Dr. Szde Yu
28 September, 2016
It has been often debated in the criminal justice field if a harsher punishment helps with deterring crime. Many studies have been conducted over the years to test how accurate this statement is. There were particularly three specific studies that looked into this concept. Many of which looked into how different factors could possibly have an impact. The results showed that there was several different point of views when it came to this specific topic.
In the 1983 study conducted by William Samuel and Elizabeth Moulds, it was revealed that there was an agreement among a widespread group of people on the topic of fair punishment for certain crimes. This study was a statewide survey involving 753 residents in the state if California. All of the people selected were 18 years and older, and were chosen randomly based on their telephone numbers. This study was conducted by professional telephone interviewers over a period of nine days. The residents were asked a series of questions involving different crimes and punishment options. The results showed that a majority of the recommend sentences made by the residents were less severe than the California Penal Code (Samuel and Moulds, 939). The researchers also looked at the different demographics within the group in order to determine if that had any effect on the results. They found that age and race did have an impact on the crime variables. The overall conclusion of the results was that most people concur on the severity of criminal offenses in efforts to help prevent crime. This study is considered to be exploratory research, since it is identifying qualitative data on a particular group. Since the results were collected...
... middle of paper ...
...ate a public debate, even though many “experts” do not believe harsh punishments help prevent any future crime.
These studies looked at different components that could have had an effect on the results. The first study found that certain variables did have an impact on the results. That most of participants did defend harsher punishment since it does deter crime. The second study attempted to explain why people believe harsher penalizations on crimes was the best route to take. They found that many people’s beliefs were driven by the concept of deterrence. The last article looked at the different opinions of an elite group of experts in the criminal justice field. It was concluded that harsher punishment does not prevent any future crime. This topic is constantly being studied due to the varying viewpoints, since many factors could play a key role in one’s opinion.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- When a child is bad, he or she gets some type of punishment, for example when one lies or cheats on a test. They will get a consciousness/ punishment of not being able to watch television or being as how cheating on a test is a more severe wrong than their punishment will be worse. Depending on what the child did wrong or bad the punishment will depend on how severe the consequence will be, because when an actual crime is done, then what would be the punishment if a small crime gets all the attention when it really does not need to be.... [tags: Crime, Criminal justice, Prison, Criminology]
1630 words (4.7 pages)
- Using pertinent theories of juvenile delinquency, this policy proposal will first highlight areas in the Illinois Juvenile Justice system that are in need of updates and modifications and secondly identify specific changes to be made in the current system. Through the application of rational choice, social control and strain theories along with an analysis of current research in the field, the submitted proposal will present one key policy change that may further reduce the number of juvenile delinquents both now and in the future.... [tags: pertinent theories of juvenile delinquency]
2147 words (6.1 pages)
- Before Antoine Dodson was on Oprah and had a song on iTunes, he was merely a man who was worried for his sister. One night, Antoine woke up to the sound of his sister screaming for help. Upon further investigation, he discovered that a rapist had broken into his apartment (“Antoine Dodson warns a perp”). Unfortunately, Antoine Dodson’s story is not a completely uncommon one in the United States. Every two minutes, someone in the United States is sexually assaulted (“Rape Abuse and Incest National Network”).... [tags: Sex Crimes]
1786 words (5.1 pages)
- Society has long since operated on a system of reward and punishment. That is, when good deeds are done or a person behaves in a desired way they SP are rewarded, or conversely punished when behaviour does not meet the societal norms. Those who defy these norms and commit crime are often punished by organized governmental justice systems through the use of penitentiaries, where prisoners carry out their sentences. The main goals of sentencing include deterrence, safety of the public, retribution, rehabilitation, punishment and respect for the law (Government of Canada, 2013).... [tags: Canadian Justice System]
3232 words (9.2 pages)
- Look around and you’re guarenteed to see some type of crime. Whether it’s as simple as someone speeding or as severe as a shooting its happeneing and its nonstop. However the question that might never be solved is why does it happen and what drives people to do what we have been told our whole lives is wrong. During this semster we have learned the different types of theories as to why crime occurs. Growing up I always felt strongly that people chose to do bad and too this day I stand by this belief.... [tags: Crime, Criminology, Criminal justice]
1088 words (3.1 pages)
- Shame punishments should be implemented in the Justice system. Because we waste so many tax dollars for locking up small-time offenders, we should use shame to save money and make the system more helpful for those who are in it. Punishing by shame can be effective through many forms, such as, community service or participating in an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting to overcome drinking problems. Shame makes the punishment more personal to the offender and creates a solution that is best for society.... [tags: Prison, Criminal justice, Crime, Punishment]
907 words (2.6 pages)
- Although this is a fictional story, we have seen a more common occurrence of school shootings throughout the United States during our lifetime. Even though many people believe that we should enforce life imprisonment for death row inmates crimes, stricter enforcement of capital punishment laws within the United States should be pursued because 1. People on death row are rarely innocent and have a substantial amount of evidence convicting them. 2. It will lower the crime rate on crimes punishable by death.... [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Murder, Death row]
2186 words (6.2 pages)
- Crime and its punishment are the responsibility of the criminal justice system. The system helps define what punishment is appropriate for which crime. The criminal justice system is in place to ensure that criminal laws are being adhered to according to the law. This judicial function is responsible for making sentences for those who are convicted for committing crimes. There are four traditional goals of punishment which are: retribution, deterrence, incapacitation (incarceration), and rehabilitation.... [tags: Crime, Criminal law, Criminal justice, Punishment]
724 words (2.1 pages)
- Technology has been becoming bigger and bigger into the field of Criminal Justice. It is almost essential for every part of the field to use technology now. The use of cars, internet, weapons, alternative methods and a lot more have made this field way more effective. Without technology this field would be nothing now a days. It has influenced the whole entire field and is going to continue to change forever. Technology has forever changed how criminal justice functions now. Police departments are changing how they operate because of it.... [tags: Police, Crime, Constable, Criminal justice]
1133 words (3.2 pages)
- Rapists in Arkansas Should Receive Harsher Punishment Many families of rapists or sexual offenders believe they are punished to harshly because they are never given the chance to attend services like counseling to better themselves before being punished as a major criminal. Many families of rape victims and other citizens believe a rapist goes nearly free compared to what the victim goes through, and believe it is unfair. Although it is true that offenders don’t get the chance to better themselves before being convicted as a hard felon, they should be convicted even harsher and differently than they already are in Arkansas because: they cause their victims to go through a lifetime full of p... [tags: sexual offender, rate, crime, law, victims, felony]
1141 words (3.3 pages)