorney does decide that the client has a legitimate cause for action, the attorney and client will then begin the attorney-client relationship starting with a retainer agreement....   [tags: Jury, Supreme Court of the United States]

Powerful Essays
978 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about History Of The Chinese Criminal Procedure Law

- Chapter Three – History of the Chinese Criminal Procedure Law Section 1 – The Chinese Criminal Procedure Law before 1996 3-1-1 The Chinese Criminal Procedure Law before 1979 Along with its historical evolution of its economic, politic and social systems, the Chinese judicial system has been gradually developing. For hundreds of years Chinese judicial system has been proliferating by adopting legal doctrines from other countries however, today the Chinese judicial system as a whole is the result of a rich Chinese history and practical experience....   [tags: Law, Common law, Civil law]

Powerful Essays
1803 words (5.2 pages)

Essay about Legal Counsel Before The 1996 Chinese Criminal Procedure Law

- Section 2 – The right to legal counsel before 2012 6-2-1 The right to legal counsel before the 1996 Chinese Criminal Procedure Law “Except in special circumstances as specified by law, all cases in the people’s courts are heard in public. The accused has right to defense”, article 125 of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of China. The Chinese Constitution expressly provides the right of defense of an individual. However, in this sentence it is not clear whether the individual has a right to defense during pre-trial proceedings....   [tags: Law, Criminal law, Lawyer, Human rights]

Powerful Essays
1317 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on The Plea Bargain

- The plea bargain, a familiar term to most Americans. It is a procedure that for many years I associated with offering flexibility and rights citizens guilty of crimes. I thought of it as a way to implement justice with compassion. My opinion changed after seeing the impact of a plea bargain on the victims family member, who is a close friend of mine. This opinion was further solidified with watching the YouTube video, Ritter plea bargain. With research I continue to find prejudice, racism, injustice, and the unconstitutional implementation of plea bargains....   [tags: criminal case, criminal procedure]

Powerful Essays
1318 words (3.8 pages)

Calendar Calls : The Court Hearing Essay

- Calendar Calls can be very lengthy depending on how many people are on the Calendar. It was also interesting to see how the different judges handled the nonjury criminal proceedings. Some judges take the defendant’s guilty pleas unanimously by having them stand up and answer the questions together out loud. In that series of questions, they are asked to state their age and highest level of education completed. I found it ironic that many individuals have either dropped out of school or have earned a GED, which shows the correlation between education level and the probability of committing a crime....   [tags: Crime, Trial, Jury, Criminal procedure]

Powerful Essays
1346 words (3.8 pages)

Procedures in the Criminal Justice System Essay

- “The criminal process is part of the State’s response to crime, part of the mechanism which the State applies substantive criminal law to its citizens”. (Ashworth & Redmayne, 2005, p.2) Within this essay, I will be looking at the procedures in the Criminal Justice System. Before laying the foundations of this work, I will briefly dedicate a few lines on what the Criminal Justice System is about. A Criminal Justice System is a set of legal and social establishments for carrying out the criminal law in agreement with a definite set of procedural regulations and restrictions....   [tags: Criminal Justice ]

Powerful Essays
1038 words (3 pages)

Criminal Investigations Essay

- Criminal Investigations are ways that crimes are looked at and criminals arrested (In Encyclopædia Britannica, 2011). It is a huge part of getting criminals off the street. Investigation is a crucial aspect for many different crimes such as, but not limited to, theft, robbery, burglary, arson, murder, and assault. Criminal Investigations can take days or up to many years to solve; some cases are never closed. Not only can investigations last for extended periods of time, the lives of those working on such cases can be put in danger....   [tags: Importance, Procedure, DNA]

Powerful Essays
1093 words (3.1 pages)